Steelwork · Exam learning

2022–2024 · Exam-focused route

2023 BQ3 — column with biaxial bending Section B · choose 2 of 3

Complete the axial-force, section and member checks, following this paper’s moment model.

Original source: 22ENGTY006.pdf · physical page 5

Note: marks are as printed in the paper; the working is a teaching guide, not an official marking scheme.

Choose the column model first

The 2022 and 2023 papers use the same 305 × 305 × 158 UC but give the moments in different ways. 2022: the end moments are given directly, with signs — use the continuous non-sway column method. 2023 (this page): beam reactions act off-centre at a joint — use the course’s simple-construction method, share the joint moment by stiffness, and use the moment factors the paper gives.

Simple explanation — open only if needed

A short steel block may survive squeezing while a long ruler with the same cross-section bends sideways. The section check asks whether the steel at one slice is strong enough. The member checks also ask whether the whole column can buckle. Passing one does not replace the others.

Source: LectureNotes/CON4334-Data File-20260730.pdf · p.1, p.11
Ag=201 cm2=20100 mm2,rx=13.9 cm=139 mm,ry=7.90 cm=79 mmA_g=201\,\mathrm{cm^2}=20100\,\mathrm{mm^2},\quad r_x=13.9\,\mathrm{cm}=139\,\mathrm{mm},\quad r_y=7.90\,\mathrm{cm}=79\,\mathrm{mm}
Zx=2369, Zy=808, Sx=2680, Sy=1230[cm3]Z_x=2369,\ Z_y=808,\ S_x=2680,\ S_y=1230\quad[\mathrm{cm^3}]
T=25 mm, t=15.8 mm, b/T=6.22, d/t=15.6,u=0.851,x=12.5T=25\,\mathrm{mm},\ t=15.8\,\mathrm{mm},\ b/T=6.22,\ d/t=15.6,\quad u=0.851,\quad x=12.5

These are lookups from the exact UC row. The flange thickness selects the S355 design strength 345 N/mm². A is area, r radius of gyration, Z elastic modulus, S plastic modulus, T flange thickness and t web thickness. u and x are the LTB section parameters, not geometric coordinates.

BQ3(a) — axial force and moments [3 marks]

Given: central load 3,150 kN including self-weight; a 200 kN reaction at the left 200 mm offset, 700 kN above the centre at 240 mm and 450 kN below at 220 mm; all are already factored. Actual column height is 4.5 m; effective length is 4.0 m in both directions. Grade S355 and Class 1 are given. Upper and lower columns have equal stiffness; all moment factors are one and amplification is 1.1.

N=3150+200+700+450=4500 kNN=3150+200+700+450=4500\,\mathrm{kN}

The top and bottom reactions rotate about x in opposite senses, so subtract their moment contributions. The left reaction contributes about y. Convert millimetres to metres for kN·m.

Mx,joint=700(0.240)−450(0.220)=168−99=69 kN mM_{x,joint}=700(0.240)-450(0.220)=168-99=69\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
∣My,joint∣=200(0.200)=40 kN m|M_{y,joint}|=200(0.200)=40\,\mathrm{kN\,m}

Joint moment is shared in proportion to column stiffness. Equal upper/lower stiffness gives one half to the column under consideration. The axial force is not halved: the lower column carries the sum of the incoming vertical loads.

η=KlowerKupper+Klower=KK+K=12\eta=\frac{K_{lower}}{K_{upper}+K_{lower}}=\frac{K}{K+K}=\frac12
Mx=69/2=34.5 kN m,My=40/2=20 kN mM_x=69/2=34.5\,\mathrm{kN\,m},\quad M_y=40/2=20\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
M^x=1.1(34.5)=37.95 kN m,M^y=1.1(20)=22 kN m,MLT=37.95 kN m\widehat M_x=1.1(34.5)=37.95\,\mathrm{kN\,m},\quad\widehat M_y=1.1(20)=22\,\mathrm{kN\,m},\quad M_{LT}=37.95\,\mathrm{kN\,m}

BQ3(b) — cross-section capacity [8 marks]

Source: LectureNotes/Ch4_Column.pdf · p.14, p.20

The cross-section check combines axial compression and two bending components at one section. Use amplified moments, gross compression resistance and the Class 1 capped plastic bending resistances. Every ratio must be dimensionless.

