Worked Example

Q3: combine shear at each bolt in an eccentric in-plane group (In-plane Eccentric Bolts)

Task: Use bolt coordinates to find the furthest-bolt resultant FRF_R and trace the lecturer's correction from total to one-side loading.

Original question · Lecture notes Chapter 2, p. 45, 47 (Tutorial 2 Q3)
Original question with the given values boxed
Yellow boxes: values the question gives, the same values marked yellow in the Given table below.

The question in short: A bracket carries an ultimate load of 200 kN, shared by two matching side plates. Each side has 8 bolts, and the load acts 300 mm from the centre of the bolt group. Find the bolt with the largest force and decide whether M16 bolts are adequate.

What differs from the previous example of this type: Unlike the earlier tension joints, the load does not pass through the centre of the bolt group, so it tries to turn the group. Each bolt gets a different force, and the worst one must be found.

GivenValue and Unit
Whole bracket200 kN ultimate load; symmetrical side plates
One-side arrangementEight bolts in two rows, 100 mm apart; vertical spacing 3 @ 100 mm
Eccentricity300 mm from one-side group centroid to load line
BoltsGrade 8.8; try M16, As=157 mm2\htmlClass{read}{A_s=157\ \mathrm{mm^{2}}}, ps=375 N/mm2\htmlClass{read}{p_s=375\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}}

Yellow: values given in the question. The same values are marked where they are substituted in the steps below.
Orange box: values read directly from the Data File, the same values boxed orange in the lookup screenshots. A value interpolated between two table rows is a calculation, so it has no box.

Numbered guide · 26 September · ▶ 02:05:00
Lecture screenshot with numbered reading guides
Numbers added to the lecture screenshot correspond to the explanations below:
  • ① One-side load 100 kN divided among 8 bolts gives direct shear 12.5 kN.
  • ② Corner geometry gives cos⁡φ=50/r\cos\varphi=50/r for vector combination.
  • ③ Maximum resultant about 45.069 kN is the shear demand for bolt selection.
  • ④ M16 shear resistance 58.875 exceeds demand; bearing data remain insufficient.
Eccentricity e = 300 mm100 kN8 bolts; x = ±50 mmy = ±50, ±150 mm (from centroid)
Supplementary schematic for understanding; not to scale.

Solution Route: Allocate between sides→centroid/squared-distance sum→direct shear FsF_s→torsional shear FTF_T→vector combination→bolt selection.

Interactive 3D model · drag to turn

This browser cannot show the 3D model.

Each bracket plate is bolted to one column flange with eight bolts, so each side takes 100 kN. The load is 300 mm from the bolt-group centroid; the torque gives the corner bolts the largest torsional shear, which is combined with the direct shear.Yellow: values given in the question; orange box: values read from the Data File; white: calculated results; red arrows: forces.
Load path · the stations the force passes through, in order

The 200 kN is first shared equally by the two bracket plates. The 100 kN on each plate misses the centroid of the bolt group, so each bolt takes a torsional shear as well as the direct shear.

  1. Ultimate load
    200 kN, 100 kN per bracket plate
    Step 1
  2. Bracket plate: eccentricity gives a torque
    e=300 mme=300\ \mathrm{mm}
    Step 6
  3. Bolts: direct shear
    12.5 kN per bolt
    Step 2
  4. Bolts: torsional shear
    39.528 kN at a corner bolt
    Step 3–6
  5. Resultant on a corner bolt (M16, single shear)
    Demand 45.069 kNCapacity 58.875 kNper bolt
    Utilisation 0.77
    Step 7–9
  6. Column flange
    The question gives no data for a bearing check
    Step 10
Each station links to the step that calculates it. Press “Show on the 3D model” to light up that part of the model above; press again to clear.
  1. Step 1 · Choose the analysed object first

    Why this step: The two side plates are alike, so each takes half the load. Fixing the load on one side first stops every bolt force from being doubled later.

    The whole bracket carries 200 kN, but the eight bolts drawn are one side, so use 100 kN. The lecturer initially obtains larger components with 200 kN, then corrects to 100 kN.

    P=Ptotal/2=200/2=100 kNP=P_{total}/2={\htmlClass{given}{200}}/2=100\ \mathrm{kN}

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 26 September 01:49:24

  2. Step 2 · Direct shear

    Why this step: First treat the load as if it acted at the centre of the group, simply pushing the plate along. This is the first part of the force on each bolt; the turning part is added later.

    Eight identical bolts share direct force equally, each acting parallel to the external force.

    New symbols in this step
    • FF, FsF_s, FTF_T: Total force, shear per bolt and tension per bolt; kN
    • pp, nn: Bolt spacing along the force, mm; number of bolts
    Fs=P/n=100/8=12.5 kNF_s=P/n=100/{\htmlClass{given}{8}}=12.5\ \mathrm{kN}

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 26 September 02:05:00

  3. Step 3 · Calculate group geometry from coordinates

    Why this step: A load away from the centre makes the plate turn about that centre. Bolts farther out resist turning more effectively, so the position of each bolt must be measured.

