STEELWORK / CON4334
Crash course · Section B

Columns: classify → section check → two buckling formulas

The column question has the most fixed procedure: classify, do one “section” formula, then two “buckling” formulas. Each formula adds up a few fractions; if the total is ≤ 1 it passes. The only difficulty is knowing which number goes where.

What does this question test? Always examined

A long column bows sideways before it crushes
Push a long ruler from both ends: it does not crush, it bows sideways first.
Part (2024)MarksWhat to do
(a)4section classification
(b)7cross-section capacity
(c)19member buckling: two interaction formulas

Concept map

Column buckling: why a long column bows out before it crushes

The column question’s LEL_E, λ\lambda, strut curves and pcp_c all come from one idea: a column is never perfectly straight, and compression makes the bow grow. This map links those words.

Text version (from cause to result)

  1. What changes it

    How the ends are held

    Fixed ends make bowing harder than pinned ends. A pin symbol means free to rotate, not free to sway.

  2. How design deals with it

    A tie in the weak direction

    A tie at mid-height in the weak direction can halve the weak-axis effective length and raise the capacity without changing the section — but only in the direction it actually holds.

    A mid-height tie halves the weak-axis effective length
  3. Cause

    FF Axial compression

    The column carries the compression coming down from the floors above.

  4. Cause

    No column is perfectly straight

    Real columns have an initial bow. Design assumes it from L/550L/550 (curve a₀) to L/200L/200 (curve d), depending on the strut curve.

    Source: Introduction lecture §14: imperfections

  5. What changes itWhere marks are lost

    LE=K LL_E=K\,L Effective length

    Turns the end conditions into an equivalent buckling length. For both ends fixed use the lecture’s recommended 0.7 (not the theoretical 0.5). If the question gives the effective length, use it.

  6. What changes it

    r=I/Ar=\sqrt{I/A} Radius of gyration: how far the steel sits from the axis

    The further the steel is spread from the axis, the larger rr and the harder it is to bow. Each section has two: a large rxr_x and a small ryr_y.

  7. Key idea

    Compression makes the bow grow

    The compression acts through the bow and adds a moment that bends the column further — the member’s P–δ effect.

    Source: P–Δ and P–δ concept map

  8. Key ideaWhere marks are lost

    λ=LE/r\lambda=L_E/r Slenderness: how slender it is

    Combines length and stockiness into one number. The larger λ\lambda, the easier it buckles. Work it out for each axis separately.

  9. Result

    pc<pyp_c<p_y It buckles before it crushes

    A long slim column fails sideways before the steel yields, so its design strength pcp_c is below pyp_y; the more slender, the smaller pcp_c. Only a short stocky column gets close to crushing (pc≈pyp_c\approx p_y).

    A long column bows sideways before it crushes
  10. What changes it

    Section shape → strut curve a/b/c/d

    Sections of different shape and thickness are more or less sensitive to imperfections, hence four curves. UC: b about xx, c about yy; UB: a about xx, b about yy. The curve does not depend on the steel grade.

  11. How design deals with it

    Pc=A pcP_c=A\,p_c Read p_c, the weaker axis governs

    Interpolate pcp_c in Table 8.8 with λ\lambda, using the right curve and pyp_y column, then multiply by the area for PcP_c. Do both axes; the smaller governs. Worked numbers: column calculation map.

  12. Exam answerWhere marks are lost

    Exam: both axes, both curves

    Write λx,λy\lambda_x,\lambda_y, which curve each uses, both interpolations and both PcP_c — every line earns marks.

Tour steps

  1. 1. The cause: compression + not straight

    A real column has an initial bow; the compression acts through it and makes the bow grow.

  2. 2. Length and stockiness

    End conditions → effective length; how far the steel sits from the axis → rr; together they give λ\lambda.

  3. 3. Buckling before crushing

    That is why a long column’s design strength pcp_c is below pyp_y.

  4. 4. Curves and the table

    The section shape picks the curve; λ\lambda + curve + pyp_y column → pcp_c → PcP_c.

  5. 5. In the exam

    Two axes, two curves, two PcP_c values.

Collect all the ingredients first Always examined

Find the UC row in Data File p.11 and copy:

SymbolUsed for
TT → pyp_ydesign strength (S355 uses 345 if the flange is thicker than 16 mm)
b/T,  d/tb/T,\;d/tclassification
AA (cm²)AgpyA_gp_y and Pc=ApcP_c=Ap_c
rx,  ryr_x,\;r_y (cm)slenderness λ=LE/r\lambda=L_E/r
Zx,Zy,Sx,SyZ_x,Z_y,S_x,S_y (cm³)moment capacities
u,  xu,\;xλLT\lambda_{LT} for LTB

The question usually gives: the design compression FF, the effective length LEL_E, the top and bottom moments, the amplification factors, and a separately amplified MLTM_{LT}.

