Tutorial 2 Q5: double-angle weld design and a conflicting size rule
Design the welds for two unequal angles carrying ultimate tension, with their longer sides connected to a gusset. Use S355 and Class 42 electrode, and check angle tension resistance.
Original source: LectureNotes/Ch 2_Connection.pdf — p. 45, p. 47.
A given value comes from the question or diagram.
A lookup value comes from the named table.
A calculated value follows from the working.
Each assumption is stated where the calculation needs it.
Known information, diagram labels and unknowns
One connected leg does not load both legs equally
An angle carries tension through only one leg. Determine how much section area the design rule permits.
Prediction, then explanation. Keeping the same gross area does not guarantee the same tension resistance when the connection arrangement changes.
Separate connected and outstanding leg areas. Include the actual holes. Then use the supplied single-angle or double-angle effective-area rule.
Ae is the effective area from the applicable angle rule in mm². py is the relevant design strength in N/mm².
Scope. Do not assume the whole gross area is effective. Symmetry, connected leg and connection type determine which rule applies.
Check and takeaway. The outstanding leg contributes through load transfer; the rule need not either count all of it or discard all of it.
The weld resists through its throat
Convert a visible fillet leg into resistance per effective length.
Prediction, then explanation. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
For the course right-angle equal-leg fillet, take throat as 0.7 times leg. Multiply throat area per unit length by weld strength.
s and a are leg and throat in mm. pw is weld strength in N/mm². qcap is resistance in kN/mm.
Scope. Use effective length, the correct steel/electrode strength and permitted leg limits. Full-penetration butt welds use a different model.
Check and takeaway. Illustration: a 6 mm leg at 250 N/mm² gives .
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
| Input | Source/type |
|---|---|
| Angle geometry | Given , two angles. For course rectangular leg areas split the shared corner equally between the two legs. |
| Centroid | Data File p.12, row, : measured from the heel along the long leg, while . is the perpendicular coordinate. |
| Force share | Symmetric two-angle connection: each angle carries . |
| Weld resistance | The original website summary writes , whereas course weld calculations use . This explanation explicitly uses the latter. For S355/Class 42, . The strength model uses only side welds and conservatively ignores the short transverse heel-end weld shown. |
| Size limits | Thicker joined part → source minimum ; angle edge → maximum . |
Why this method applies
Unequal lever arms require unequal forces
Two longitudinal welds must transfer a tensile force through the angle centroid without an unintended moment.
Prediction, then explanation. The weld with the shorter lever arm must carry more force to balance the longer-arm weld’s moment.
Use force balance and moment balance together. Then divide each force by its own line resistance to find required effective length.
P, F₁ and F₂ are forces. z₁ and z₂ are perpendicular distances from the load line. Use consistent length units.
Scope. Equal force shares apply only to the symmetric case. Physical terminated weld length also needs the supplied end deductions.
Check and takeaway. If the two lever arms become equal, the equations return equal forces. That limiting case checks the force distribution.
Use the same mechanism: One connected leg does not load both legs equally. Keeping the same gross area does not guarantee the same tension resistance when the connection arrangement changes.
Use the same mechanism: The weld resists through its throat. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
First check whether the angle pair can carry the force after the course shear-lag reduction.
Then design unequal side-weld lengths so the weld resultant passes through each angle’s centroid.
Finally check that the chosen leg is permitted by both minimum and maximum rules.
In this particular detail those rules conflict; strength sizing alone cannot produce an acceptable final fillet-weld detail.
1. Check the two angles in tension
Use the same mechanism: One connected leg does not load both legs equally. Keeping the same gross area does not guarantee the same tension resistance when the connection arrangement changes.
A table value has conditions
Find a design property without mixing a row, column or standard from a different case.
Prediction, then explanation. A different flange thickness can select a lower design strength even when the steel grade name remains unchanged.
Match the complete section designation. Read the relevant axis and unit. For strength tables, select material, thickness and curve before interpolating.
Given values come from the question. Lookup values come from a named table. Assumed values require an explicit condition.
Scope. A missing row or omitted restraint cannot be recovered from a schematic’s scale. Keep the result conditional when required data are absent.
Check and takeaway. Record the table, row, column and unit beside the substitution. That makes a later check possible.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Physical interpretation: One connected leg does not load both legs equally
The connected leg receives the pull first.
The other leg receives it through the angle.
Sketch, not to scale; use the original dimensions.
- Identify connected and outstanding legs from the drawing.
- Use the relevant bolted or welded angle rule.
- Keep the lecturer’s area convention consistent.
Remember: Bolted and welded reduction expressions are not the same rule.
The source section table gives rounded gross area including root/toe geometry.
The course’s explicit leg-area model gives and is used consistently in this shear-lag calculation.
Do not mix the table gross area with a different corner subtraction without explaining the method.
Mechanism detailsWhy a connected angle leg matters
The complete mechanism is explained below.
Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.
- Locate the connected leg, outstanding leg and centroid before using the table.
- Only the connected leg directly receives the fastener force.
The outstanding area may not become equally effective at the same section.
This motivates the effective-area rule.