    Bolt coordinates are measured from the centroid of the group: the rows are 100 mm apart, so x=±50 mmx=\pm50\ \mathrm{mm}; the vertical spacing is 3 @ 100 mm, so y=±50y=\pm50 and ±150 mm. Squares of negative coordinates are positive.

    x=±100/2=±50,y=±100/2=±50, ±(100+100/2)=±150 mm∑xi2=8(50)2=20000 mm2\begin{aligned}x&=\pm{\htmlClass{given}{100}}/2=\pm50,\quad y=\pm{\htmlClass{given}{100}}/2=\pm50,\ \pm({\htmlClass{given}{100}}+{\htmlClass{given}{100}}/2)=\pm150\ \mathrm{mm}\\\sum x_i^2&={\htmlClass{given}{8}}(50)^2=20000\ \mathrm{mm^2}\end{aligned}
    x=±100/2=±50y=±100/2=±50, ±(100+100/2)=±150 mm∑xi2=8(50)2=20000 mm2\begin{aligned}x&=\pm{\htmlClass{given}{100}}/2=\pm50\\y&=\pm{\htmlClass{given}{100}}/2\\&=\pm50,\ \pm({\htmlClass{given}{100}}+{\htmlClass{given}{100}}/2)\\&=\pm150\ \mathrm{mm}\\\sum x_i^2&={\htmlClass{given}{8}}(50)^2=20000\ \mathrm{mm^2}\end{aligned}

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 26 September 01:53:41

  4. Step 4 · Add squared vertical distances

    Why this step: The sum of squared distances measures how well the whole group resists turning. The larger it is, the smaller the turning force on each bolt.

    Four bolts have |yy|=150 and four |yy|=50. Sum squared distances; do not square the sum of distances.

    ∑yi2=4(1502+502)=100000 mm2∑ri2=∑xi2+∑yi2=20000+100000=120000 mm2\begin{aligned}\sum y_i^2&=4(150^2+50^2)=100000\ \mathrm{mm^2}\\\sum r_i^2&=\sum x_i^2+\sum y_i^2=20000+100000=120000\ \mathrm{mm^2}\end{aligned}
    ∑yi2=4(1502+502)=100000 mm2∑ri2=∑xi2+∑yi2=20000+100000=120000 mm2\begin{aligned}\sum y_i^2&=4(150^2+50^2)=100000\ \mathrm{mm^2}\\\sum r_i^2&=\sum x_i^2+\sum y_i^2\\&=20000+100000\\&=120000\ \mathrm{mm^2}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 2000020000 from Step 3.

  5. Step 5 · Furthest-corner radius

    Why this step: When the group turns, the bolt farthest from the centre moves the most and takes the largest turning force. So the corner bolts are the ones to check.

    Find rr from the right triangle. It determines torsional-shear magnitude.

    New symbols in this step
    • MM, rr, Σr2\Sigma r^{2}: Eccentric moment kNmm, radius mm, sum of squared distances mm²
    r=x2+y2=502+1502=158.114 mmr=\sqrt{x^2+y^2}=\sqrt{50^2+150^2}=158.114\ \mathrm{mm}
    r=x2+y2=502+1502=158.114 mm\begin{aligned}r&=\sqrt{x^2+y^2}\\&=\sqrt{50^2+150^2}\\&=158.114\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}
  6. Step 6 · Torsional component

    Why this step: This is the extra force on the bolt caused by the load being off-centre. The larger the eccentricity, the larger the turning moment and the force on the corner bolt.

    M=PeM=Pe. Bolt torsional forces distribute according to radius. FtF_t is perpendicular to that radius, not automatically parallel to the external force.

    Ft=Per∑ri2=100(300)(158.114)120000=39.528 kNF_t=\frac{Per}{\sum r_i^2}=\frac{100({\htmlClass{given}{300}})(158.114)}{120000}=39.528\ \mathrm{kN}
    Ft=Per∑ri2=100(300)(158.114)120000=39.528 kN\begin{aligned}F_t&=\frac{Per}{\sum r_i^2}\\&=\frac{100({\htmlClass{given}{300}})(158.114)}{120000}\\&=39.528\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 158.114158.114 from Step 5; 120000120000 from Step 4.

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 26 September 02:05:00

  7. Step 7 · Read the included angle

    Why this step: The two forces point in different directions, so they cannot simply be added. The angle between them is found first so that they can be combined in the next step.

    At the critical corner, the illustrated angle has cos⁡θ=50/r\cos\theta=50/r. Other corners have different directions; inspect the arrows first.

    cos⁡ϕ=x/r=50/158.114≈0.31623\cos\phi=x/r=50/158.114\approx0.31623

    Where the numbers come from: 158.114158.114 from Step 5.

