Tutorial 4 Q4: eccentric roof reactions in simple construction
Check the roof-storey S355 section using simple construction: UC. . First-order ultimate loads: concentric , eccentric at , eccentric at . All moment amplification factors are .
Original source: LectureNotes/Ch 4_Column.pdf — p. 40.
A given value comes from the question or diagram.
A lookup value comes from the named table.
A calculated value follows from the working.
Each assumption is stated where the calculation needs it.
Known information, diagram labels and unknowns
Find which plate buckles first
Before using plastic bending resistance, check whether the flange and web can sustain the required stress distribution.
Prediction, then explanation. At fixed width, a thinner plate has a larger width-to-thickness ratio. Local buckling then becomes more restrictive.
Calculate the flange and web ratios separately. Compare each with the limits for its stress condition. The worse class governs.
py is the design yield strength in N/mm². ε is a dimensionless scale used in the supplied classification limits.
Scope. Pure bending and uniform compression use different web limits. Class 2 allows plastic resistance but not the Class 1 rotation capability.
Check and takeaway. A Class 1 web and Class 2 flange give a Class 2 section. Do not average the class numbers.
Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion
A beam has enough local bending resistance. Check whether its compression flange can move sideways and twist.
Prediction, then explanation. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.
Identify the compressed flange and effective restraints. Calculate the specified slenderness, read buckling strength and compare resistance with the segment demand.
LE and ry use the same length unit. pb uses N/mm²; Sx uses mm³; Mb uses N·mm. mLT is dimensionless.
Scope. Use the specified section class, effective-length branch and loading condition. Load height alone does not prove a destabilizing case.
Check and takeaway. Removing a lateral restraint requires a new segment stability check. The old shorter-segment result cannot establish the longer segment’s adequacy.
A force couple carries moment
Separate the force couple used to carry moment from the force used to carry web shear.
Prediction, then explanation. For the same moment, a larger lever arm requires a smaller couple force. It does not remove the web shear.
Moment is force multiplied by perpendicular separation. Divide the required moment by the specified separation to obtain each couple force.
M is moment in kN·mm; z is the specified force-line separation in mm; F is force in kN.
Scope. Use the lever arm defined by the source model. Do not silently replace it with overall section depth or another geometric distance.
Check and takeaway. Check flange welds for the couple forces and web welds for the stated shear model. Both force paths need a satisfactory detail.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Lookup: Data File p.11, exact row UC.
Read the dimensions/local ratios table and the properties table separately.
The axis crosses the web horizontally; passes vertically through its centre in the table sketch.
| Property | Value and units |
|---|---|
| Flange/web/root-to-root web depth | 、、。 |
| Local slenderness | 、。 |
| Radii (converted from ) | ;。 |
| Area | 。 |
| Elastic moduli | ;。 |
| Plastic moduli | ;。 |
| LTB parameters | , . Both dimensionless |
Why this method applies
An eccentric beam reaction bends the column
A simple beam joint delivers a vertical reaction away from the column centre. Find the resulting column moments.
Prediction, then explanation. Equal opposite-face reactions can cancel a joint moment. Their downward forces still add to column compression.
Sum axial forces first. Calculate the signed eccentric moments. Share the net joint moment between upper and lower columns using the stated stiffness model.
R is reaction; e is perpendicular eccentricity. K denotes the stiffness measure prescribed for moment sharing.
Scope. Equal sharing requires equal stated stiffness. Use actual storey length where the special simple-construction LTB rule requires it.
Check and takeaway. A pin-like beam connection can still cause an eccentric reaction moment in the column. Joint rotation and reaction location are separate facts.
Moment shape matters within one segment
Represent a nonuniform moment distribution in the applicable member-buckling equation.
Prediction, then explanation. Two segments can have equal peak moment but different distributions. Their equivalent moment factors can therefore differ.
Evaluate moments from the true whole-beam analysis at the required positions. Apply the exact table’s weights, signs and lower bound.
mLT is an LTB factor. mx and my belong to the specified flexural checks. They are not interchangeable.
Scope. Some rules use magnitudes; others require signed ordinates. A factor does not reduce the actual moment used in a local section check.
