STEELWORK / CON4334
Worked examples

Column example 2: a weak-axis tie permits a lighter section

Diagrams, explanations and answers are presented in reading order. No playback or response is required.

← Read this lecture example beside its chapter concepts

All answers shownChinese–English terminology
Diagrams, explanations and answers are presented in reading order. No playback or response is required.

Repeat the 2,500kN axial-column design with a 6m pinned column and an effective midheight tie against weak-axis buckling. Select and check a Grade S355 UC.

Original source: LectureNotes/Ch 4_Column.pdf — p. 23, p. 24.

A given value comes from the question or diagram.

A lookup value comes from the named table.

A calculated value follows from the working.

Each assumption is stated where the calculation needs it.

Known information, diagram labels and unknowns

A table value has conditions

Find a design property without mixing a row, column or standard from a different case.

The row and column meet at one cell. The table heading supplies the units and the conditions that give the cell meaning.
The row and column meet at one cell. The table heading supplies the units and the conditions that give the cell meaning.

Prediction, then explanation. A different flange thickness can select a lower design strength even when the steel grade name remains unchanged.

Match the complete section designation. Read the relevant axis and unit. For strength tables, select material, thickness and curve before interpolating.

Given values come from the question. Lookup values come from a named table. Assumed values require an explicit condition.

Scope. A missing row or omitted restraint cannot be recovered from a schematic’s scale. Keep the result conditional when required data are absent.

Check and takeaway. Record the table, row, column and unit beside the substitution. That makes a later check possible.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

InputOrigin
Axial forceGiven 2,500kN design compression.
Direction of tieQuestion states weak direction: shorten y-axis buckling length only.
Trial sectionData File p.11, 254×254×73 UC: T=14.2mm, bT=8.96, dt=23.3, rx=11.1cm, ry=6.48cm, A=93.1cm2.
Tablespᵧ355 because T≤16; rolled H≤40 uses curves b/c.

Why this method applies

Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion

A beam has enough local bending resistance. Check whether its compression flange can move sideways and twist.

The dashed straight line is the initial reference. The curved flange lines illustrate the labelled sideways movement and twist.
The dashed straight line is the initial reference. The curved flange lines illustrate the labelled sideways movement and twist.

Prediction, then explanation. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.

Identify the compressed flange and effective restraints. Calculate the specified slenderness, read buckling strength and compare resistance with the segment demand.

λ=LE/ry,Mb=pbSx  (Class 1/2),mLTMmax≤Mb\lambda=L_E/r_y,\qquad M_b=p_bS_x\;\text{(Class 1/2)},\qquad m_{LT}M_{max}\le M_b

LE and ry use the same length unit. pb uses N/mm²; Sx uses mm³; Mb uses N·mm. mLT is dimensionless.

Scope. Use the specified section class, effective-length branch and loading condition. Load height alone does not prove a destabilizing case.

Check and takeaway. Removing a lateral restraint requires a new segment stability check. The old shorter-segment result cannot establish the longer segment’s adequacy.

Use the same mechanism: A table value has conditions. A different flange thickness can select a lower design strength even when the steel grade name remains unchanged.

Use the property for the physical question

A section table contains several numbers. Choose the property that matches the calculation and bending axis.

Read the three labels beside the I-section: I describes geometric stiffness, Z elastic section modulus and S plastic section modulus.
Read the three labels beside the I-section: I describes geometric stiffness, Z elastic section modulus and S plastic section modulus.

Prediction, then explanation. Moving equal area away from an axis increases I about that axis. It does not increase total area.

Each small area contributes its area multiplied by squared distance. Sum those contributions to obtain I.

I=∫y2 dA,r=I/AI=\int y^2\,dA,\qquad r=\sqrt{I/A}

I is second moment of area in mm⁴. y is distance from the chosen axis in mm. A is area in mm². r is radius of gyration in mm.

Scope. Z is elastic section modulus; S is plastic section modulus in this course. Neither is interchangeable with I.

Check and takeaway. A nominal section designation is a row identifier. Use the actual dimensions and units in that exact row.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

Compare this to Example 1: restraints can be as important as area.

The weak-axis tie reduces its unbraced length from 6 to 3m.

A smaller column is now possible, but after changing section both radii, the area and the thickness-dependent strength must be reread.

Do not reuse Example 1’s section properties.

1. Set each effective length

Check buckling about both axes

Determine which buckling direction limits the compressed member.

Compare the outlines labelled Straight and Bowed. The dashed line beside Bowed marks its original straight reference.
Compare the outlines labelled Straight and Bowed. The dashed line beside Bowed marks its original straight reference.

Prediction, then explanation. At fixed radius, longer effective length raises slenderness. The supplied buckling curve generally gives lower compressive strength.