The method Always examined

  1. (a) Classify

    ε=275/py\varepsilon=\sqrt{275/p_y}. Flange b/T≤9εb/T\le9\varepsilon → Class 1. The web is also compressed; the safest rule: if d/t≤40εd/t\le40\varepsilon it is Class 1 whatever the axial force (a UC web has d/td/t around 20, so it always passes).

  2. Amplify the moments (once only)

    Mx,amp=factor×Mx,max⁡My,amp=factor×My,max⁡M_{x,\text{amp}}=\text{factor}\times M_{x,\max}\qquad M_{y,\text{amp}}=\text{factor}\times M_{y,\max}

    The separately given MLTM_{LT} is already amplified — do not multiply it again.

  3. (b) Cross-section capacity: is one slice strong enough?

    FAgpy+Mx,ampMcx+My,ampMcy≤1\frac{F}{A_gp_y}+\frac{M_{x,\text{amp}}}{M_{cx}}+\frac{M_{y,\text{amp}}}{M_{cy}}\le1Mcx=min⁡(pySx,  1.2pyZx)Mcy=min⁡(pySy,  1.2pyZy)M_{cx}=\min(p_yS_x,\;1.2p_yZ_x)\qquad M_{cy}=\min(p_yS_y,\;1.2p_yZ_y)

    For a UC the minor axis is almost always limited by 1.2pyZy1.2p_yZ_y; do not use pySyp_yS_y alone.

  4. Slenderness and compressive strength pcp_c (both axes)

    λx=LExrxλy=LEyry\lambda_x=\frac{L_{Ex}}{r_x}\qquad\lambda_y=\frac{L_{Ey}}{r_y}
    Section (thickness ≤ 40 mm)curve about xxcurve about yy
    rolled H-section (UC)bc
    rolled I-section (UB)ab

    Interpolate pcp_c in Table 8.8 using the right curve and the right pyp_y column. Then Pcx=Apcx/10P_{cx}=Ap_{cx}/10 and Pcy=Apcy/10P_{cy}=Ap_{cy}/10 (with AA in cm², the answer is in kN). Pc=min⁡(Pcx,Pcy)P_c=\min(P_{cx},P_{cy}).

  5. Moment factors mx,mym_x,m_y (Table 8.9) and mLTm_{LT} (Table 8.4a)

    β=\beta= smaller end moment ÷ larger end moment. Single curvature (the column bends to one side) → β\beta positive; double curvature (S-shape) → β\beta negative.

    Table 8.9: m=0.6+0.4β  (β≥0)m=0.6+0.2β  (β<0)\text{Table 8.9: }m=0.6+0.4\beta\;(\beta\ge0)\qquad m=0.6+0.2\beta\;(\beta<0)Table 8.4a: mLT=0.6+0.4β  ≥0.44\text{Table 8.4a: }m_{LT}=0.6+0.4\beta\;\ge0.44
  6. (c-1) Interaction formula 1: compression buckling

    FPc+mx Mx,amppyZx+my My,amppyZy≤1\frac{F}{P_c}+\frac{m_x\,M_{x,\text{amp}}}{p_yZ_x}+\frac{m_y\,M_{y,\text{amp}}}{p_yZ_y}\le1

    Note: the denominators use the elastic pyZp_yZ (not SS), even for a Class 1 section.

  7. LTB bending resistance MbM_b

    λ=LEryv=1[1+0.05(λ/x)2]0.25λLT=u v λMb=pbSx\lambda=\frac{L_E}{r_y}\qquad v=\frac{1}{\left[1+0.05(\lambda/x)^2\right]^{0.25}}\qquad\lambda_{LT}=u\,v\,\lambda\qquad M_b=p_bS_x

    Interpolate pbp_b in Table 8.3a (Data File p.5) in the pyp_y column.

  8. (c-2) Interaction formula 2: compression + lateral-torsional buckling

    FPcy+mLT MLTMb+my My,firstpyZy≤1\frac{F}{P_{cy}}+\frac{m_{LT}\,M_{LT}}{M_b}+\frac{m_y\,M_{y,\text{first}}}{p_yZ_y}\le1

    Three small traps: the first term uses PcyP_{cy} (minor axis); MLTM_{LT} is the value given (already amplified); the last term uses the unamplified MyM_y.

