LECTURE 06 / CON4334 STEELWORKS

Column examples: biaxial bending, amplification and interpreting utilisation

2022-10-31Recording length 03:08:05Watch on YouTube ↗

This lecture focuses on axial compression FcF_c with biaxial bending. Read the effective-length, buckling and interaction foundations, then start with complete Example 5. Q2 and Q3 include all three checks; Q5 is slightly above 1 at member level and shows how the lecturer states a marginally OK result.

Abbreviations: DL—Dead Load; LL—Live Load; ULS—Ultimate Limit State; SLS—Serviceability Limit State; UDL—Uniformly Distributed Load; LTB—Lateral-torsional Buckling; UB—Universal Beam; UC—Universal Column.

Key Points

  • For axial compression FcF_c plus biaxial bending, complete the section check followed by both member interaction checks.
  • Amplify moments as specified, for example by 1.1 or 1.15, then select governing values.
  • Determine β\beta from end-moment directions and read mxm_x, mym_y and mLTm_{LT}. These factors apply only to demand terms in member expressions.
  • Member denominators use PcP_c, elastic pyZp_yZ capacities and MbM_b, rather than section AgpyA_gp_y.
  • Compare utilisation with 1. Q5 gives about 1.05, which the lecturer judges marginally OK. Write the values in the answer; do not round to 1.

Key Formulas

FcAgpy+MxMcx+MyMcy≤1\dfrac{F_c}{A_gp_y}+\dfrac{M_x}{M_{cx}}+\dfrac{M_y}{M_{cy}}\le1
FcPc+mxMxpyZx+myMypyZy≤1\dfrac{F_c}{P_c}+\dfrac{m_xM_x}{p_yZ_x}+\dfrac{m_yM_y}{p_yZ_y}\le1
FcPc+mLTMLTMb+myMypyZy≤1\dfrac{F_c}{P_c}+\dfrac{m_{LT}M_{LT}}{M_b}+\dfrac{m_yM_y}{p_yZ_y}\le1

Exam Question Types

Design flows for these question types

Reading Notes
  • The approximately 01:30–01:50 break is omitted; assignment-submission matters were also handled during it.

Separate section and member levels in column design (Section versus Member)

What this unit is for: A column carries compression and moments about two axes at once; this unit explains checking the hardest-worked cross-section first, then the whole column against buckling, each with its own capacities.

Picture it this way: Think of the compression and the two moments as three expenses paid from one budget. Each is first written as a fraction of its own limit, and the three fractions together must not pass one whole. For the cross-section the compression limit is AgpyA_gp_y; for the whole column it becomes the smaller PcP_c.

Prerequisites: Instability can precede material crushing (Buckling) · Combined axial force and bending (Interaction Checks) · Read an I-section and its section table (Section Properties)

Concept Walkthrough

The lecturer restates the two levels. Section expressions assess material and local cross-sectional resistance; member expressions also include length, end restraint and overall instability. Write AgpyA_gp_y and PcP_c separately and note that the former contains no length term.

A column may have different slenderness λ\lambda, buckling curves and end-moment diagrams about xx and yy. Keep a separate data column for each. Both being bending directions does not justify a shared factor or modulus.

These are course code methods, not simple addition of three forces. Divide each demand by its resistance to obtain a dimensionless ratio, then compare using the appropriate interaction equation. This structure helps identify incorrect denominators.

In Class

Sequence for using column design expressions

Calculate λx\lambda_{x} and λy\lambda_{y}, obtain pcp_c from the correct curves, and find Pc=AgpcP_c=A_gp_c. Then handle biaxial moments and LTB according to the problem type.

The section axial-force denominator is AgpyA_gp_y; the member denominator is PcP_c. The difference represents overall buckling.

Pc=Agpc,λx=Lex/rx,λy=Ley/ryP_c=A_gp_c,\qquad\lambda_x=L_{ex}/r_x,\quad\lambda_y=L_{ey}/r_y
Pc=Agpcλx=Lex/rxλy=Ley/ry\begin{aligned}P_c&=A_gp_c\\\lambda_x&=L_{ex}/r_x\\\lambda_y&=L_{ey}/r_y\end{aligned}
FcAgpy+MxMcx+MyMcy≤1\frac{F_c}{A_gp_y}+\frac{M_x}{M_{cx}}+\frac{M_y}{M_{cy}}\le1
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 00:14:33
Formula page covering compression members, section checks and member buckling.
Formula page covering compression members, section checks and member buckling.

