Tutorial 2 Q7: separate flange and web weld design
Design welds connecting a bracket cut from UB S355 to a column. Ultimate vertical load is at eccentricity . Use Class 42 electrode and the question’s assumption that flange welds resist moment while web welds resist shear.
Original source: LectureNotes/Ch 2_Connection.pdf — p. 45, p. 48.
A given value comes from the question or diagram.
A lookup value comes from the named table.
A calculated value follows from the working.
Each assumption is stated where the calculation needs it.
Known information, diagram labels and unknowns
A force couple carries moment
Separate the force couple used to carry moment from the force used to carry web shear.
Prediction, then explanation. For the same moment, a larger lever arm requires a smaller couple force. It does not remove the web shear.
Moment is force multiplied by perpendicular separation. Divide the required moment by the specified separation to obtain each couple force.
M is moment in kN·mm; z is the specified force-line separation in mm; F is force in kN.
Scope. Use the lever arm defined by the source model. Do not silently replace it with overall section depth or another geometric distance.
Check and takeaway. Check flange welds for the couple forces and web welds for the stated shear model. Both force paths need a satisfactory detail.
The weld resists through its throat
Convert a visible fillet leg into resistance per effective length.
Prediction, then explanation. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
For the course right-angle equal-leg fillet, take throat as 0.7 times leg. Multiply throat area per unit length by weld strength.
s and a are leg and throat in mm. pw is weld strength in N/mm². qcap is resistance in kN/mm.
Scope. Use effective length, the correct steel/electrode strength and permitted leg limits. Full-penetration butt welds use a different model.
Check and takeaway. Illustration: a 6 mm leg at 250 N/mm² gives .
A table value has conditions
Find a design property without mixing a row, column or standard from a different case.
Prediction, then explanation. A different flange thickness can select a lower design strength even when the steel grade name remains unchanged.
Match the complete section designation. Read the relevant axis and unit. For strength tables, select material, thickness and curve before interpolating.
Given values come from the question. Lookup values come from a named table. Assumed values require an explicit condition.
Scope. A missing row or omitted restraint cannot be recovered from a schematic’s scale. Keep the result conditional when required data are absent.
Check and takeaway. Record the table, row, column and unit beside the substitution. That makes a later check possible.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
| Input | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Moment force couple | Use the source example’s overall-depth lever-arm approximation between flange force lines. |
| Flange run | One physical weld line at each flange, carrying the flange couple force. |
| Web runs | Two physical runs share direct shear. |
| Section thickness | Data File p.9 row : flange ,web . |
| Unspecified input | Column flange thickness is absent, affecting the minimum permitted weld size at the web/column joint. The strength design can be calculated; unconditional detailing depends on that thickness. |
Why this method applies
Treat a weld group as lines
An eccentric force creates direct line force and torsional line force in the same weld group.
Prediction, then explanation. Increasing eccentricity increases the torsional contribution. The governing corner depends on vector addition, not distance alone.
Find the line centroid. Integrate squared distance along the effective lines. Add direct and torsional components at every candidate critical point.
J is line polar inertia in mm³. x and y use mm. With M in kN·mm, q is line force in kN/mm.
Scope. A solid rectangle has area inertia in mm⁴ and is not this weld-line model. Missing weld sides change the centroid and integrals.
Check and takeaway. Compare the largest resultant line force with the selected throat resistance. Keep kN/mm distinct from total force in kN.
Use the same mechanism: A force couple carries moment. For the same moment, a larger lever arm requires a smaller couple force. It does not remove the web shear.
Use the same mechanism: The weld resists through its throat. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Use the stated simplified load split rather than a full elastic weld-group analysis.
Moment becomes an equal-and-opposite pair of flange forces .
The web takes the vertical shear.
Size each family of welds using its own effective length.
Because , changing the leg also changes the effective length; recheck the chosen trial.
1. Moment and flange welds
Use the same mechanism: A force couple carries moment. For the same moment, a larger lever arm requires a smaller couple force. It does not remove the web shear.
Use the same mechanism: The weld resists through its throat. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
Use the same mechanism: A table value has conditions. A different flange thickness can select a lower design strength even when the steel grade name remains unchanged.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Physical interpretation: How two flange forces make a moment
Two opposite forces form a turning pair, like two hands turning a wheel.
Sketch, not to scale; use the original dimensions.
- Identify the separation between their actual force lines.
- Required force equals moment divided by that separation.
- Design the relevant flange group for that force.
Remember: The force-line separation is not automatically the overall section depth.
Provide fillet along each flange run.
For flange edge, maximum leg permits 10.
The thicker-part minimum is at most in the supplied table, so 10 meets it even if the column flange is thicker.
Effective .
The force in each flange is .
Do not divide it by two merely because the couple has two flanges.
This force-couple idealization is explicitly tied to the lecturer’s corresponding bracket method.
A refined connection analysis would establish the actual flange force resultants.
The nominal lever arm is not a newly measured weld-centroid separation.