Understanding map

Columns: which number goes into which of the three formulas?

The column question always follows the same steps; the only difficulty is which number goes where, because the section formula and the two buckling formulas use different denominators. Tap any box to see which formula it ends up in. The values are from 2024 BQ3 (254×254×89 UC).

Text version (in working order)

  1. From the questionWhere marks are lost

    LEL_E Effective length

    Given in the question (same for both axes). Used for the slenderness about each axis.

  2. From the tables

    rxr_x, ryr_y Radii of gyration

    One for each axis (cm), giving two slendernesses. The minor-axis ryr_y is much smaller.

    Where it comes from: Section table (cm; ×10 for mm).

  3. From the question

    MtopM_{\text{top}}, MbotM_{\text{bot}} End moments

    The top and bottom moments about both axes, clockwise positive. They give the maximum moment and the sign of β\beta.

    2024 BQ3

    x:  +75 / +45y:  +65 / −39   kN⋅mx:\;+75\,/\,+45\qquad y:\;+65\,/\,-39\;\text{ kN·m}
  4. From the tablesWhere marks are lost

    pyp_y Design strength

    The flange is T=17.3T=17.3 mm, thicker than 16 mm, so S355 gives 345. Nearly every capacity box uses it.

    Where it comes from: TT from the section table (Data File p.11) → design-strength table.

  5. From the tables

    uu, xx Buckling parameter, torsional index

    Used only for the LTB λLT\lambda_{LT}, exactly as in the beam LTB question.

    Where it comes from: Same section-table row.

  6. Worked out

    λx\lambda_x, λy\lambda_y Slenderness, both axes

    Work out both. The minor-axis λy\lambda_y is usually larger, and it is also the λ\lambda for LTB.

    Formula

    λx=LErxλy=LEry\lambda_x=\frac{L_E}{r_x}\qquad\lambda_y=\frac{L_E}{r_y}

    2024 BQ3

    4000112=35.71400065.5=61.07\frac{4000}{112}=35.71\qquad\frac{4000}{65.5}=61.07
  7. From the question

    kampk_{\text{amp}} Amplification factor

    Compression makes the column bend more, so the moments grow (P–δ). Amplify MxM_x and MyM_y once only.

  8. From the tables

    AA Area

    The area of the whole section. Used in AgpyA_gp_y and Pc=ApcP_c=Ap_c.

    Where it comes from: Section table.

  9. From the tables

    ZZ, SS Elastic and plastic moduli

    ZZ is the elastic and SS the plastic modulus (cm³), one pair per axis. The formulas use them differently: the section formula min⁡(pyS,1.2pyZ)\min(p_yS,1.2p_yZ), the buckling formulas pyZp_yZ, and MbM_b uses SxS_x.

    2024 BQ3

    Zx=1096,  Zy=379,  Sx=1224,  Sy=575 cm3Z_x=1096,\;Z_y=379,\;S_x=1224,\;S_y=575\text{ cm}^3
  10. Worked out

    Class\text{Class} (a) Section class

    ε=275/py\varepsilon=\sqrt{275/p_y}. Flange b/T≤9εb/T\le9\varepsilon and web d/t≤40εd/t\le40\varepsilon → Class 1, so the plastic modulus SS may be used.

    2024 BQ3

    ε=0.893;  b/T=7.41<8.04;  d/t=19.4<35.7  ⇒  Class 1\varepsilon=0.893;\;b/T=7.41<8.04;\;d/t=19.4<35.7\;\Rightarrow\;\text{Class 1}
  11. Worked outWhere marks are lost

    βx\beta_x, βy\beta_y End-moment ratios

    Smaller end moment ÷ larger end moment. Single curvature (bending to one side) is positive; double curvature (S-shape) is negative.

    2024 BQ3

    x:  +75,+45  same sign⇒βx=−0.6y:  +65,−39  opposite⇒βy=+0.6x:\;+75,+45\;\text{same sign}\Rightarrow\beta_x=-0.6\qquad y:\;+65,-39\;\text{opposite}\Rightarrow\beta_y=+0.6
  12. Worked out

    λLT\lambda_{LT} Equivalent slenderness

    As for beams: λ=λy\lambda=\lambda_y, vv from λ/x\lambda/x, λLT=uvλ\lambda_{LT}=uv\lambda.