Check and takeaway. Measure quarter points from the segment start, not automatically from the beam’s left support.
Use the same mechanism: Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Sum every vertical load for compression, but use each force’s perpendicular lever arm for its bending axis.
A roof joint has no upper column to share moment with in this stated model.
Simple construction fixes the moment factors to and provides the special 0.5L/rᵧ LTB rule.
1. Axial force, moments and classification
Follow one strip of floor
An area load must become a beam load before beam reactions can be calculated.
Prediction, then explanation. At fixed area load, twice the tributary width gives twice the line load. An end reaction remains a concentrated force.
Consider one metre along the beam. The associated floor area is b square metres. Multiply area load by that width.
q is area load in kN/m²; b is tributary width in m; w is line load in kN/m.
Scope. Determine b from slab spanning and supports. Add beam self-weight separately. A secondary-beam reaction is not automatically a UDL.
Check and takeaway. Illustration: . The width cancels one length unit.
Use the same mechanism: An eccentric beam reaction bends the column. Equal opposite-face reactions can cancel a joint moment. Their downward forces still add to column compression.
Compression acts on the displaced shape
A compressed member moves away from its initial load line. Explain why the bending moment can increase.
Prediction, then explanation. At fixed axial force, a larger offset creates a larger additional moment. This can further increase the displacement.
Force acting through an offset forms a moment. Second-order analysis includes that changed geometry in equilibrium.
P is axial force. Δ and δ are the relevant perpendicular displacements. Consistent force and length units give moment units.
Scope. Use the amplification or analysis method stated for the frame. Do not amplify an already amplified moment a second time.
Check and takeaway. Zero offset removes this additional moment in the ideal sketch. Real design may still require imperfections and code checks.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Physical interpretation: How a floor load reaches a beam
Each beam collects the load from its own strip of floor.
Sketch, not to scale; use the original dimensions.
- Find the tributary width from the actual plan.
- Area load × tributary width gives load per beam length.
- A supporting beam receives the other beam’s end reaction.
Remember: A reaction becomes a point load, not automatically a UDL.
The lecture’s Class 1 combined-stress web limit cannot be below because .
This check therefore avoids an unjustified plastic classification while remaining conservative.
The flange is checked independently.
Mechanism detailsFollow the floor load in 3D
The complete mechanism is explained below.
Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.
The floor carries pressure in .
The highlighted strip belongs to one secondary beam.
Multiply pressure by tributary width: .
The illustration uses .
- A primary beam receives the secondary beam reaction at their connection, not a new full-span UDL.
Trace reactions down to columns and foundations.
Count each loaded area once.
2. Check the section
A strong cross-section can belong to an unstable member
A column carries axial compression and bending. Explain why more than one check is required.
Prediction, then explanation. At fixed moments and resistances, increasing compression increases utilisation. A section pass cannot remove the length-dependent instability checks.
Separate cross-section, flexural-buckling and LTB interaction equations. Use each equation’s own denominators and first-order or amplified moments.
is a section axial resistance. is a member compression resistance. Elastic and prescribed are different bending denominators.
Scope. Preserve the course barred-moment definitions and Eq. 8.81 convention. Do not substitute plastic moduli into an elastic denominator.
Check and takeaway. Report each requested utilisation and the governing check. The largest properly calculated ratio identifies the closest limit.
Use the same mechanism: Compression acts on the displaced shape. At fixed axial force, a larger offset creates a larger additional moment. This can further increase the displacement.
Two simultaneous actions use one component
Check a component that carries shear and tension, or compression and bending, at the same time.
Prediction, then explanation. At fixed resistances, increasing one demand increases its utilisation. The permitted sum is not always one.
First apply the individual checks. Next use the exact combined equation and its definitions. Keep demands from the same load case.
This is the course bolt interaction rule. Fs and Ft are bolt demands; Ps and Pnom are their specified resistance denominators.
Scope. The 1.4 limit and nominal tension denominator do not apply to column equations. Their limits and moment definitions are separate.
Check and takeaway. A sum above one can pass this bolt rule while still needing individual checks. A pass must name the actual equation used.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
At a cross section, compression and bending share the material.
Use amplified moments and capped plastic resistances.
