STEELWORK / CON4334
Worked examples

2023 BQ4: the same beam with two restraint arrangements

Diagrams, explanations and answers are presented in reading order. No playback or response is required.
All answers shownChinese–English terminology
Diagrams, explanations and answers are presented in reading order. No playback or response is required.

For a 6m simply supported 406×140×46 UB S355, assumed Class 1, carrying a central 110kN design point load and negligible self-weight: (a) find maximum shear/moment; (b) check LTB with support restraints only; (c) repeat with an additional effective midpoint lateral restraint.

Original source: Pastpaper/22ENGTY033.pdf — p. 6.

A given value comes from the question or diagram.

A lookup value comes from the named table.

A calculated value follows from the working.

Each assumption is stated where the calculation needs it.

Known information, diagram labels and unknowns

Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion

A beam has enough local bending resistance. Check whether its compression flange can move sideways and twist.

The dashed straight line is the initial reference. The curved flange lines illustrate the labelled sideways movement and twist.
The dashed straight line is the initial reference. The curved flange lines illustrate the labelled sideways movement and twist.

Prediction, then explanation. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.

Identify the compressed flange and effective restraints. Calculate the specified slenderness, read buckling strength and compare resistance with the segment demand.

λ=LE/ry,Mb=pbSx  (Class 1/2),mLTMmax≤Mb\lambda=L_E/r_y,\qquad M_b=p_bS_x\;\text{(Class 1/2)},\qquad m_{LT}M_{max}\le M_b

LE and ry use the same length unit. pb uses N/mm²; Sx uses mm³; Mb uses N·mm. mLT is dimensionless.

Scope. Use the specified section class, effective-length branch and loading condition. Load height alone does not prove a destabilizing case.

Check and takeaway. Removing a lateral restraint requires a new segment stability check. The old shorter-segment result cannot establish the longer segment’s adequacy.

Change the ruler, keep the quantity

A section table uses centimetres, but the strength calculation uses millimetres. The numbers must describe the same section.

Length1 factorArea2 factors3 factorsEach centimetre becomes ten millimetres.
In the diagram, the length, square and cube contain one, two and three length factors. Each factor changes when the ruler changes.

Prediction, then explanation. Would every property increase by ten? No. The exponent determines how many factors of ten are needed.

First identify the physical quantity. Next convert each length factor. Keep force and length conversions separate when converting a moment.

1 cmn=10n mmn,1 kN m=106 N mm1\,\mathrm{cm}^n=10^n\,\mathrm{mm}^n,\qquad 1\,\mathrm{kN\,m}=10^6\,\mathrm{N\,mm}

Here n is the length exponent: 2 for area, 3 for section modulus and 4 for second moment of area.

Scope. Changing units changes neither the load nor the section. A conversion factor cannot repair a formula for the wrong physical quantity.

Check and takeaway. Illustration: 2 cm4=20,000 mm42\,\mathrm{cm}^4=20{,}000\,\mathrm{mm}^4. The fourth power belongs to the unit, not the number 2.

A table value has conditions

Find a design property without mixing a row, column or standard from a different case.

The row and column meet at one cell. The table heading supplies the units and the conditions that give the cell meaning.
The row and column meet at one cell. The table heading supplies the units and the conditions that give the cell meaning.

Prediction, then explanation. A different flange thickness can select a lower design strength even when the steel grade name remains unchanged.

Match the complete section designation. Read the relevant axis and unit. For strength tables, select material, thickness and curve before interpolating.

Given values come from the question. Lookup values come from a named table. Assumed values require an explicit condition.

Scope. A missing row or omitted restraint cannot be recovered from a schematic’s scale. Keep the result conditional when required data are absent.

Check and takeaway. Record the table, row, column and unit beside the substitution. That makes a later check possible.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

Lookup: Data File pp.9–10, exact 406×140×46 UB row.

Dimensions on p.9; properties on p.10.

D is overall depth.

d is the clear web depth between root fillets, not the nominal designation.

PropertyLookup value / conversion
DimensionsD403.2, web t 6.8, flange T11.2, root r 10.2, clear d 360.4, all mm
Local ratiosbT=6.35;dt=53。
Major-axis propertiesIx=15690cm4=1.569×108mm4; Zx=778cm3; Sx=888cm3.
LTB propertiesry=3.03cm=30.3mm; u=0.871; torsional index x=38.9.

Why this method applies

Moment shape matters within one segment

Represent a nonuniform moment distribution in the applicable member-buckling equation.