    Formula

    v=1[1+0.05(λ/x)2]0.25λLT=u v λv=\frac{1}{\left[1+0.05(\lambda/x)^2\right]^{0.25}}\qquad\lambda_{LT}=u\,v\,\lambda

    2024 BQ3

    v=0.853λLT=0.85×0.853×61.07=44.29v=0.853\qquad\lambda_{LT}=0.85\times0.853\times61.07=44.29
  13. From the question

    FF Design compression

    The axial compression the column must carry (kN, factored). All three formulas start with it.

  14. From the questionWhere marks are lost

    MLTM_{LT} Given M_LT

    A separately given moment that is already amplified; used only in formula 2.

  15. Demand

    Mx,ampM_{x,\text{amp}}, My,ampM_{y,\text{amp}} Amplified moments

    The larger end moment on each axis times the factor. Used in the section formula and formula 1.

    Formula

    Mamp=kamp×Mmax⁡M_{\text{amp}}=k_{\text{amp}}\times M_{\max}

    2024 BQ3

    1.1×75=82.51.1×65=71.5 kN⋅m1.1\times75=82.5\qquad1.1\times65=71.5\text{ kN·m}
  16. CapacityWhere marks are lost

    AgpyA_gp_y Squash load

    The force that yields the whole section; used only in the section formula.

    Formula

    Agpy=A×100×py1000  (kN)A_gp_y=\frac{A\times100\times p_y}{1000}\;(\text{kN})

    2024 BQ3

    113×100×3451000=3898.5 kN\frac{113\times100\times345}{1000}=3898.5\text{ kN}
  17. CapacityWhere marks are lost

    McxM_{cx}, McyM_{cy} Section moment capacities

    Class 1 → SS may be used, capped at 1.2pyZ1.2p_yZ. Used only in the section formula.

    Formula

    Mc=min⁡(pyS,  1.2pyZ)M_c=\min(p_yS,\;1.2p_yZ)

    2024 BQ3

    Mcx=min⁡(422.28,  453.74)=422.28Mcy=min⁡(198.38,  156.91)=156.91M_{cx}=\min(422.28,\;453.74)=422.28\qquad M_{cy}=\min(198.38,\;156.91)=156.91
  18. CapacityWhere marks are lost

    PcxP_{cx}, PcyP_{cy} Compression resistance

    Interpolate pcp_c in Table 8.8 with λ\lambda, using the right curve and pyp_y column, then multiply by the area. UC: curve b about xx, curve c about yy.

    Formula

    Pc=A pc10  (kN,  A in cm2)P_c=\frac{A\,p_c}{10}\;(\text{kN},\;A\text{ in cm}^2)

    2024 BQ3

    pcx=316.9,  pcy=238.3  ⇒  Pcx=3580.5,  Pcy=2693.1 kNp_{cx}=316.9,\;p_{cy}=238.3\;\Rightarrow\;P_{cx}=3580.5,\;P_{cy}=2693.1\text{ kN}
  19. Worked out

    mxm_x, mym_y, mLTm_{LT} Moment factors

    mx,mym_x,m_y from Table 8.9; mLTm_{LT} from Table 8.4a (with βx\beta_x), not below 0.44.

    Formula

    m=0.6+0.4β  (β≥0)m=0.6+0.2β  (β<0)mLT=0.6+0.4β≥0.44m=0.6+0.4\beta\;(\beta\ge0)\quad m=0.6+0.2\beta\;(\beta<0)\qquad m_{LT}=0.6+0.4\beta\ge0.44

    2024 BQ3

    mx=0.6+0.2(−0.6)=0.48my=0.6+0.4(0.6)=0.84mLT=max⁡(0.44, 0.36)=0.44m_x=0.6+0.2(-0.6)=0.48\quad m_y=0.6+0.4(0.6)=0.84\quad m_{LT}=\max(0.44,\,0.36)=0.44
  20. CapacityWhere marks are lost

    pyZxp_yZ_x, pyZyp_yZ_y Elastic moment capacities

    The buckling formulas use the elastic pyZp_yZ as the denominator, even for a Class 1 section.

    2024 BQ3

    345×10961000=378.12345×3791000=130.76 kN⋅m\frac{345\times1096}{1000}=378.12\qquad\frac{345\times379}{1000}=130.76\text{ kN·m}
  21. Capacity

    MbM_b Buckling resistance moment

    Interpolate pbp_b in the pyp_y column of Table 8.3a and multiply by SxS_x. Used only in formula 2.