Example 5: retain moment signs through all three comparisons (Biaxial Worked Example)

What this unit is for: The moments at the two ends of a column differ in size and direction; this unit keeps their signs and completes three comparisons, one for the cross-section and two for the whole column.

Picture it this way: Bend a long plastic strip with both hands. Turn the ends so it forms one bow, curving to one side; turn them the opposite way and it forms an SS. The single bow pushes a column towards buckling most, the SS much less, so the signs of the end moments decide the size of the moment factor.

Prerequisites: Combined axial force and bending (Interaction Checks) · Instability can precede material crushing (Buckling) · Why a beam moves sideways and twists (Lateral-torsional Buckling)

Concept Walkthrough

Given end-moment signs follow specified rotations; table β\beta follows the bending-diagram convention. The lecturer converts xx moments +80/+24 to β=−0.3\beta=-0.3 and yy moments +30/−21 to β=0.7\beta=0.7. Draw end arrows and the internal moment diagram before using the table signs.

Each section capacity takes the smaller candidate; 1.2pyZ governs the weak axis. Member expressions use elastic pyZp_yZ, plus PcP_c and moment factors. The three totals differ because their checks differ; do not choose the smallest as the overall conclusion.

The complete example links area units, effective length LeL_e, both pcp_c values, moment factors and LTB using the lecturer's method.

Complete worked examples in this unit: Example 5: biaxial checks for a non-sway-frame column (Biaxial Column)

In Class

Example 5: given conditions for a non-sway-frame column

The column is in a non-sway frame, fixed at one end and pinned at the other, with axial force Fc=1650 kNF_c=1650\ \mathrm{kN}. End moments are +80/+24 kNm about xx and +30/−21 kNm about yy.

Specified amplification factors are 1.08 about xx and 1.15 about yy, giving governing demands Mx=86.4M_x=86.4 and My=34.5 kNmM_y=34.5\ \mathrm{kNm}.

Mx=1.08(80)=86.4 kNm,My=1.15(30)=34.5 kNmM_x=1.08(80)=86.4\ \mathrm{kNm},\qquad M_y=1.15(30)=34.5\ \mathrm{kNm}
Mx=1.08(80)=86.4 kNmMy=1.15(30)=34.5 kNm\begin{aligned}M_x&=1.08(80)=86.4\ \mathrm{kNm}\\M_y&=1.15(30)=34.5\ \mathrm{kNm}\end{aligned}
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 00:24:38
Question showing a 4.5 m column, 254×254×89 UC and end moments.
Question showing a 4.5 m column, 254×254×89 UC and end moments.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 00:26:46
Signed end-moment ratio β and the mLT table.
Signed end-moment ratio β\beta and the mLTm_{LT} table.
How to read this image: Read end-moment directions in the diagram before selecting β\beta. Do not rely solely on dividing the signed numbers in the question.

Example 5: section capacities and total utilisation

Thickness gives py=345 N/mm2p_y=345\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}. For xx use min⁡(422.3, 453.7)=422.3 kNm\min(422.3,\,453.7)=422.3\ \mathrm{kNm}; for yy use min⁡(198.4, 156.9)=156.9 kNm\min(198.4,\,156.9)=156.9\ \mathrm{kNm}.

Ag=113 cm2A_g=113\ \mathrm{cm^{2}}. The axial ratio is about 0.423 and moment ratios about 0.205 and 0.220. Their sum is approximately 0.848<1, so the section passes.

ηsection=1650(1000)113(100)(345)+86.4422.3+34.5156.9≈0.848<1\eta_{section}=\frac{1650(1000)}{113(100)(345)}+\frac{86.4}{422.3}+\frac{34.5}{156.9}\approx0.848<1
ηsection=1650(1000)113(100)(345)+86.4422.3+34.5156.9≈0.848<1\begin{aligned}\eta_{section}&=\frac{1650(1000)}{113(100)(345)}+\frac{86.4}{422.3}+\frac{34.5}{156.9}\\&\approx0.848\\&<1\end{aligned}
Governing weak-axis resistance is 156.9, not the plastic result 198.4 kNm.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 00:29:38
The solution compares plastic resistance and elastic caps about both axes.
The solution compares plastic resistance and elastic caps about both axes.