Calculate slenderness about each axis. Select each axis’s curve from section type and thickness. Then obtain and compare the two compressive resistances.

λx=LEx/rx,λy=LEy/ry,Pc=pcAg\lambda_x=L_{Ex}/r_x,\quad\lambda_y=L_{Ey}/r_y,\qquad P_c=p_cA_g

Effective lengths and radii use mm. pc is compressive strength in N/mm²; Ag is gross area in mm²; Pc is in N.

Scope. Do not select the governing axis using radius alone. Effective length and buckling curve can differ. A combined column also needs interaction checks.

Check and takeaway. A short-section yield resistance is not the same as long-member buckling resistance. Keep py and pc distinct.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

Physical interpretation: Why a long column can fail before crushing

Push a long thin ruler from both ends: it may bow sideways first.

Why a long column can fail before crushing — Push a long thin ruler from both ends: it may bow sideways first.

Sketch, not to scale; use the original dimensions.

  1. Find effective length and radius of gyration for each axis.
  2. Calculate slenderness for both directions.
  3. Use the appropriate buckling curve before forming resistance.

Remember: Compare the final resistances; slenderness alone may not identify the controlling axis.

Related concept and full method

Major axis has no effective intermediate tie: LEx=6,000mmMinor axis has a mid-height tie: LEy=3,000mmEach of the two segments has length 3m and carries the full 2,500kN axial force.

A horizontal positional restraint suppresses a buckling displacement.

It does not support half the vertical load or create a new 2,5002kN compression case.

Mechanism detailsEffective length and buckling axes1 concept · 1 source expressions

The complete mechanism is explained below.

Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.

  1. A column can bow sideways before its section reaches the crushing resistance.
  2. Each axis has its own radius of gyration and restraint spacing.
  3. , with compatible length units.

    A tie affects only the directions it actually restrains.

  4. Select each buckling curve and compressive strength before forming Pc.

    The governing axis is determined by resistance, not slenderness alone.

2. Trial 254×254×73 UC

Use the same mechanism: Check buckling about both axes. At fixed radius, longer effective length raises slenderness. The supplied buckling curve generally gives lower compressive strength.

Use the same mechanism: A table value has conditions. A different flange thickness can select a lower design strength even when the steel grade name remains unchanged.

Use the same mechanism: Use the property for the physical question. Moving equal area away from an axis increases I about that axis. It does not increase total area.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

T=14.2mm≤16→py=355Nmm2Ag=93.1cm2=9,310mm2rx=11.1cm=111mm;ry=6.48cm=64.8mm

These values come from the same exact section row on Data File p.11.

This lighter trial is the one selected in the lecture.

Mechanism detailsEffective length and buckling axes3 concepts · 1 source expressions

The complete mechanism is explained below.

Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.

  1. A column can bow sideways before its section reaches the crushing resistance.
  2. Each axis has its own radius of gyration and restraint spacing.
  3. , with compatible length units.

    A tie affects only the directions it actually restrains.

  4. Select each buckling curve and compressive strength before forming Pc.

    The governing axis is determined by resistance, not slenderness alone.

3. Check local slenderness

Find which plate buckles first

Before using plastic bending resistance, check whether the flange and web can sustain the required stress distribution.

The short waves are local plate buckling. They differ from sideways movement of the whole member.
The short waves are local plate buckling. They differ from sideways movement of the whole member.

Prediction, then explanation. At fixed width, a thinner plate has a larger width-to-thickness ratio. Local buckling then becomes more restrictive.

Calculate the flange and web ratios separately. Compare each with the limits for its stress condition. The worse class governs.

ε=275/py\varepsilon=\sqrt{275/p_y}

py is the design yield strength in N/mm². ε is a dimensionless scale used in the supplied classification limits.

Scope. Pure bending and uniform compression use different web limits. Class 2 allows plastic resistance but not the Class 1 rotation capability.

Check and takeaway. A Class 1 web and Class 2 flange give a Class 2 section. Do not average the class numbers.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

ε=275355=0.88014113ε=11.4418;bT=8.96<11.441840ε=35.2056;dt=23.3<35.2056Flange and web are both non-slender in uniform compression.

Mechanism detailsWhy thin elements buckle locally1 concept · 1 source expressions

The complete mechanism is explained below.

Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.

  1. The flange outstand and web have different widths, thicknesses and edge support conditions.
  2. A thinner plate can wrinkle locally before the complete member loses stability.
  3. Class 1 allows plastic rotation.

    Class 2 reaches plastic resistance.

    Class 3 reaches elastic resistance.

    Class 4 requires effective properties.

  4. Check every relevant compression element with the supplied limits and stress distribution.

    The deformation shown is qualitative.

4. Slenderness for the tied and untied directions

Use the same mechanism: Check buckling about both axes. At fixed radius, longer effective length raises slenderness. The supplied buckling curve generally gives lower compressive strength.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

λx=6,000111=54.054054λy=3,00064.8=46.296296

Now λx exceeds λy.