    Formula

    Mb=pbSx1000M_b=\frac{p_bS_x}{1000}

    2024 BQ3

    pb=304.1  ⇒  Mb=304.1×12241000=372.3 kN⋅mp_b=304.1\;\Rightarrow\;M_b=\frac{304.1\times1224}{1000}=372.3\text{ kN·m}
  22. Check

    (b)\text{(b)} ∑≤1\textstyle\sum\le1 Cross-section capacity

    Is one “slice” strong enough? Three fractions added together must be ≤ 1.

    Formula

    FAgpy+Mx,ampMcx+My,ampMcy≤1\frac{F}{A_gp_y}+\frac{M_{x,\text{amp}}}{M_{cx}}+\frac{M_{y,\text{amp}}}{M_{cy}}\le1

    2024 BQ3

    6503898.5+82.5422.28+71.5156.91=0.167+0.195+0.456=0.818≤1  ✓\frac{650}{3898.5}+\frac{82.5}{422.28}+\frac{71.5}{156.91}=0.167+0.195+0.456=0.818\le1\;\checkmark
  23. Check

    (c-1)\text{(c-1)} ∑≤1\textstyle\sum\le1 Formula 1: compression buckling

    Will the whole column buckle in compression? Use the smaller PcP_c of the two axes.

    Formula

    FPc+mxMx,amppyZx+myMy,amppyZy≤1\frac{F}{P_c}+\frac{m_xM_{x,\text{amp}}}{p_yZ_x}+\frac{m_yM_{y,\text{amp}}}{p_yZ_y}\le1

    2024 BQ3

    6502693.1+0.48×82.5378.12+0.84×71.5130.76=0.241+0.105+0.459=0.805  ✓\frac{650}{2693.1}+\frac{0.48\times82.5}{378.12}+\frac{0.84\times71.5}{130.76}=0.241+0.105+0.459=0.805\;\checkmark
  24. CheckWhere marks are lost

    (c-2)\text{(c-2)} ∑≤1\textstyle\sum\le1 Formula 2: compression + LTB

    The first term uses the minor-axis PcyP_{cy}; the middle term the given MLTM_{LT}; the last term the unamplified MyM_y (65).

    Formula

    FPcy+mLTMLTMb+myMypyZy≤1\frac{F}{P_{cy}}+\frac{m_{LT}M_{LT}}{M_b}+\frac{m_yM_y}{p_yZ_y}\le1

    2024 BQ3

    6502693.1+0.44×96372.3+0.84×65130.76=0.241+0.113+0.418=0.772  ✓\frac{650}{2693.1}+\frac{0.44\times96}{372.3}+\frac{0.84\times65}{130.76}=0.241+0.113+0.418=0.772\;\checkmark

Tour steps

  1. 1. Collect the ingredients

    Copy T,A,r,Z,S,u,xT,A,r,Z,S,u,x from the UC row on Data File p.11, and set pyp_y from TT.

  2. 2. (a) Classify (4 marks)

    ε\varepsilon comes from pyp_y; Class 1 means the section formula may use the plastic modulus SS.

  3. 3. Amplify the moments (once only)

    Take the larger end moment on each axis × 1.1. The separately given MLT=96M_{LT}=96 is already amplified — do not multiply again.

  4. 4. (b) Section check (7 marks)

    The denominators are AgpyA_gp_y and Mc=min⁡(pyS,1.2pyZ)M_c=\min(p_yS,1.2p_yZ).

  5. 5. Slenderness and PcP_c for both axes

    λ=LE/r\lambda=L_E/r; for a UC use curve b about xx and curve c about yy, in the 345 column. The minor axis usually governs.

  6. 6. The sign of β\beta and the mm factors

    Same sign at both ends → double curvature → negative β\beta. The mx,my,mLTm_x,m_y,m_{LT} factors follow from β\beta.

  7. 7. (c-1) Formula 1

    The denominators change to the elastic pyZp_yZ; the first term uses the smaller PcP_c.

  8. 8. MbM_b (as in the LTB question)

    λy\lambda_y with u,xu,x gives λLT\lambda_{LT}; look up pbp_b and multiply by SxS_x.

  9. 9. (c-2) Formula 2

    Seven arrows meet here — watch the three small traps: PcyP_{cy}, the given MLTM_{LT} and the unamplified MyM_y.

A column needs more than one check
A slice can be strong enough while the whole member still buckles — so the section and the member are checked separately.