Example 5: effective length, buckling curves and moment factors

The end conditions give Le=0.85×4500=3825 mmL_e=0.85\times4500=3825\ \mathrm{mm}, λx≈34.2\lambda_{x}\approx34.2 and λy≈58.4\lambda_{y}\approx58.4. The respective curves give pc≈319p_c\approx319 about xx and ≈246 N/mm² about yy, so the weak axis governs.

The course moment-diagram ratios are βx=−24/80=−0.3\beta_{x}=-24/80=-0.3 with mx=0.54m_x=0.54, and βy=21/30=0.7\beta_{y}=21/30=0.7 with my=0.88m_y=0.88.

Pc≈246(113)(100)/1000=2779.8 kNP_c\approx246(113)(100)/1000=2779.8\ \mathrm{kN}
Pc≈246(113)(100)/1000=2779.8 kN\begin{aligned}P_c&\approx246(113)(100)/1000\\&=2779.8\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}
Moment factors come from the course table; the checks use 0.54 and 0.88.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 00:34:56
The lecturer compares readings from different compression-strength curves.
The lecturer compares readings from different compression-strength curves.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 00:37:29
Example 5: first member interaction expression.
Example 5: first member interaction expression.
How to read this image: Read axial, xx and yy terms in sequence, checking mx=0.54m_x=0.54, my=0.88m_y=0.88 and elastic capacities 378.1/130.8.

Example 5: LTB resistance and member checks

With u=0.850u=0.850, λ=58.4\lambda=58.4, x=14.5x=14.5, v≈0.862v\approx0.862 and βw=1\beta_{w}=1, the screen obtains λLT≈42.8\lambda_{LT}\approx42.8. The table gives pb=308.6 N/mm2p_b=308.6\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}} and Mb≈377.7 kNmM_b\approx377.7\ \mathrm{kNm}.

Member moment terms use elastic capacities pyZx≈378.1p_yZ_x\approx378.1 and pyZy≈130.8 kNmp_yZ_y\approx130.8\ \mathrm{kNm}. With mx=0.54m_x=0.54 and my=0.88m_y=0.88, the first total is about 0.95. The LTB expression uses mLT≈0.48m_{LT}\approx0.48 and totals about 0.94. Both are below 1.

λLT=0.85(0.862)(58.4)≈42.8\lambda_{LT}=0.85(0.862)(58.4)\approx42.8
16502779.8+0.54(86.4)378.1+0.88(34.5)130.8≈0.949<1\frac{1650}{2779.8}+\frac{0.54(86.4)}{378.1}+\frac{0.88(34.5)}{130.8}\approx0.949<1
16502779.8+0.54(86.4)378.1+0.88(34.5)130.8≈0.949<1\begin{aligned}\frac{1650}{2779.8}+\frac{0.54(86.4)}{378.1}+\frac{0.88(34.5)}{130.8}&\approx0.949\\&<1\end{aligned}
These utilisations use rounded displayed parameters. Do not replace the elastic capacities here with the section-check values 422.3 and 156.9.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 00:40:00
Calculation page for equivalent slenderness and bending buckling resistance.
Calculation page for equivalent slenderness and bending buckling resistance.
Worked Example

Example 5: biaxial checks for a non-sway-frame column (Biaxial Column)

A 4.5 m column, 254×254×89 UC, is fixed at one end and pinned at the other. It carries 1650 kN of compression plus end moments about both axes. Decide whether the section is strong enough and whether the whole column buckles.

Solution Route: Amplify demand→classification/section capacities→section interaction→effective length LeL_e/pc→moment factors→member interaction and LTB.

Open the worked example (11 steps) →

Q2: same section, new loading and effective length (Updated Column Inputs)

What this unit is for: The same section now has a new compression, new moments and a new effective length; this unit redoes the cross-section and whole-column checks, and the column only just passes.

Picture it this way: Start a fresh page with the new data and amplify the moments. The cross-section check uses AgpyA_gp_y; the whole-column check switches to the smaller PcP_c. With no information on how the moments vary, every m is taken as 1, which treats the moment as equally large all along the column, the worst case.