NRd=Agpy/1000=20100(345)/1000=6934.5 kNN_{Rd}=A_gp_y/1000=20100(345)/1000=6934.5\,\mathrm{kN}
Mcx=min⁡(345(2680),1.2(345)(2369))/1000=min⁡(924.6,980.766)=924.6 kN mM_{cx}=\min(345(2680),1.2(345)(2369))/1000=\min(924.6,980.766)=924.6\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
Mcy=min⁡(345(1230),1.2(345)(808))/1000=min⁡(424.35,334.512)=334.512 kN mM_{cy}=\min(345(1230),1.2(345)(808))/1000=\min(424.35,334.512)=334.512\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
NAgpy+M^xMcx+M^yMcy=45006934.5+37.95924.6+22334.512=0.755741≤1\frac{N}{A_gp_y}+\frac{\widehat M_x}{M_{cx}}+\frac{\widehat M_y}{M_{cy}}=\frac{4500}{6934.5}+\frac{37.95}{924.6}+\frac{22}{334.512}=0.755741\le1

The section check passes. About the minor axis the elastic cap controls — using the plastic value without the cap would overestimate the resistance.

BQ3(c) — member buckling [19 marks]

Source: LectureNotes/CON4334-Data File-20260730.pdf · p.7, p.8

For the rolled UC with flange thickness below 40 mm, choose strut curve b about x and curve c about y. Effective length divided by the corresponding radius gives slenderness. Use the 345 N/mm² column of each curve’s compression-strength table.

λx=LEx/rx=4000/139=28.776978,λy=LEy/ry=4000/79=50.632911\lambda_x=L_{Ex}/r_x=4000/139=28.776978,\quad\lambda_y=L_{Ey}/r_y=4000/79=50.632911

Choose Data File p.8, curve b. Interpolate between the two surrounding slenderness rows in the same design-strength column; do not mix columns.

pcx=332+28.776978−2530−25(325−332)=326.71223  N/mm2p_{cx}=332+\frac{28.776978-25}{30-25}(325-332)=326.71223\;\mathrm{N/mm^2}

Choose Data File p.8, curve c. Interpolate between the two surrounding slenderness rows in the same design-strength column; do not mix columns.

pcy=268+50.632911−5052−50(263−268)=266.417722  N/mm2p_{cy}=268+\frac{50.632911-50}{52-50}(263-268)=266.417722\;\mathrm{N/mm^2}
Pcx=Agpcx/1000=20100(326.71223)/1000=6566.915827 kNP_{cx}=A_gp_{cx}/1000=20100(326.71223)/1000=6566.915827\,\mathrm{kN}
Pcy=20100(266.417722)/1000=5354.996203 kNP_{cy}=20100(266.417722)/1000=5354.996203\,\mathrm{kN}
Pc=min⁡(Pcx,Pcy)=5354.996203 kNP_c=\min(P_{cx},P_{cy})=5354.996203\,\mathrm{kN}
Source: LectureNotes/Ch4_Column.pdf · p.19, p.20

All three moment factors are given as one. The simple-construction LTB rule uses half the ACTUAL column height divided by the minor-axis radius. The 4,000 mm effective length belongs to compression slenderness, not this rule.

mx=my=mLT=1,λLT=0.5L/ry=0.5(4500)/79=28.481013m_x=m_y=m_{LT}=1,\quad\lambda_{LT}=0.5L/r_y=0.5(4500)/79=28.481013
Source: LectureNotes/CON4334-Data File-20260730.pdf · p.5

Choose Data File p.5, Table 8.3, 345 N/mm² column. Interpolate between the two surrounding slenderness rows in the same design-strength column; do not mix columns.

pb=345+28.481013−2530−25(345−345)=345  N/mm2p_b=345+\frac{28.481013-25}{30-25}(345-345)=345\;\mathrm{N/mm^2}
Mb=pbSx/1000=345(2680)/1000=924.6 kN mM_b=p_bS_x/1000=345(2680)/1000=924.6\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
Source: LectureNotes/Ch4_Column.pdf · p.20

For the member interaction equations, the course uses ELASTIC section bending resistances. These are different from the capped plastic resistances used in the section check. The first member equation uses the smaller compression resistance and amplified moments.