Concept map

C shape or S shape? The sign of β\beta and the moment factors mm and mLTm_{LT}

Every year marks are lost on the sign of β\beta in the column question. Picture the shape the end moments bend the column into and the sign follows; then keep mm and mLTm_{LT} apart — which table and which term.

Text version (from cause to result)

  1. Cause

    MtopM_{\text{top}}, MbotM_{\text{bot}} End moments at top and bottom

    Exam papers usually give the applied top and bottom moments for each axis, clockwise positive.

  2. Key idea

    Does the column bend into a C or an S?

    Single curvature: the whole column bends to one side, like a C. Double curvature: there is a point of contraflexure in between, like an S.

  3. Result

    An S shape is much less dangerous

    A C shape matches the shape the column buckles into, so it is the most dangerous; in an S shape the two halves bend opposite ways, so buckling is harder to trigger and the equivalent moment (mm) is smaller.

    Same peak, different shape
  4. Key ideaWhere marks are lost

    β\beta End-moment ratio and its sign

    β\beta = smaller end moment ÷ larger end moment: positive for single curvature (C), negative for double curvature (S). With clockwise positive: same sign at both ends → double → negative; opposite signs → single → positive.

  5. How design deals with it

    mxm_x, mym_y Column buckling: Table 8.9

    m=0.6+0.4βm=0.6+0.4\beta (β≥0\beta\ge0); m=0.6+0.2βm=0.6+0.2\beta (β<0\beta<0). Each axis uses its own β\beta.

  6. How design deals with it

    mLTm_{LT} Lateral-torsional buckling: Table 8.4a

    mLT=0.6+0.4β≥0.44m_{LT}=0.6+0.4\beta\ge0.44, using the major-axis βx\beta_x.

  7. What changes it

    The two tables are not interchangeable

    Table 8.9 (column buckling) and Table 8.4 (LTB) differ most in double curvature, and their quarter-point formulas differ too. Decide which check it is first, then pick the table.

    Choose the check, then the factor
  8. How design deals with itWhere marks are lost

    Which term each one multiplies

    Formula 1: mxMx/pyZxm_xM_x/p_yZ_x and myMy/pyZym_yM_y/p_yZ_y. Formula 2: mLTMLT/Mbm_{LT}M_{LT}/M_b and myMy/pyZym_yM_y/p_yZ_y. The cross-section formula uses no mm.

  9. What changes it

    Simple construction: all equal 1

    For a column bent by eccentric beam reactions (simple construction), mx=my=mLT=1m_x=m_y=m_{LT}=1. See the simple-construction map.

  10. Exam answer

    Exam: give the reason for the sign

    For each axis: end moments → same or opposite sign → single or double → β\beta → mm. 2024: xx axis +75 / +45 → β=−0.6\beta=-0.6 → mx=0.48m_x=0.48; yy axis +65 / −39 → β=+0.6\beta=+0.6 → my=0.84m_y=0.84; mLT=max⁡(0.44,0.36)=0.44m_{LT}=\max(0.44,0.36)=0.44.

Tour steps

  1. 1. The end moments decide the shape

    First picture whether the column bends into a C or an S.

  2. 2. Why is an S safer?

    A C matches the buckled shape; an S has halves bending opposite ways, so mm is smaller.

  3. 3. The sign of β\beta

    C is positive, S is negative. With clockwise positive, same sign = S = negative.

  4. 4. Two tables

    Column buckling uses Table 8.9 for mx,mym_x,m_y; LTB uses Table 8.4a for mLTm_{LT} — not interchangeable.

  5. 5. Where they go

    mm appears only in the two buckling formulas; in simple construction they are all 1.

  6. 6. In the exam

    For each axis write the reason: “same / opposite sign → single / double → β\beta”.

Walkthrough: 2024 BQ3 (30 marks) Always examined

Given: 254×254×89 UC, S355, effective length 4 m, design compression 650 kN. Applied moments, clockwise positive: xx axis top +75, bottom +45 kN·m; yy axis top +65, bottom −39 kN·m. Amplification factor 1.1 for both axes; already-amplified MLT=96 kN⋅mM_{LT}=96\text{ kN·m}.

2024 BQ3 original question: list of column loads
The original question has no frame drawing, only this list of loads: axial force, top and bottom moments about both axes, amplification factors and MLTM_{LT}.