That alone does not prove the x axis controls because its curve b is more favourable than the weak-axis curve c.

Mechanism detailsEffective length and buckling axes1 concept · 1 source expressions

The complete mechanism is explained below.

Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.

  1. A column can bow sideways before its section reaches the crushing resistance.
  2. Each axis has its own radius of gyration and restraint spacing.
  3. , with compatible length units.

    A tie affects only the directions it actually restrains.

  4. Select each buckling curve and compressive strength before forming Pc.

    The governing axis is determined by resistance, not slenderness alone.

5. Interpolate each curve

Use the same mechanism: Check buckling about both axes. At fixed radius, longer effective length raises slenderness. The supplied buckling curve generally gives lower compressive strength.

Use the same mechanism: A table value has conditions. A different flange thickness can select a lower design strength even when the steel grade name remains unchanged.

Move between two known values

The required slenderness lies between two table rows. Estimate the strength on the straight segment between those rows.

xy(70, 200)(74, 192)(80, 180)70748040% of input interval → 40% of output change
The marked position lies partway along the horizontal interval. Use the same fraction of the vertical change.

Prediction, then explanation. If the second strength is lower, moving toward that row must reduce the interpolated strength.

Subtract the lower input to find distance travelled. Divide by the input interval. Multiply that fraction by the output change.

f=x−x0x1−x0,y=y0+f(y1−y0)f=\frac{x-x_0}{x_1-x_0},\qquad y=y_0+f(y_1-y_0)

x is the required input. The two known pairs are (x₀, y₀) and (x₁, y₁). f has no unit.

Scope. Use one table, curve and strength column. This interpolation does not permit extrapolation or inventing an intermediate steel section.

Check and takeaway. Illustration: between strengths 200 and 180, a fraction of 0.4 gives 192 N/mm². The result lies between both endpoints.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

Physical interpretation: A value between two table rows

Move the same fraction of the way across both number ranges.

A value between two table rows — Move the same fraction of the way across both number ranges.

Sketch, not to scale; use the original dimensions.

  1. Choose the correct table, curve and strength column first.
  2. Find how far your input lies between the two rows.
  3. Apply that fraction to the change between their answers.

Remember: Teaching example: halfway between outputs 100 and 80 gives 90.

Related concept and full method

Use Table 8.8(b), pᵧ355 for x and Table 8.8(c), pᵧ355 for y.

Major axis: 54 row gives 288,56 row gives 283Nmm2. Interpolation fraction: 54.054054−5456−54=0.027027pc=288+0.027027×(283−288)=287.864865Nmm2Minor axis: 46 row gives 286,48 row gives 280Nmm2. Interpolation fraction: 46.296296−4648−46=0.148148pc=286+0.148148×(280−286)=285.111111Nmm2

Despite its smaller slenderness, the weak axis gives the slightly smaller strength.

The source values 288 and 285Nmm2 are rounded representations.

Mechanism detailsEffective length and buckling axes3 concepts · 1 source expressions

The complete mechanism is explained below.

Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.

  1. A column can bow sideways before its section reaches the crushing resistance.
  2. Each axis has its own radius of gyration and restraint spacing.
  3. , with compatible length units.

    A tie affects only the directions it actually restrains.

  4. Select each buckling curve and compressive strength before forming Pc.

    The governing axis is determined by resistance, not slenderness alone.

6. Check the controlling resistance

Use the same mechanism: Check buckling about both axes. At fixed radius, longer effective length raises slenderness. The supplied buckling curve generally gives lower compressive strength.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

Pcx=9,310×287.8648651,000=2680.022kNPcy=9,310×285.1111111,000=2654.384kNPc=2654.384kN>2,500kNAdequate. Utilisation: 2,5002654.384=0.9418

The original rounds pc to 285, giving 93.1×28510=2,653.35kN, printed 2,653kN.

The exact interpolation gives 2,654.384kN.

The tie makes the 73kgm trial adequate where the untied example used 118kgm.

This conclusion assumes the tie provides the stated effective restraint; tie design itself is not part of this question.

Mechanism detailsEffective length and buckling axes1 concept · 2 source expressions

The complete mechanism is explained below.

Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.

  1. A column can bow sideways before its section reaches the crushing resistance.
  2. Each axis has its own radius of gyration and restraint spacing.
  3. , with compatible length units.

    A tie affects only the directions it actually restrains.

  4. Select each buckling curve and compressive strength before forming Pc.

    The governing axis is determined by resistance, not slenderness alone.

Result and concise exam wording

A strong cross-section can belong to an unstable member

A column carries axial compression and bending. Explain why more than one check is required.