Prerequisites: Combined axial force and bending (Interaction Checks) · Instability can precede material crushing (Buckling)

Concept Walkthrough

Q2 returns to 305×305×118 UC but changes axial force FcF_c, moments and effective length LeL_e: Fc=1450 kNF_c=1450\ \mathrm{kN}, Mx=220 kNmM_x=220\ \mathrm{kNm}, My=35 kNmM_y=35\ \mathrm{kNm} and Le=4.5 mL_e=4.5\ \mathrm{m}. List the new data rather than copying Example 5 because the designation seems familiar.

Section utilisation is 0.8035. For the member, yy-axis λ=57.9\lambda=57.9 gives pc=247.2 N/mm2p_c=247.2\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}} and Pc=3708 kNP_c=3708\ \mathrm{kN}. No end-moment distribution is supplied, so mx=my=mLT=1m_x=m_y=m_{LT}=1 is taken conservatively.

The member expressions give 0.988 and 0.992, both below 1. The column passes with little margin. The second uses LTB resistance Mb=600.1 kNmM_b=600.1\ \mathrm{kNm}, from λLT=43.5\lambda_{LT}=43.5 and pb=306.5 N/mm2p_b=306.5\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}.

Complete worked examples in this unit: Column Q2: section and member checks for 305×305×118 UC (Column Q2)

In Class

Q2: add biaxial bending to the same section

Use 305×305×118 UC with Le=4.5 mL_e=4.5\ \mathrm{m}, design axial force Fc=1450 kNF_c=1450\ \mathrm{kN}, Mx=220M_x=220, My=35 kNmM_y=35\ \mathrm{kNm} and governing MLT=200 kNmM_{LT}=200\ \mathrm{kNm}.

Amplification factors 1.1 and 1.15 give demands 242 and 40.25 kNm. Treat LTB demand separately using the specified governing moment.

Mx=1.1(220)=242 kNm,My=1.15(35)=40.25 kNmM_x=1.1(220)=242\ \mathrm{kNm},\qquad M_y=1.15(35)=40.25\ \mathrm{kNm}
Mx=1.1(220)=242 kNmMy=1.15(35)=40.25 kNm\begin{aligned}M_x&=1.1(220)=242\ \mathrm{kNm}\\M_y&=1.15(35)=40.25\ \mathrm{kNm}\end{aligned}
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 00:44:58
Q2 checks the structural adequacy of the Q1 column section.
Q2 checks the structural adequacy of the Q1 column section.

Q2: continue to buckling after the section check

Ag=150 cm2A_g=150\ \mathrm{cm^{2}} and py=345 N/mm2p_y=345\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}. Section bending resistances are approximately 675.5 kNm about xx and 243.9 kNm about yy.

Using amplified moments gives section utilisation about 0.280+0.358+0.165=0.804<1. Next, λy≈57.9\lambda_{y}\approx57.9 and pc≈247.2p_c\approx247.2 give Pc≈3708 kNP_c\approx3708\ \mathrm{kN} for member checks.

ηsection≈14505175+242675.5+40.25243.9≈0.803\eta_{section}\approx\frac{1450}{5175}+\frac{242}{675.5}+\frac{40.25}{243.9}\approx0.803
ηsection≈14505175+242675.5+40.25243.9≈0.803\begin{aligned}\eta_{section}&\approx\frac{1450}{5175}+\frac{242}{675.5}+\frac{40.25}{243.9}\\&\approx0.803\end{aligned}
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 01:04:55
The upper worksheet gives two-axis section capacities; the lower part begins slenderness calculations.
The upper worksheet gives two-axis section capacities; the lower part begins slenderness calculations.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 01:09:59
Q2 buckling: Le=4.5 m and slenderness ratios 33.1 and 57.9.
Q2 buckling: Le=4.5 mL_e=4.5\ \mathrm{m} and slenderness ratios 33.1 and 57.9.
How to read this image: Curve b about xx gives pc=320.7 N/mm2p_c=320.7\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}; curve c about yy gives 247.2 N/mm². Use the smaller.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 01:18:15
Q2 first member expression: mx=my=1 gives total 0.988<1.
Q2 first member expression: mx=my=1m_x=m_y=1 gives total 0.988<1.
How to read this image: Use elastic denominators: Mcx=345×1760/1000=607.2 kNmM_{cx}=345\times1760/1000=607.2\ \mathrm{kNm} and Mcy=345×589/1000=203.2 kNmM_{cy}=345\times589/1000=203.2\ \mathrm{kNm}.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 01:27:52
Q2 LTB resistance and second member interaction expression.
Q2 LTB resistance and second member interaction expression.
How to read this image: λLT=0.85×0.884×57.9≈43.5\lambda_{LT}=0.85\times0.884\times57.9\approx43.5. Read pb=306.5 N/mm2p_b=306.5\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}, giving Mb=306.5×1958/1000≈600.1 kNmM_b=306.5\times1958/1000\approx600.1\ \mathrm{kNm}.
Worked Example