The two diagrams have equal peaks. The left high-moment region is short; the right high-moment region extends across more of the segment.
The two diagrams have equal peaks. The left high-moment region is short; the right high-moment region extends across more of the segment.

Prediction, then explanation. Two segments can have equal peak moment but different distributions. Their equivalent moment factors can therefore differ.

Evaluate moments from the true whole-beam analysis at the required positions. Apply the exact table’s weights, signs and lower bound.

mLT is an LTB factor. mx and my belong to the specified flexural checks. They are not interchangeable.

Scope. Some rules use magnitudes; others require signed ordinates. A factor does not reduce the actual moment used in a local section check.

Check and takeaway. Measure quarter points from the segment start, not automatically from the beam’s left support.

Use the same mechanism: Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.

A cut reveals the internal actions

Find where the beam moment is largest. A large load arrow alone does not locate that point.

The dashed imaginary cut separates two beam pieces. The opposing arrows represent the shear action between those pieces.
The dashed imaginary cut separates two beam pieces. The opposing arrows represent the shear action between those pieces.

Prediction, then explanation. Under a uniform downward load, shear falls steadily. Moment reaches a stationary value where shear becomes zero.

Balance the forces on the cut piece to get V. Balance their moments about the cut to get M. Evaluate each load region separately.

V(x)=RA−wx,M(x)=RAx−wx22V(x)=R_A-wx,\qquad M(x)=R_Ax-\frac{wx^2}{2}

x and L use m; w uses kN/m; V uses kN; M uses kN·m. These lines apply before any point load.

Scope. A point load adds a shear jump. A concentrated couple adds a moment jump. Check load points, supports and overhang roots too.

Check and takeaway. A UDL gives a sloping shear line and a curved moment line. A flat moment diagram therefore cannot represent a loaded UDL region.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

Vertical loading is identical in both cases.

Therefore, the reactions and BMD stay identical.

What changes is the unrestrained segment: one 6m length becomes two 3m lengths.

Both the segment moment factor and the segment buckling resistance must be recalculated.

(a) Maximum shear and moment —2 printed marks

Balance the isolated beam

Find the two vertical reactions before calculating internal shear or moment.

A / RₐB / RᵦPaL
A and B are vertical supports. The downward load acts at distance a from A. Its distance from B is L − a.

Prediction, then explanation. Move the same load toward B. Reaction B increases because the load has a larger moment arm about A.

Take moments about A. Reaction A has zero lever arm there. Then use vertical force balance to find reaction A.

RBL=Pa,RA+RB=PR_B L=Pa,\qquad R_A+R_B=P

P, RA and RB are forces in kN. L is support spacing and a is load position, both in m.

Scope. These expressions describe one point load on a simply supported beam. Add other loads through equilibrium; keep their actual positions.

Check and takeaway. Illustration: P = 60 kN, L = 6 m and a = 2 m give RB = 20 kN and RA = 40 kN.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

Physical interpretation: Why reactions balance the loads

Think of a seesaw that must neither fall nor turn.

Why reactions balance the loads — Think of a seesaw that must neither fall nor turn.

Sketch, not to scale; use the original dimensions.

  1. Upward and downward forces must balance.
  2. Take moments about a support to eliminate its reaction.
  3. Use perpendicular distance from the point to the force line.

Remember: A lateral restraint is not automatically a vertical support.

Related concept and full method

By symmetry: RA=RC=1102=55kNMaximum shear magnitude: |V|max=55kNMaximum midspan moment: Mmax=PL4=110×64=165kN·m
Calculated shear and bending diagrams with labelled support/load ordinates; positive values upward. All values are repeated in the working.

Teaching diagrams drawn from the calculation, not original source images.

Labels identify calculated diagrams, positive ordinates upwards, shear force and bending moment.

Positions are in m, V is measured in kN, M is measured in kN·m; A, B and C denote the left end, midspan and right end.

All values are also listed in the solution steps.Open full-size image.

Mechanism detailsBalance reactions and moments1 concept · 1 source expressions

The complete mechanism is explained below.

Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.

  1. This demonstrator is a simply supported 6 m beam with a 60 kN point load.

    It is not the page’s original loading diagram.

  2. .

    Moving the load towards B increases .

  3. .

    The two upward reactions must sum to P.

  4. With the load at midspan, .

    End couples, UDLs and overhangs require their own equilibrium terms.

(b) End restraints only —14 printed marks

Use the same mechanism: Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.