From the table (p.11): T=17.3T=17.3, b/T=7.41b/T=7.41, d/t=19.4d/t=19.4, A=113 cm2A=113\text{ cm}^2, rx=11.2r_x=11.2, ry=6.55 cmr_y=6.55\text{ cm}, Zx=1096Z_x=1096, Zy=379Z_y=379, Sx=1224S_x=1224, Sy=575 cm3S_y=575\text{ cm}^3, u=0.85u=0.85, x=14.5x=14.5.

Past-paper walkthrough

(a) Classification — 4 marks

T=17.3>16⇒py=345ε=275/345=0.893T=17.3>16\Rightarrow p_y=345\qquad\varepsilon=\sqrt{275/345}=0.893b/T=7.41<9ε=8.04  (Class 1)d/t=19.4<40ε=35.7  (Class 1)b/T=7.41<9\varepsilon=8.04\;(\text{Class 1})\qquad d/t=19.4<40\varepsilon=35.7\;(\text{Class 1})

Class 1.

Past-paper walkthrough

(b) Cross-section capacity — 7 marks

Agpy=113×100×3451000=3898.5 kNMx,amp=1.1×75=82.5My,amp=1.1×65=71.5A_gp_y=\frac{113\times100\times345}{1000}=3898.5\text{ kN}\qquad M_{x,\text{amp}}=1.1\times75=82.5\qquad M_{y,\text{amp}}=1.1\times65=71.5Mcx=min⁡(422.28,  453.74)=422.28Mcy=min⁡(198.38,  156.91)=156.91 kN⋅mM_{cx}=\min(422.28,\;453.74)=422.28\qquad M_{cy}=\min(198.38,\;156.91)=156.91\text{ kN·m}6503898.5+82.5422.28+71.5156.91=0.167+0.195+0.456=0.818≤1  ✓\frac{650}{3898.5}+\frac{82.5}{422.28}+\frac{71.5}{156.91}=0.167+0.195+0.456=0.818\le1\;\checkmark

Past-paper walkthrough

(c) Member buckling — 19 marks

Moment factors: xx axis +75 / +45, same sign → double curvature, βx=−45/75=−0.6\beta_x=-45/75=-0.6; yy axis +65 / −39, opposite signs → single curvature, βy=+0.6\beta_y=+0.6.

mx=0.6+0.2(−0.6)=0.48my=0.6+0.4(0.6)=0.84mLT=max⁡(0.44,  0.6+0.4(−0.6))=0.44m_x=0.6+0.2(-0.6)=0.48\qquad m_y=0.6+0.4(0.6)=0.84\qquad m_{LT}=\max(0.44,\;0.6+0.4(-0.6))=0.44

Compressive strength: UC → curve b about xx, curve c about yy, py=345p_y=345 column.

λx=4000112=35.71  ⇒  pcx=318+0.143×(310−318)=316.9\lambda_x=\frac{4000}{112}=35.71\;\Rightarrow\;p_{cx}=318+0.143\times(310-318)=316.9λy=400065.5=61.07  ⇒  pcy=241+0.534×(236−241)=238.3\lambda_y=\frac{4000}{65.5}=61.07\;\Rightarrow\;p_{cy}=241+0.534\times(236-241)=238.3Pcx=113×316.910=3580.5 kNPcy=113×238.310=2693.1 kN=PcP_{cx}=\frac{113\times316.9}{10}=3580.5\text{ kN}\qquad P_{cy}=\frac{113\times238.3}{10}=2693.1\text{ kN}=P_c

Interaction formula 1 (elastic denominators pyZx=378.12p_yZ_x=378.12, pyZy=130.76 kN⋅mp_yZ_y=130.76\text{ kN·m}):

6502693.1+0.48×82.5378.12+0.84×71.5130.76=0.241+0.105+0.459=0.805≤1  ✓\frac{650}{2693.1}+\frac{0.48\times82.5}{378.12}+\frac{0.84\times71.5}{130.76}=0.241+0.105+0.459=0.805\le1\;\checkmark

LTB:

λ=61.07v=[1+0.05(61.0714.5)2]−0.25=0.853λLT=0.85×0.853×61.07=44.29\lambda=61.07\qquad v=\left[1+0.05\left(\tfrac{61.07}{14.5}\right)^2\right]^{-0.25}=0.853\qquad\lambda_{LT}=0.85\times0.853\times61.07=44.29pb=317+0.858×(302−317)=304.1Mb=304.1×12241000=372.3 kN⋅mp_b=317+0.858\times(302-317)=304.1\qquad M_b=\frac{304.1\times1224}{1000}=372.3\text{ kN·m}

Interaction formula 2 (last term uses the unamplified My=65M_y=65):

6502693.1+0.44×96372.3+0.84×65130.76=0.241+0.113+0.418=0.772≤1  ✓\frac{650}{2693.1}+\frac{0.44\times96}{372.3}+\frac{0.84\times65}{130.76}=0.241+0.113+0.418=0.772\le1\;\checkmark

All three checks pass.