Column Q2: section and member checks for 305×305×118 UC (Column Q2)

A 305×305×118 UC column with an effective length of 4.5 m carries 1450 kN of compression and moments of 220 and 35 kNm about its two axes, before amplification. Complete the section check and both member checks to decide whether the column is adequate.

Solution Route: Amplify demand→section utilisation→two-axis λ/pc\lambda/p_c→PcP_c→first member expression→LTB resistance MbM_b→second member expression.

Open the worked example (9 steps) →

Q3: a heavier section, all three checks (Heavier Section)

What this unit is for: A heavier section is used and the end moments change; this unit gets β\beta and m from the signs of the end moments, then completes the three checks.

Picture it this way: Write one line for each direction: the two end moments, the smaller divided by the larger to give β\beta, and m from the table. The factor m multiplies the demand only, while capacities such as PcP_c and MbM_b stay underneath. Each formula adds three ratios and compares the total with 1.

Prerequisites: Will the plate buckle before its material strength is fully mobilised? (Section Classification) · Combined axial force and bending (Interaction Checks) · Instability can precede material crushing (Buckling)

Concept Walkthrough

Q3 uses a heavier 305×305×198 UC and new loading: Fc=2500 kNF_c=2500\ \mathrm{kN}; xx end moments +350/+150 kNm amplified by 1.1; yy end moments +90/−70 kNm amplified by 1.15; Le=6 mL_e=6\ \mathrm{m}. Restate the conditions for every new problem, then follow the same procedure.

End-moment signs determine β\beta. Same-sign xx end moments give double curvature, β=−150/350=−0.429\beta=-150/350=-0.429, mx=0.514m_x=0.514 and mLT=0.454m_{LT}=0.454. Opposite-sign yy moments give single curvature, β=70/90=0.778\beta=70/90=0.778 and my=0.911m_y=0.911.

The section check is 0.853; member checks are 0.951 and 0.914. All are below 1, so the column passes. For yy, λ=74.6\lambda=74.6 and pc=200.1 N/mm2p_c=200.1\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}. LTB uses λLT=46.0\lambda_{LT}=46.0, pb=298.5 N/mm2p_b=298.5\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}} and Mb=1026.9 kNmM_b=1026.9\ \mathrm{kNm}.

Complete worked examples in this unit: Column Q3: biaxial bending of 305×305×198 UC (Column Q3)

In Class

Q3: complete procedure for a heavier UC section

The section changes to a heavier 305×305×198 UC with different end moments about both axes. Recalculate βx\beta_{x} and βy\beta_{y}; do not retain Example 5 factors.

The sequence remains classification and pyp_y→two-axis section capacities→Le/rL_e/r→curves and pcp_c→moment factors→two member interaction expressions.

Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 01:49:08
Another column question lists axial force, end moments and amplification factors.
Another column question lists axial force, end moments and amplification factors.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 01:59:56
Q3 section check: Mcx=pyS=1186.8 kNm and Mcy=1.2pyZy=429.3 kNm, giving total 0.853<1.
Q3 section check: Mcx=pyS=1186.8 kNmM_{cx}=p_yS=1186.8\ \mathrm{kNm} and Mcy=1.2pyZy=429.3 kNmM_{cy}=1.2p_yZ_y=429.3\ \mathrm{kNm}, giving total 0.853<1.
How to read this image: 2500/8694=0.288; 1.1×350/1186.8=0.324; 1.15×90/429.3=0.241.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 02:04:55
Q3 buckling strength and moment factors about both axes.
Q3 buckling strength and moment factors about both axes.
How to read this image: λ=6000/80.4=74.6\lambda=6000/80.4=74.6 gives pc=200.1 N/mm2p_c=200.1\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}. β=−0.429\beta=-0.429 gives mx=0.514m_x=0.514; β=0.778\beta=0.778 gives my=0.911m_y=0.911.