Bolted, welded, single-angle and double-angle details can have different rules.
Preserve the formula attached to the original case.
2. Balance weld forces, then expose the detailing conflict
Use the same mechanism: Unequal lever arms require unequal forces. The weld with the shorter lever arm must carry more force to balance the longer-arm weld’s moment.
Use the same mechanism: The weld resists through its throat. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Physical interpretation: Why two weld lengths can be unequal
Two side welds must balance the load about its actual line of action.
Sketch, not to scale; use the original dimensions.
- Find the load line and the lever arm to each weld.
- Balance moments as well as the total force.
- Convert each weld’s force into its own required length.
Remember: Equal-looking legs do not justify equal weld forces without equilibrium.
Name the side nearer the angle heel and the free long-leg edge .
Their transverse spacing is .
The centroid is from and from .
These are table-derived dimensions, not measured from the sketch.
For a transparent strength-only trial use fillet, the largest allowed by the source’s angle-edge maximum.
This trial will be rejected on the minimum-size condition below.
Repeat on both angles.
Effective lengths and 82 exceed and .
Both physical lengths exceed the side spacing.
Returns at least and lap at least would be required in such a trial.
Conclusion: the angles pass tension, but no fillet leg satisfies both supplied detailing rules for the stated angle/ gusset detail.
The lengths / are a strength demonstration, not an acceptable final detail.
A changed angle thickness or a separately justified alternative weld detail is required.
The task cannot be concluded by silently adopting or along a angle edge.
Gusset net width is not given, so a complete gusset tensile check also cannot be established.
Mechanism detailsBalance two weld forces
The complete mechanism is explained below.
Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.
- The angle centroid/load line is generally not halfway between the two weld runs.
.
Both weld runs contribute to the applied force.
.
The run nearer the load line carries more force.
For equal throat resistance per length, the required effective lengths follow the same ratio.
Add detailing allowances afterwards.
Lecturer's answer
| Item | Lecturer's value |
|---|---|
| Connected / outstanding leg area | , |
| Double-angle tension | |
| 6 mm weld, total length | , 167 mm per angle |
| Side X (centroid 20.4 mm from side X) | , add 2s → 130 mm |
| Side Y | , add 2s → 65 mm; 15 mm returns |
Conclusion: The angles are adequate; weld each angle with 6 mm fillets, 130 mm on side X and 65 mm on side Y, with 15 mm returns. Answer the exam this way.
Source: Lecturer's tutorial solution, Ch 2, p. 6.
Result and concise exam wording
Use the same mechanism: One connected leg does not load both legs equally. Keeping the same gross area does not guarantee the same tension resistance when the connection arrangement changes.
Use the same mechanism: The weld resists through its throat. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Double-angle tension: , , , adequate.Use 6 mm welds (): in all, 167 mm per angle.Split about the centroid (20.4 mm from side X): side X 115 mm, add 2s, use 130 mm;side Y 52 mm, add 2s, use 65 mm; 15 mm returns.(Extra remark: under the weld-size rules a 6 mm angle edge may not allow a 6 mm weld; see section 2.)
Misconceptions and checks
Count cuts through each loaded bolt
Find how many shear planes transfer the force through one side of the connection.
Prediction, then explanation. For equal sharing and unchanged bolt area, two active planes provide twice one plane’s shear resistance.
Select the area at the actual shear plane. Multiply by bolt shear strength. Count only the bolts and planes in the same transfer stage.
ps is bolt shear strength in N/mm²; As is the appropriate area in mm². nb counts bolts; ns counts equally loaded shear planes.
Scope. Use the thread area when threads cross the plane as required. Check bearing, plate failure and detailing separately.
Check and takeaway. Both halves of a butt splice carry the full transmitted force in sequence. Counting both halves together would double the apparent resistance.
Use the same mechanism: The weld resists through its throat. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
- Use per angle, not 350 per angle.
- Use the long-leg centroid coordinate , not cᵧ.
- Use the double-angle welded reduction .
- Check whether minimum and maximum weld-leg bounds overlap before declaring a design.
How the method transfers to a new variant
Use the same mechanism: Unequal lever arms require unequal forces. The weld with the shorter lever arm must carry more force to balance the longer-arm weld’s moment.
Use the same mechanism: One connected leg does not load both legs equally. Keeping the same gross area does not guarantee the same tension resistance when the connection arrangement changes.
Use the same mechanism: The weld resists through its throat. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
- Identify the connected leg and force per angle.
- Calculate the course angle tension area including the correct shear-lag reduction.
- Check the permitted weld-size interval.
- If a permissible size exists, balance side forces with centroid lever arms.
- Convert to effective lengths, add end allowances and check actual capacities/detailing.
Prediction with explained answer
Use the same mechanism: The weld resists through its throat. At fixed weld strength, doubling the leg doubles throat and line resistance in this model. Detailing limits can prevent that choice.
Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions
Prediction and explained answer.
Invented reasoning variant: would merely lengthening the welds solve the source minimum-leg problem?
Answer and reasoning
No. More length increases strength but does not change the leg.
The minimum remains .
The physical detail/material choice or an explicitly supported alternative detailing provision must change.