The total must not exceed ; all terms below are dimensionless.
Mechanism detailsA strong slice can belong to an unstable member
The complete mechanism is explained below.
Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.
- Combine axial compression and the two bending demands using the specified section resistances.
- The whole member adds effective-length and buckling-curve effects.
This uses its own moment factor and bending resistance.
It is not a copy of the section check.
Elastic, plastic and buckling resistances are not interchangeable.
Read the three original expressions and their first-order/amplified moments.
3. Axial and flexural member resistance
Use the same mechanism: A strong cross-section can belong to an unstable member. At fixed moments and resistances, increasing compression increases utilisation. A section pass cannot remove the length-dependent instability checks.
Check buckling about both axes
Determine which buckling direction limits the compressed member.
Prediction, then explanation. At fixed radius, longer effective length raises slenderness. The supplied buckling curve generally gives lower compressive strength.
Calculate slenderness about each axis. Select each axis’s curve from section type and thickness. Then obtain and compare the two compressive resistances.
Effective lengths and radii use mm. pc is compressive strength in N/mm²; Ag is gross area in mm²; Pc is in N.
Scope. Do not select the governing axis using radius alone. Effective length and buckling curve can differ. A combined column also needs interaction checks.
Check and takeaway. A short-section yield resistance is not the same as long-member buckling resistance. Keep py and pc distinct.
Use the same mechanism: Two simultaneous actions use one component. At fixed resistances, increasing one demand increases its utilisation. The permitted sum is not always one.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Physical interpretation: The column needs more than one pass
A slice can be strong while the whole member still buckles.
Sketch, not to scale; use the original dimensions.
- Check cross-section compression plus bending.
- Then check the separate member-buckling expressions.
- Keep each moment, factor and resistance in its specified expression.
Remember: The three checks do not share interchangeable denominators.
Table 8.7: hot-rolled H-section (UC), maximum thickness , about the use curve b; about use curve c.
Read the Data File p.8 column.
The two axes use different curves, so slenderness alone cannot determine the governing axis.
Member interaction uses elastic moment denominators pᵧZ, even when the cross-section check used plastic moduli.
Use amplified moments here.
Mechanism detailsA strong slice can belong to an unstable member
The complete mechanism is explained below.
Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.
- Combine axial compression and the two bending demands using the specified section resistances.
- The whole member adds effective-length and buckling-curve effects.
This uses its own moment factor and bending resistance.
It is not a copy of the section check.
Elastic, plastic and buckling resistances are not interchangeable.
Read the three original expressions and their first-order/amplified moments.
4. Simple-construction LTB and conclusion
Use the same mechanism: A strong cross-section can belong to an unstable member. At fixed moments and resistances, increasing compression increases utilisation. A section pass cannot remove the length-dependent instability checks.
Use the same mechanism: Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.
Use the same mechanism: Two simultaneous actions use one component. At fixed resistances, increasing one demand increases its utilisation. The permitted sum is not always one.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Physical interpretation: A beam can escape sideways
The compressed flange can move sideways while the section twists.
Sketch, not to scale; use the original dimensions.
- Divide the beam at effective lateral restraints.
- Use each segment’s effective length to obtain its buckling resistance.
- Compare that resistance with the segment’s equivalent moment demand.
Remember: A section bending check alone does not check lateral-torsional buckling.
Simple-construction special rule: use actual storey length in 0.5L/rᵧ.
The axial effective length is a different quantity.
Read Data File p.5 Table 8.3a, pᵧ355 column:
Course Eq.8.81 uses first-order minor-axis moment in its last term.
Mᴸᵀ is the specified amplified major-axis value.
Do not amplify it twice.
The axial denominator is .
; , ; , .
.
Ratios: section , flexural buckling , axial force/LTB .
At least one required ratio exceeds .
Therefore the column is marginally O.K. (only about 3% over), as in the lecturer's answer.
Mechanism detailsA strong slice can belong to an unstable member
The complete mechanism is explained below.
Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.
- Combine axial compression and the two bending demands using the specified section resistances.
- The whole member adds effective-length and buckling-curve effects.
This uses its own moment factor and bending resistance.
It is not a copy of the section check.