Q3: put moment factors on the correct demand terms

mxm_x and mym_y multiply moment demands. PcP_c, McM_c or MbM_b remain in their corresponding denominators. Every term must be dimensionless.

The worksheet shows mx≈0.514m_x\approx0.514 and my≈0.91m_y\approx0.91. These reflect different moment diagrams; do not set both to 1 merely because this is another column question.

η1=FcPc+mxMxMcx+myMyMcy\eta_1=\frac{F_c}{P_c}+\frac{m_xM_x}{M_{cx}}+\frac{m_yM_y}{M_{cy}}
η2=FcPc+mLTMLTMb+myMyMcy\eta_2=\frac{F_c}{P_c}+\frac{m_{LT}M_{LT}}{M_b}+\frac{m_yM_y}{M_{cy}}
Member denominators use elastic capacities pyZp_yZ: Mcx=345×2995/1000≈1033.3 kNmM_{cx}=345\times2995/1000\approx1033.3\ \mathrm{kNm} and Mcy=345×1037/1000≈357.8 kNmM_{cy}=345\times1037/1000\approx357.8\ \mathrm{kNm}.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 02:09:50
The worksheet shows member checks followed by LTB calculations below.
The worksheet shows member checks followed by LTB calculations below.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 02:14:58
Q3 LTB: λLT=46.0, pb=298.5 N/mm² and Mb=1026.9 kNm.
Q3 LTB: λLT=46.0\lambda_{LT}=46.0, pb=298.5 N/mm2p_b=298.5\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}} and Mb=1026.9 kNmM_b=1026.9\ \mathrm{kNm}.
How to read this image: v=1/(1+0.05×(74.6/10.2)2)v=1/(1+0.05\times(74.6/10.2)^{2})^0.25≈0.722; λLT=0.854×0.722×74.6≈46.0\lambda_{LT}=0.854\times0.722\times74.6\approx46.0.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 02:17:26
Q3 second member expression: 0.496+0.155+0.264=0.914<1.
Q3 second member expression: 0.496+0.155+0.264=0.914<1.
How to read this image: Multiply MLT=350 kNmM_{LT}=350\ \mathrm{kNm} by mLT=0.454m_{LT}=0.454, then divide by Mb=1026.9 kNmM_b=1026.9\ \mathrm{kNm}.
Worked Example

Column Q3: biaxial bending of 305×305×198 UC (Column Q3)

A 305×305×198 UC column with an effective length of 6 m carries 2500 kN of compression. End moments are 350 and 150 kNm about the xx axis, and 90 and −70 kNm about the yy axis. Complete the section check and both member checks.

Solution Route: Amplify demand→section resistance/utilisation→λ/pc\lambda/p_c→β\beta and m factors→first member expression→LTB→second member expression.

Open the worked example (11 steps) →

Q5: derive biaxial moments from eccentric reactions (Eccentric Column Reactions)

What this unit is for: Several beams rest on the column from different sides, each off the column centre; this unit adds them into the column compression and finds the moments about the two axes.

Picture it this way: A round table stands on one central leg with a weight on each side. All the weight goes down the leg, but only the difference between the two sides tries to tip the table. The moments from beam reactions on opposite sides of a column are likewise subtracted first, and only what remains bends the column.

Prerequisites: How loads travel from the slab to the ground (Load Path) · Why the position of a force matters (Moment and Eccentricity) · Combined axial force and bending (Interaction Checks)

Concept Walkthrough

Add the five downward loads to obtain 1930 kN, then take moments about each axis. Subtract opposing rotations; do not make every force-times-distance term positive.

The upper and lower column segments have equal stiffness here, so divide net joint moment by 2. This differs from the previous 6 m/3 m distribution. Two segments do not always imply equal sharing.

After amplification by 1.15 about both axes, section utilisation is only 0.630. It appears generous, but 5100 mm length reduces PcP_c. The next unit explains why member utilisation still exceeds 1.