Use the same mechanism: Moment shape matters within one segment. Two segments can have equal peak moment but different distributions. Their equivalent moment factors can therefore differ.

Move between two known values

The required slenderness lies between two table rows. Estimate the strength on the straight segment between those rows.

xy(70, 200)(74, 192)(80, 180)70748040% of input interval → 40% of output change
The marked position lies partway along the horizontal interval. Use the same fraction of the vertical change.

Prediction, then explanation. If the second strength is lower, moving toward that row must reduce the interpolated strength.

Subtract the lower input to find distance travelled. Divide by the input interval. Multiply that fraction by the output change.

f=x−x0x1−x0,y=y0+f(y1−y0)f=\frac{x-x_0}{x_1-x_0},\qquad y=y_0+f(y_1-y_0)

x is the required input. The two known pairs are (x₀, y₀) and (x₁, y₁). f has no unit.

Scope. Use one table, curve and strength column. This interpolation does not permit extrapolation or inventing an intermediate steel section.

Check and takeaway. Illustration: between strengths 200 and 180, a fraction of 0.4 gives 192 N/mm². The result lies between both endpoints.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

Physical interpretation: A beam can escape sideways

The compressed flange can move sideways while the section twists.

A beam can escape sideways — The compressed flange can move sideways while the section twists.

Sketch, not to scale; use the original dimensions.

  1. Divide the beam at effective lateral restraints.
  2. Use each segment’s effective length to obtain its buckling resistance.
  3. Compare that resistance with the segment’s equivalent moment demand.

Remember: A section bending check alone does not check lateral-torsional buckling.

Related concept and full method

S355, flange T=11.2mm, so py=355Nmm2. ε=275355=0.880141Flange: bT=6.35<9ε=7.921268Web in bending: dt=53<80ε=70.411267Both are Class 1, so βW=1; plastic moment resistance is permitted.dt=53<70ε=61.609858No shear-buckling calculation is required under the course limit.

For the full 6m segment the BMD is triangular with its peak in the middle.

At local quarter points 1.5,3,4.5m, the moments are 82.5,165,82.5kN·m.

Table 8.4b: mLT=0.2+0.15×82.5+0.5×165+0.15×82.5165=0.2+0.075+0.5+0.075=0.85Equivalent uniform moment demand: 0.85×165=140.25kN·m

Normal-load effective length is the given segment length.

All quantities in λ and λᴸᵀ are dimensionless.

This Class 1 section has βW=1.

λ=LEry=600030.3=198.019802v=[1+0.05(λx)2]−14=[1+0.05(198.01980238.9)2]−14=0.812407λLT=uvλβW=0.871×0.812407×198.019802×1=140.120058

Table 8.3a, Data File p.5, pᵧ355 column:

140 gives 80,145 gives 75Nmm2. Interpolation fraction: 140.120058−140145−140=0.024012pb=80+0.024012×(75−80)=79.879942Nmm2Mb=pbSx1,000=79.879942×8881,000=70.933388kN·mEquivalent uniform moment demand: mLTMmax=140.250000kN·mUtilisation: 140.25000070.933388=1.977207Fails.

The beam fails this LTB check.

Its section bending resistance 315.24kN·m exceeds 165.

However, that local-section fact cannot override the much smaller lateral-buckling resistance 70.933388kN·m.

Mechanism detailsA beam bends sideways and twists4 concepts · 5 source expressions

The complete mechanism is explained below.

Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.

  1. For the illustrated sagging beam the top flange is compressed.
  2. The unrestrained compression flange can move sideways while the complete cross-section twists.
  3. Only effective restraints divide the member into unbraced segments.

    They do not automatically add vertical supports.

  4. Use the segment effective length, section properties and matching moment factor.

    This is an exaggerated mode shape, not a calculated displacement.

(c) Add an effective midpoint restraint —14 printed marks

Use the same mechanism: Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.

Use the same mechanism: Moment shape matters within one segment. Two segments can have equal peak moment but different distributions. Their equivalent moment factors can therefore differ.

Use the same mechanism: Move between two known values. If the second strength is lower, moving toward that row must reduce the interpolated strength.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

Physical interpretation: Which length belongs in the calculation?

A sideways tie can shorten the buckling region without shortening the beam’s vertical span.

Which length belongs in the calculation? — A sideways tie can shorten the buckling region without shortening the beam’s vertical span.

Sketch, not to scale; use the original dimensions.

  1. Separate vertical-support spacing from lateral-restraint spacing.
  2. Apply the course rule for the actual end restraint and loading.
  3. Keep the original vertical load analysis unless its supports change.