Elastic, plastic and buckling resistances are not interchangeable.
Read the three original expressions and their first-order/amplified moments.
Lecturer's answer
| Item | Lecturer's value |
|---|---|
| Axial force and moments | , , |
| Section resistance | ratio |
| Buckling | , , ; ratio |
| Lateral-torsional buckling | , ; ratio |
Conclusion: The ratios are only just above 1; the lecturer accepts the column as marginally O.K.
Source: Lecturer's tutorial solution, Ch 4, pp. 6–8.
Result and concise exam wording
Use the same mechanism: Compression acts on the displaced shape. At fixed axial force, a larger offset creates a larger additional moment. This can further increase the displacement.
Use the same mechanism: An eccentric beam reaction bends the column. Equal opposite-face reactions can cancel a joint moment. Their downward forces still add to column compression.
Use the same mechanism: Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
F890 kN; first-order Mx 20.8/My 14.7; amplified /.
No roof moment sharing; all ; actualL4.5 m in λᴸᵀ=0.5L/rᵧ.
; , ; , .
.
Ratios: section , flexural buckling , axial force/LTB .
At least one required ratio exceeds .
Therefore the column is marginally O.K. (only about 3% over), as in the lecturer's answer.
Misconceptions and checks
Use the same mechanism: Compression acts on the displaced shape. At fixed axial force, a larger offset creates a larger additional moment. This can further increase the displacement.
Use the property for the physical question
A section table contains several numbers. Choose the property that matches the calculation and bending axis.
Prediction, then explanation. Moving equal area away from an axis increases I about that axis. It does not increase total area.
Each small area contributes its area multiplied by squared distance. Sum those contributions to obtain I.
I is second moment of area in mm⁴. y is distance from the chosen axis in mm. A is area in mm². r is radius of gyration in mm.
Scope. Z is elastic section modulus; S is plastic section modulus in this course. Neither is interchangeable with I.
Check and takeaway. A nominal section designation is a row identifier. Use the actual dimensions and units in that exact row.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
- Do not use for a flange thicker than .
- Do not substitute plastic moduli in the member elastic denominators.
- Do not amplify an already amplified Mᴸᵀ twice.
- Do not treat an axial resistance pass as proof of combined-load adequacy.
Reaction position along creates moment about .
The force label alone is not the moment-axis label.
- The central load adds compression but no eccentric moment.
How the method transfers to a new variant
Use the same mechanism: Compression acts on the displaced shape. At fixed axial force, a larger offset creates a larger additional moment. This can further increase the displacement.
Use the same mechanism: Find which plate buckles first. At fixed width, a thinner plate has a larger width-to-thickness ratio. Local buckling then becomes more restrictive.
Use the same mechanism: Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
- Identify construction type, axis, actual length and effective length.
Read thickness, grade and the exact UC row.
Classify before using plastic moduli.
- Sum vertical forces and derive signed eccentric moments; share moments only when the joint has two columns.
Apply specified amplification once.
Check the capped section interaction.
- Select curves / for these rolled H sections, interpolate both strengths and check flexural interaction with elastic moduli.
- Use the appropriate simple/continuous LTB slenderness rule and the course first-order minor-axis term.
- Report every utilisation and let any failed check govern.
Prediction with explained answer
Balance the isolated beam
Find the two vertical reactions before calculating internal shear or moment.
Prediction, then explanation. Move the same load toward B. Reaction B increases because the load has a larger moment arm about A.
Take moments about A. Reaction A has zero lever arm there. Then use vertical force balance to find reaction A.
P, RA and RB are forces in kN. L is support spacing and a is load position, both in m.
Scope. These expressions describe one point load on a simply supported beam. Add other loads through equilibrium; keep their actual positions.
Check and takeaway. Illustration: P = 60 kN, L = 6 m and a = 2 m give RB = 20 kN and RA = 40 kN.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Prediction and explained answer.
Invented variant: add an equal vertical reaction at the opposite position about .
What changes?
Answer and reasoning
Compression rises to .
The two reactions cancel their -axis moments, so My becomes 0; remains first-order.
It is unsafe to assume the column improves automatically: the axial term rises while the minor bending term disappears.
Recompute all three ratios.