In Class

Q5: how eccentric loads produce biaxial moments

Axial force FcF_c is 1200+150+100+180+300=1930 kN.

The screen calculates Mx=(300×0.27−180×0.23)/2=19.8 kNmM_x=(300\times0.27-180\times0.23)/2=19.8\ \mathrm{kNm} and My=(150×0.22−100×0.11)/2=11 kNmM_y=(150\times0.22-100\times0.11)/2=11\ \mathrm{kNm}. Division by 2 follows this problem's upper/lower segment distribution assumption; it is not universal.

Fc=1200+150+100+180+300=1930 kNF_c=1200+150+100+180+300=1930\ \mathrm{kN}
Fc=1200+150+100+180+300=1930 kN\begin{aligned}F_c&=1200+150+100+180+300\\&=1930\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}
Mx=19.8 kNm,My=11 kNmM_x=19.8\ \mathrm{kNm},\qquad M_y=11\ \mathrm{kNm}
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 02:23:29
Five loads and their eccentricities on a simple-construction column.
Five loads and their eccentricities on a simple-construction column.

Q5: passing the section is only the first stage

For 254×254×89 UC, Ag=113 cm2A_g=113\ \mathrm{cm^{2}} and py=345p_y=345; section bending capacities are 422.3 and 156.9 kNm. Both moments are amplified by 1.15 to 22.77 and 12.65 kNm.

Section utilisation is about 0.495+0.054+0.081=0.630<1. However, Le=5100 mmL_e=5100\ \mathrm{mm} and ry=65.5 mmr_y=65.5\ \mathrm{mm} give λy≈77.86\lambda_{y}\approx77.86, requiring reduced member resistance.

ηsection≈19303898.5+22.77422.3+12.65156.9≈0.630<1\eta_{section}\approx\frac{1930}{3898.5}+\frac{22.77}{422.3}+\frac{12.65}{156.9}\approx0.630<1
ηsection≈19303898.5+22.77422.3+12.65156.9≈0.630<1\begin{aligned}\eta_{section}&\approx\frac{1930}{3898.5}+\frac{22.77}{422.3}+\frac{12.65}{156.9}\\&\approx0.630\\&<1\end{aligned}
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 02:34:58
The worksheet shows adequate section resistance, then uses Le=5100 mm.
The worksheet shows adequate section resistance, then uses Le=5100 mmL_e=5100\ \mathrm{mm}.

Q5 decision: a result slightly above 1 judged marginally OK (Interpreting a Marginal Result)

What this unit is for: The cross-section check has plenty to spare, yet both whole-column formulas come out slightly above 1; this unit explains how such a result should be written down.

Picture it this way: Both subjects must be passed, and a high mark in one cannot make up for just missing the other. A low ratio for the cross-section cannot make up for a whole-column ratio slightly above 1. The answer states the values of both formulas as they are, without rounding them down to 1.

Prerequisites: Combined axial force and bending (Interaction Checks) · Instability can precede material crushing (Buckling)

Concept Walkthrough

Using the same data, the two member checks give approximately 1.050 and 1.052, only about 5% above 1. The lecturer writes “marginally OK” beside the worksheet, judging it just acceptable. The section utilisation 0.630 cannot be used to offset the member checks.

In the exam, follow the lecturer: give the values of both expressions, then write “marginally OK”. Remark: under the strict ≤1 condition, 1.05 exceeds the limit, and the lecturer also says it is, in principle, not OK.

State which expression, its value and the limit exceeded. Any redesign requires a revised section or restraint and recalculation, not merely a changed conclusion.

Complete worked examples in this unit: Q5: utilisation slightly above 1, judged marginally OK by the lecturer (Marginal Utilization)

In Class
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 02:45:00
Q5 intermediate data for elastic capacities, Pc and the LTB route.
Q5 intermediate data for elastic capacities, PcP_c and the LTB route.
How to read this image: Confirm Le=5100 mmL_e=5100\ \mathrm{mm} and the corresponding capacities before reading the next interaction screen. Do not mix in data from other 305-series sections.