Mex=pyZx/1000=345(2369)/1000=817.305 kN mM_{ex}=p_yZ_x/1000=345(2369)/1000=817.305\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
Mey=pyZy/1000=345(808)/1000=278.76 kN mM_{ey}=p_yZ_y/1000=345(808)/1000=278.76\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
ηflex=NPc+mxM^xMex+myM^yMey\eta_{flex}=\frac{N}{P_c}+\frac{m_x\widehat M_x}{M_{ex}}+\frac{m_y\widehat M_y}{M_{ey}}
ηflex=45005354.996203+1(37.95)817.305+1(22)278.76=0.965691≤1\eta_{flex}=\frac{4500}{5354.996203}+\frac{1(37.95)}{817.305}+\frac{1(22)}{278.76}=0.965691\le1

The second member equation combines minor-axis compression buckling with major-axis LTB. It uses MLT as stated above and the first-order minor-axis moment (the barred moment in the course summary). Do not insert the amplified minor-axis moment again.

ηLT=NPcy+mLTMLTMb+myM‾yMey\eta_{LT}=\frac{N}{P_{cy}}+\frac{m_{LT}M_{LT}}{M_b}+\frac{m_y\overline M_y}{M_{ey}}
ηLT=45005354.996203+1(37.95)924.6+1(20)278.76=0.953128≤1\eta_{LT}=\frac{4500}{5354.996203}+\frac{1(37.95)}{924.6}+\frac{1(20)}{278.76}=0.953128\le1

Both member checks pass (with ex and ey taken from the drawing, as noted at the start of this question).

Compact exam script

Reveal the exam script
N=4500 kN,M^x=37.95 kN m,M^y=22 kN mN=4500\,\mathrm{kN},\quad\widehat M_x=37.95\,\mathrm{kN\,m},\quad\widehat M_y=22\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
ηsection=0.755741,ηflex=0.965691,ηLT=0.953128\eta_{section}=0.755741,\quad\eta_{flex}=0.965691,\quad\eta_{LT}=0.953128

All are below one under the stated interpretation. Give the table brackets, moment factors and source qualification in the script.

Common mistakes

  • Never interchange elastic and plastic modulus denominators between section and member checks.
  • Only joint moment is shared between upper/lower columns; axial load is not halved.
  • For the 2023 simple model, LTB uses 4.5 m actual height, compression uses 4.0 m effective length.

Procedure for a new variant

  1. Determine the construction model, axes and signs.
  2. Separate first-order, amplified and LTB moments.
  3. Look up both strut curves and the applicable LTB strength.
  4. Perform section and both member equations; state conditions.

Independent self-check — invented variant

Invented variant: in the 2023 joint, the lower column is twice as stiff as the upper. What changes before any strength check?

Hint

Use lower stiffness divided by total stiffness.

Answer and reasoning
η=2/(1+2)=2/3,Mx=69(2/3)=46,My=40(2/3)=26.666667[kN m]\eta=2/(1+2)=2/3,\quad M_x=69(2/3)=46,\quad M_y=40(2/3)=26.666667\quad[\mathrm{kN\,m}]
M^x=50.6,M^y=29.333333[kN m],N=4500 kN\widehat M_x=50.6,\quad\widehat M_y=29.333333\quad[\mathrm{kN\,m}],\quad N=4500\,\mathrm{kN}

All interaction ratios must be recalculated. The load share is based on stiffness; equal halves would now be wrong.