The three boxes name separate checks: Section, Flexural and LTB. The bottom caption explains that passing one does not pass the others.
The three boxes name separate checks: Section, Flexural and LTB. The bottom caption explains that passing one does not pass the others.

Prediction, then explanation. At fixed moments and resistances, increasing compression increases utilisation. A section pass cannot remove the length-dependent instability checks.

Separate cross-section, flexural-buckling and LTB interaction equations. Use each equation’s own denominators and first-order or amplified moments.

AgpyA_g p_y is a section axial resistance. AgpcA_g p_c is a member compression resistance. Elastic pyZp_y Z and prescribed McM_c are different bending denominators.

Scope. Preserve the course barred-moment definitions and Eq. 8.81 convention. Do not substitute plastic moduli into an elastic denominator.

Check and takeaway. Report each requested utilisation and the governing check. The largest properly calculated ratio identifies the closest limit.

Use the same mechanism: Check buckling about both axes. At fixed radius, longer effective length raises slenderness. The supplied buckling curve generally gives lower compressive strength.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

Use S355 254×254×73 UC,py=355; under the 13ε, 40ε limits, it is non-slender.LxE=6m, LyE=3m; λx=54.0541, λy=46.2963.

Curves b/c give pcx=287.865, pcy=285.111Nmm2.

Pc=2,654.384kN>2,500, adequate.

Rounded source resistance 2,653kN.

Misconceptions and checks

Use the same mechanism: Find which plate buckles first. At fixed width, a thinner plate has a larger width-to-thickness ratio. Local buckling then becomes more restrictive.

Use the same mechanism: Check buckling about both axes. At fixed radius, longer effective length raises slenderness. The supplied buckling curve generally gives lower compressive strength.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

  • The tie changes only its effective buckling direction.
  • Use the full axial force in both 3m portions.
  • Compare actual pc values, not slenderness alone.
  • Reclassify after selecting a lighter section.

How the method transfers to a new variant

Use the same mechanism: Vertical bending can trigger sideways motion. Adding a valid lateral restraint shortens a stability segment. It need not change the beam’s vertical reaction or moment diagram.

A force couple carries moment

Separate the force couple used to carry moment from the force used to carry web shear.

The flange forces act in opposite directions. Their separation z gives the lever arm. The web arrow represents shear.
The flange forces act in opposite directions. Their separation z gives the lever arm. The web arrow represents shear.

Prediction, then explanation. For the same moment, a larger lever arm requires a smaller couple force. It does not remove the web shear.

Moment is force multiplied by perpendicular separation. Divide the required moment by the specified separation to obtain each couple force.

F=M/zF=M/z

M is moment in kN·mm; z is the specified force-line separation in mm; F is force in kN.

Scope. Use the lever arm defined by the source model. Do not silently replace it with overall section depth or another geometric distance.

Check and takeaway. Check flange welds for the couple forces and web welds for the stated shear model. Both force paths need a satisfactory detail.

Use the same mechanism: A strong cross-section can belong to an unstable member. At fixed moments and resistances, increasing compression increases utilisation. A section pass cannot remove the length-dependent instability checks.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

  1. Identify axial load, any moments, actual length and restraints in each axis.
  2. Choose/read a section and confirm strength from the actual thickness.
  3. Check the appropriate flange and web local-slenderness limits.
  4. Find λx and λy separately.

    Select each axis curve and interpolate pc.

  5. Calculate both axial resistances and identify the governing axis.
  6. If moments exist, complete section, flexural and axial/LTB interactions using their own capacities and moment definitions.

Prediction with explained answer

Use the same mechanism: Check buckling about both axes. At fixed radius, longer effective length raises slenderness. The supplied buckling curve generally gives lower compressive strength.

Use the same mechanism: A table value has conditions. A different flange thickness can select a lower design strength even when the steel grade name remains unchanged.

Apply the reasoning to this section’s data and conditions

Prediction and explained answer.

Invented variant: remove the weak-axis tie but retain 254×254×73 UC.

Find the weak-axis slenderness and estimate its supplied-table resistance.

Answer and reasoning

λy=6,00064.8=92.59259.

Curve c,pᵧ355: row 92 gives 158 and 94 gives 153, so pc=158+(0.592592)(153−158)=156.5185Nmm2.

Pcy=9,310×156.51851,000=1,457.187kN, much less than 2,500.

The untied version fails.

Mechanism detailsEffective length and buckling axes2 concepts · 3 source expressions

The complete mechanism is explained below.

Read each stage together with its stated conditions; playback and interaction are not required.

  1. A column can bow sideways before its section reaches the crushing resistance.
  2. Each axis has its own radius of gyration and restraint spacing.
  3. , with compatible length units.

    A tie affects only the directions it actually restrains.

  4. Select each buckling curve and compressive strength before forming Pc.

    The governing axis is determined by resistance, not slenderness alone.