Mechanism detailsSeparate the moment couple and shear
The complete mechanism is explained below.
Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.
- A simplified moment connection assigns different actions to different fastener groups.
- Opposite flange forces separated by z resist moment: .
- The web fasteners or welds carry the assigned vertical shear in this model.
- Flange force, web shear, plate bearing and detailing each need their specified checks.
2. Web shear welds and detailing condition
Use the same mechanism: The weld resists through its throat. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
Use the same mechanism: A force couple carries moment. For the same moment, a larger lever arm requires a smaller couple force. It does not remove the web shear.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Physical interpretation: Why the weld throat is smaller than its leg
The shortest cut through the weld is thinner than the outside leg.
Sketch, not to scale; use the original dimensions.
- For the stated equal-leg 90° fillet, throat is approximately 0.7 × leg.
- Multiply throat area by the matching weld design strength.
- For force per length, use a one-millimetre weld strip.
Remember: Choose strength from both the steel grade and electrode class.
The web weld meets the thicker-part minimum if the column flange thickness is at most under the supplied table.
If it exceeds , the minimum would be , incompatible with the edge maximum in this edge-detail model.
A different detail would be needed.
Since column flange thickness is not stated, report as the completed strength selection with this explicit detailing condition, not an unconditional fabrication approval.
Provide any required end returns of at least where the actual joint permits; their geometry is not dimensioned here.
Mechanism detailsFrom fillet leg to effective throat
The complete mechanism is explained below.
Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.
- An equal-leg fillet between perpendicular plates has an approximately right-triangular section.
For this geometry, throat .
It is shorter than the leg.
Effective resisting area = .
With here, capacity per length is .
- Use the course end allowances, minimum size and length rules; increasing the geometric length alone does not resolve every detailing check.
Lecturer's answer
| Item | Lecturer's value |
|---|---|
| Flange welds (moment) | → |
| Web welds (shear) | → |
Conclusion: Use 10 mm fillet welds on the flanges and 6 mm fillet welds on the web.
Source: Lecturer's tutorial solution, Ch 2, p. 8.
Result and concise exam wording
Use the same mechanism: The weld resists through its throat. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
Use the same mechanism: A table value has conditions. A different flange thickness can select a lower design strength even when the steel grade name remains unchanged.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
M150 kNm; source lever arm gives flange force .
Use flange fillets on runs: effective , capacity each.
For web shear use fillets on two runs: effective each, pair capacity 688.8 kN>600.
Web minimum-size compliance remains conditional on the omitted column flange thickness ( selection permitted by the supplied minimum table only up to thicker part).
Misconceptions and checks
Use the same mechanism: A table value has conditions. A different flange thickness can select a lower design strength even when the steel grade name remains unchanged.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
- Use the given weld run rather than nominal section width.
- Each flange carries the full couple force.
- Use both web runs for shear, but deduct from each.
- Do not claim an omitted column thickness has been checked.
How the method transfers to a new variant
Use the same mechanism: A force couple carries moment. For the same moment, a larger lever arm requires a smaller couple force. It does not remove the web shear.
Use the same mechanism: The weld resists through its throat. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
- Factor loads if required, then calculate .
- Convert moment into flange force using the stated force-couple model.
- Try flange leg sizes and update each effective length.
- Size the pair of web welds for the full shear force.
- Check known maximum/minimum size and length conditions; state missing detailing inputs.
Prediction with explained answer
Use the same mechanism: A force couple carries moment. For the same moment, a larger lever arm requires a smaller couple force. It does not remove the web shear.
Use the same mechanism: The weld resists through its throat. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
Keep load categories separate
A floor carries permanent material and changing occupancy loads. Find the design load for the stated check.
Prediction, then explanation. Increasing imposed load changes its own term. It does not change the dead-load factor or the steel stiffness.
First convert mass to weight where required. Next collect G and Q in compatible units. Apply the combination specified by the course problem.
G is characteristic dead load; Q is characteristic imposed load. Wu is the design load for this course gravity combination.
Scope. This combination is not universal. Use the specified service load for deflection and the stated factors for other standards or cases.
Check and takeaway. Illustration: G = 10 kN and Q = 5 kN give 22 kN. Factoring their sum by one guessed factor loses the distinction.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Prediction and explained answer.
Invented variant: ultimate load remains but its eccentricity rises to .
Can the selected flange weld remain ?
Answer and reasoning
, above the weld resistance .
The web shear remains .
Therefore, its strength demand is unchanged.
A larger flange weld is limited by the edge maximum; even gives, still insufficient.
A changed flange weld layout/detail is needed.
Mechanism detailsSeparate the moment couple and shear
The complete mechanism is explained below.
Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.
- A simplified moment connection assigns different actions to different fastener groups.
- Opposite flange forces separated by z resist moment: .
- The web fasteners or welds carry the assigned vertical shear in this model.
- Flange force, web shear, plate bearing and detailing each need their specified checks.