Full solution: 2024 BQ3.

The other version: simple construction (eccentric beam reactions) Often examined

A pinned beam can still bend its column
A reaction away from the column centre creates a lever arm.
  1. Eccentricity of each reaction

    Beam on the column flange: e=100 mm+D/2e=100\text{ mm}+D/2; beam on the column web: e=100 mm+t/2e=100\text{ mm}+t/2 (use the question’s value if one is given).

  2. Net moment

    On the same axis, reactions from opposite sides partly cancel: M=∑R eM=\sum R\,e (watch the directions).

  3. Share the moment between upper and lower columns by stiffness

    Mlower=M×Ilower/LlowerIlower/Llower+Iupper/Lupper(half each if identical)M_{\text{lower}}=M\times\frac{I_{\text{lower}}/L_{\text{lower}}}{I_{\text{lower}}/L_{\text{lower}}+I_{\text{upper}}/L_{\text{upper}}}\quad(\text{half each if identical})
  4. Accumulate the axial force

    The lower column carries the reactions from all floors above plus this floor. Sharing the moment does not reduce the axial force.

  5. Use the simplified formulas

    For simple construction mx=my=mLT=1m_x=m_y=m_{LT}=1; for LTB use λLT=0.5L/ry\lambda_{LT}=0.5L/r_y (LL = actual storey height, not the effective length). Compression still uses LE/rL_E/r.

Concept map

Simple construction: the beams are pinned, so why is the column still bent?

“Pinned” makes it easy to think the column is only compressed. But the beam reaction is off the column centre, so it bends the column. The map splits two routes: the moment is shared by stiffness; the axial force accumulates floor by floor and is not shared.

Text version (from cause to result)

  1. Cause

    Pinned beam-to-column joints

    Simple design assumes pinned beam ends that pass no continuity moment; sideways loads go to bracing or a core.

  2. Cause

    Beams pass their reactions to the column

    Each beam’s end reaction (factored) presses on the column.

  3. Key idea

    e=100+D/2e=100+D/2 The reaction is off-centre: eccentricity

    The reaction is taken 100 mm from the column face. Beam on the column flange: e=100+D/2e=100+D/2; on the column web: e=100+t/2e=100+t/2 (mm). Use the question’s value if given.

    A pinned beam can still bend its column
  4. ResultWhere marks are lost

    M=∑R eM=\sum R\,e The column is bent

    Reaction × eccentricity = moment. On the same axis, equal reactions from opposite sides cancel their moments.

  5. How design deals with it

    I/L∑I/L\tfrac{I/L}{\sum I/L} Moment shared by stiffness

    With the same section above and below, II cancels and only the lengths matter: a 3 m lower column is twice as stiff as a 6 m upper one and takes 2/3; equal lengths take half each.

  6. ResultWhere marks are lost

    F=∑RF=\sum R Axial force adds up floor by floor

    The lower column carries the reactions of every floor above plus this floor. Only the moments cancel; the axial forces all add up.

  7. How design deals with it

    Simplified formulas: m = 1

    In simple construction mx=my=mLT=1m_x=m_y=m_{LT}=1; for LTB use λLT=0.5L/ry\lambda_{LT}=0.5L/r_y with LL the actual storey height, not the effective length. Compression still uses LE/rL_E/r.

  8. Exam answer

    Exam answer order

    (1) ee for each reaction; (2) net moment ∑Re\sum Re; (3) share by I/LI/L; (4) accumulate the axial force; (5) use the formulas with m=1m=1. Example: 2023 FT BQ3.

Tour steps

  1. 1. Pinned, but the reaction is off-centre

    A pin passes no moment, but the reaction acts a distance ee from the column centre.

  2. 2. So the column bends

    M=∑ReM=\sum Re; equal reactions on opposite sides cancel.

  3. 3. Two routes, kept apart

    The moment is shared between upper and lower columns by stiffness; the axial force just adds up.

  4. 4. Use the simplified formulas

    m=1m=1, and LTB uses the actual storey height.

Examples: 2023 FT BQ3, lecture examples 3 and 4.

Where marks are usually lost Always examined

Next: try it yourself