Remember: Restraints in one direction may not restrain the other direction.

Related concept and full method

The left 3m segment now has moments 0 atA and 165 atB.

The right segment mirrors it.

The BMD over each segment is a straight triangle with its maximum at an end, not in the middle.

End-moment ratio: β=0165=0Table 8.4a: mLT=0.6+0.4β=0.6Equivalent demand: 0.6×165=99kN·mNew effective length of each half-segment LE=3,000mm.

Normal-load effective length is the given segment length.

All quantities in λ and λᴸᵀ are dimensionless.

This Class 1 section has βW=1.

λ=LEry=300030.3=99.009901v=[1+0.05(λx)2]−14=[1+0.05(99.00990138.9)2]−14=0.932256λLT=uvλβW=0.871×0.932256×99.009901×1=80.395537

Table 8.3a, Data File p.5, pᵧ355 column:

80 gives 190,85 gives 175Nmm2. Interpolation fraction: 80.395537−8085−80=0.079107pb=190+0.079107×(175−190)=188.813390Nmm2Mb=pbSx1,000=188.813390×8881,000=167.666290kN·mEquivalent uniform moment demand: mLTMmax=99.000000kN·mUtilisation: 99.000000167.666290=0.590459Passes.

Both halves pass.

A point load alone is not a lateral restraint; part(c) grants a separate effective restraint at that location.

Suggested method-credit evidence: show the changedLE, moment factor, λ/v/λLT, table interpolation, resistance and conclusion.

Do not merely state “restraint makes it safe.”

Mechanism detailsA beam bends sideways and twists4 concepts · 4 source expressions

The complete mechanism is explained below.

Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.

  1. For the illustrated sagging beam the top flange is compressed.
  2. The unrestrained compression flange can move sideways while the complete cross-section twists.
  3. Only effective restraints divide the member into unbraced segments.

    They do not automatically add vertical supports.

  4. Use the segment effective length, section properties and matching moment factor.

    This is an exaggerated mode shape, not a calculated displacement.

Result and concise exam wording

Use the same mechanism: Balance the isolated beam. Move the same load toward B. Reaction B increases because the load has a larger moment arm about A.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

(a)V55 kN,M165 kNm. (b)LE6 m,mLT0.85,demand 140.25;λ198.019802,v 0.812407,λLT140.120058,pb 79.879942,Mb 70.933388 kNm → fails. (c)TwoLE3 m segments,mLT0.6,demand 99;λ99.009901,v 0.932256,λLT80.395537,pb 188.813390,Mb 167.666290 kNm → passes.

Normal-load/LE assumptions as stated.

Misconceptions and checks

Use the same mechanism: Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

  • Do not factor the 110kN design load.
  • Do not usemLT0.85 for the half-span segment.
  • Do not double the bolt/beam load merely because there are two segments.
  • A local bending pass does not rule out LTB.

How the method transfers to a new variant

Use the same mechanism: Moment shape matters within one segment. Two segments can have equal peak moment but different distributions. Their equivalent moment factors can therefore differ.

Use the same mechanism: Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.

Use the same mechanism: A cut reveals the internal actions. Under a uniform downward load, shear falls steadily. Moment reaches a stationary value where shear becomes zero.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

  1. Keep the same vertical-load analysis.
  2. Redraw only the restraint boundaries for each case.
  3. Calculate a moment factor for each actual segment BMD.
  4. Recompute slenderness and resistance for that length.
  5. Compare equivalent demand withMb and state each case separately.

Prediction with explained answer

Use the same mechanism: Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

Prediction and explained answer.

Invented variant: with the midpoint restraint present, increase the central design load to 180kN.

Does LTB still pass?

Answer and reasoning

New maximum moment M=180×64=270kN·m.

For each half-span, mLT remains 0.6, giving demand 162kN·m.

Resistance remains 167.666290kN·m, so LTB passes with only a small margin.

Other checks also need updating.

This conclusion covers only the stated LTB model.

Mechanism detailsA beam bends sideways and twists1 concept · 1 source expressions

The complete mechanism is explained below.

Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.

  1. For the illustrated sagging beam the top flange is compressed.
  2. The unrestrained compression flange can move sideways while the complete cross-section twists.
  3. Only effective restraints divide the member into unbraced segments.

    They do not automatically add vertical supports.

  4. Use the segment effective length, section properties and matching moment factor.

    This is an exaggerated mode shape, not a calculated displacement.