Q5: slightly above 1, judged marginally OK by the lecturer

The course obtains pc≈191.34 N/mm2p_c\approx191.34\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}} and Pc≈2162 kNP_c\approx2162\ \mathrm{kN}. Member elastic bending capacities are about 378.1 and 130.8 kNm. The simple-construction method uses moment factors of 1.

The first expression is approximately 1930/2162+22.77/378.1+12.65/130.8=1.050>1. The LTB expression uses Mb≈366.3 kNmM_b\approx366.3\ \mathrm{kNm} and also totals about 1.05>1.

Both expressions exceed 1 by only about 5%. The lecturer writes “marginally OK” beside the worksheet, meaning just acceptable; in the answer, give the values of both expressions.

η1≈1.050>1⇒marginally OK\eta_1\approx1.050>1\quad\Rightarrow\quad\text{marginally OK}
η2≈19302162+22.77366.3+12.65130.8≈1.052>1\eta_2\approx\frac{1930}{2162}+\frac{22.77}{366.3}+\frac{12.65}{130.8}\approx1.052>1
η2≈19302162+22.77366.3+12.65130.8≈1.052>1\begin{aligned}\eta_2&\approx\frac{1930}{2162}+\frac{22.77}{366.3}+\frac{12.65}{130.8}\\&\approx1.052\\&>1\end{aligned}
Remark: the lecturer also says that, strictly, 1.05 is not OK; a different section or condition requires a complete recheck.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 02:49:52
The screen total is about 1.05 with a “marginally ok” note; another expression below also exceeds 1.
The screen total is about 1.05 with a “marginally ok” note; another expression below also exceeds 1.
Worked Example

Q5: utilisation slightly above 1, judged marginally OK by the lecturer (Marginal Utilization)

A 254×254×89 UC column carries 1200 kN at its centre plus four downward forces that act away from the centre and so bend the column. Find the total compression and the moments about both axes, then check the section and the whole column.

Solution Route: Combine loads→eccentric moments→specified distribution→amplification→section check→two member checks→the lecturer's judgement.

Open the worked example (9 steps) →

Final exercise: the 3000 kN column (End-of-lecture Question)

What this unit is for: A column question gives end moments with signs about both axes; this unit first turns them into amplified moments and β\beta values, ready for the interaction check.

Picture it this way: Copy the two end moments for each direction on its own line, signs included. On each line the larger one times the amplification factor is the demand, and the smaller divided by the larger gives β\beta. These numbers alone settle nothing, because the capacities have not been worked out yet.

Prerequisites: Combined axial force and bending (Interaction Checks) · Why the position of a force matters (Moment and Eccentricity)

Concept Walkthrough

The lecturer ends with a past-paper question: 305×305×158 UC, S355, Fc=3000 kNF_c=3000\ \mathrm{kN}; xx end moments −90/+70 kNm amplified by 1.1; yy end moments −60/−50 kNm amplified by 1.15; MLT=1.1×90=99 kNmM_{LT}=1.1\times90=99\ \mathrm{kNm}.

List signed end moments by axis, then obtain amplified governing values Mx=99M_x=99 and My=69 kNmM_y=69\ \mathrm{kNm}. Retain signs because they determine β\beta: opposite-sign xx moments give single curvature and β=70/90=0.778\beta=70/90=0.778; same-sign yy moments give double curvature and β=−50/60=−0.833\beta=-50/60=-0.833.

Only the β\beta-to-m lookup is shown here. The 14 November revision uses the same 3000 kN, 99 kNm and 69 kNm actions for interaction checks; see its assignment-beams-and-columns unit.

In Class

Final exercise: organise signed end moments first

Given end moments are −90/+70 kNm about xx and −60/−50 kNm about yy. Amplification factors are 1.1 and 1.15, with governing MLT=99 kNmM_{LT}=99\ \mathrm{kNm}.

First obtain maximum absolute demands Mx=99M_x=99 and My=69 kNmM_y=69\ \mathrm{kNm}. Then use the moment diagrams to establish β\beta and factors, complete both-axis lookups and interaction checks.

The lecturer only shows the question and β\beta lookup here, without completing it. The 14 November revision applies interaction checks to the same loading.
Lecture screenshot · 31 October · ▶ 03:00:00
Exercise with a 305×305×158 UC and 3000 kN axial force.
Exercise with a 305×305×158 UC and 3000 kN axial force.
↑ Top