  8. Step 8 · Combine demand

    Why this step: The bolt really feels one combined force, and that is its shear demand. The closer the two forces are in direction, the larger the combined force.

    Use the lecturer's vector combination, not 12.5+39.528.

    FR=Fs2+Ft2+2FsFtcos⁡ϕ=12.52+39.5282+2(12.5)(39.528)(0.31623)≈45.069 kN\begin{aligned}F_R&=\sqrt{F_s^2+F_t^2+2F_sF_t\cos\phi}\\&=\sqrt{12.5^2+39.528^2+2(12.5)(39.528)(0.31623)}\approx45.069\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}
    FR=Fs2+Ft2+2FsFtcos⁡ϕ=12.52+39.5282+2(12.5)(39.528)(0.31623)≈45.069 kN\begin{aligned}F_R&=\sqrt{F_s^2+F_t^2+2F_sF_t\cos\phi}\\&=\sqrt{12.5^2+39.528^2+2(12.5)(39.528)(0.31623)}\\&\approx45.069\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 12.512.5 from Step 2; 39.52839.528 from Step 6; 0.316230.31623 from Step 7.

    Load path · Eccentric load = direct shear + torsional shear
    ① Eccentric load② Direct shear③ Torsional shear④ Vector sum=+→Pe = 300P = 100 kNcentroidFs​ = 12.5 kNFt​ = 39.528 kN (farthest point)M = Pe = 30000 kNmmFR​ = 45.069 kNsame at every pointlarger farther from the centroidcritical point: against Ps​ = 58.875 kN
    Moving the eccentric 100 kN to the centroid of the bolt group needs a torque M=PeM=Pe to go with it. ② The direct shear is shared equally by the eight bolts; ③ the torque gives each bolt a force perpendicular to its radius, larger farther from the centroid; ④ the two are added as vectors bolt by bolt, and the corner bolts on the load side take the most.
  9. Step 9 · Try M16

    Why this step: This guards against the most heavily loaded bolt shearing off. If the worst bolt does not fail, the whole group is adequate in shear.

    Effective area Ae=157A_e=157 gives single-shear resistance 58.875, above maximum demand.

    New symbols in this step
    • PsP_s, PbbP_{bb}, PbsP_{bs}, PtP_t: Shear, bolt bearing, plate bearing and plate tension resistances; kN
    • psp_s, pbbp_{bb}, pbsp_{bs}, pyp_y: Corresponding course design strengths; N/mm²
    Ps=psAs=375(157)/1000=58.875 kN>45.069 kNP_s=p_sA_s={\htmlClass{read}{375}}({\htmlClass{read}{157}})/1000=58.875\ \mathrm{kN}>45.069\ \mathrm{kN}
    Ps=psAs=375(157)/1000=58.875 kN>45.069 kN\begin{aligned}P_s&=p_sA_s\\&={\htmlClass{read}{375}}({\htmlClass{read}{157}})/1000\\&=58.875\ \mathrm{kN}\\&>45.069\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}

    Units: psp_s is in N/mm² and AsA_s is in mm², so the product is in N; dividing by 1000 gives kN, ready to compare with the combined force.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 4 · Bolt tables
    The M16 row gives tensile stress area As = 157 mm²; the Grade 8.8 row gives ps = 375 N/mm².
    The M16 row gives tensile stress area As=157 mm2A_s=157\ \mathrm{mm^{2}}; the Grade 8.8 row gives ps=375 N/mm2p_s=375\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
  10. Step 10 · Retain the problem's scope

    Why this step: A bolt that does not shear off can still crush the hole wall. Plate bearing needs the plate thickness and end distance, so the conclusion here covers shear only.

    The lecturer states that end distances ee, column dimensions and other bearing data are absent. This completes bolt selection for the given shear demand only; it does not imply eccentric connections need no bearing check.

Conclusion

The distinction between whole-bracket and one-side loads is the key correction. M16 passes the displayed shear demand only. Plate bearing PbsP_{bs} and complete detailing require further data.

All the symbols of this example

SymbolsMeaning and Units
FF, FsF_s, FTF_TTotal force, shear per bolt and tension per bolt; kN
PsP_s, PbbP_{bb}, PbsP_{bs}, PtP_tShear, bolt bearing, plate bearing and plate tension resistances; kN
dd, d0d_0, ee, lel_eBolt diameter, hole diameter, end distance along force and clear hole spacing; mm
AsA_s, AgA_g, AnA_n, AeA_eBolt effective shear area and gross/net/effective plate areas; mm²
psp_s, pbbp_{bb}, pbsp_{bs}, pyp_yCorresponding course design strengths; N/mm²
MM, rr, Σr2\Sigma r^{2}Eccentric moment kNmm, radius mm, sum of squared distances mm²
pp, nnBolt spacing along the force, mm; number of bolts

Video positions: 26 September 01:50:00 · 26 September 01:55:00 · 26 September 02:00:00 · 26 September 02:05:00

↑ Top