Worked Example

Q4: bracket-bolt shear, tension and interaction (Shear–Tension Interaction)

Task: Calculate demands in both directions, then compare each of the three course conditions.

Original question · Lecture notes Chapter 2, p. 45, 47 (Tutorial 2 Q4)
Original question with the given values boxed
Yellow boxes: values the question gives, the same values marked yellow in the Given table below.

The question in short: A bracket is fixed by 12 M20 bolts in two rows of 6. It carries a dead load of 200 kN and an imposed load of 150 kN with an eccentricity of 250 mm. Decide whether the bolts are adequate when sheared and pulled at the same time.

What differs from the previous example of this type: Unlike Q3, the eccentricity here tips the bracket outwards, so the upper bolts are pulled. The bolts take shear and tension together, which needs one extra combined check.

GivenValue and Unit
LoadingDL200, LL150 kN; eccentricity 250 mm
Bolts12 M20 bolts, Grade 8.8, in two rows; As=245 mm2\htmlClass{read}{A_s=245\ \mathrm{mm^{2}}}; ps=375\htmlClass{read}{p_s=375}, pt=560 N/mm2\htmlClass{read}{p_t=560\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}}
LayoutSix bolts per row, vertical spacing 5 @ 60 mm
ModelThe lecturer takes the bottom as rotation reference and tension proportional to yy

Yellow: values given in the question. The same values are marked where they are substituted in the steps below.
Orange box: values read directly from the Data File, the same values boxed orange in the lookup screenshots. A value interpolated between two table rows is a calculation, so it has no box.

Solution Route: Design force→direct shear FsF_s→moment/squared-distance sum→top-bolt tension→individual capacities→interaction.

Interactive 3D model · drag to turn

This browser cannot show the 3D model.

The bracket end plate is bolted to the column flange face with 12 bolts. The eccentric load tends to rotate the bracket about the bottom row: besides shear, each bolt takes tension proportional to its distance from that axis (red arrows), largest at the top row.Yellow: values given in the question; orange box: values read from the Data File; white: calculated results; red arrows: forces.
Load path · the stations the force passes through, in order

The load passes from the bracket through 12 bolts into the column flange. The bolts take two actions at once: direct shear, and tension from the moment of the eccentric load. Each is checked alone, then together.

  1. Design load
    F=520 kNF=520\ \mathrm{kN} at 250 mm eccentricity
    Step 1
  2. Bolt shear (shared by 12)
    Demand 43.333 kNCapacity 91.875 kNper bolt
    Utilisation 0.47
    Step 2–6
  3. Tension in the top row
    Demand 98.485 kNCapacity 109.76 kNper bolt
    Utilisation 0.90
    Step 3–6
  4. Shear and tension together (limit 1.4)
    Sum 1.369Limit 1.4
    closest to the limit
    Step 7
  5. Column flange
    Receives the shear and tension from the bolts
    Step 1
Red frame: the station closest to its limit. Each station links to the step that calculates it. Press “Show on the 3D model” to light up that part of the model above; press again to clear.
  1. Step 1 · Design force

    Why this step: The loads given have not yet been multiplied by load factors. Scaling them up first gives the design force the bolts must really resist.

    All twelve bolts carry the group load here. Do not retain Q3's one-side division by 2.

    New symbols in this step
    • FF, FsF_s, FTF_T: Total force, shear per bolt and tension per bolt; kN
    • GkG_k, QkQ_k: Unfactored dead and imposed loads; kN
    F=1.4Gk+1.6Qk=1.4(200)+1.6(150)=520 kNF=1.4G_k+1.6Q_k=1.4({\htmlClass{given}{200}})+1.6({\htmlClass{given}{150}})=520\ \mathrm{kN}
    F=1.4Gk+1.6Qk=1.4(200)+1.6(150)=520 kN\begin{aligned}F&=1.4G_k+1.6Q_k\\&=1.4({\htmlClass{given}{200}})+1.6({\htmlClass{given}{150}})\\&=520\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 26 September 02:19:58

  2. Step 2 · Direct shear

    Why this step: The load pushes along the contact face and tries to cut each bolt across. This step finds how much of that force each bolt must resist.

    Find demand per bolt using this problem's distribution assumption.

    New symbols in this step
    • pp, nn: Bolt spacing along the force, mm; number of bolts
    Fs=F/n=520/12=43.333 kNF_s=F/n=520/{\htmlClass{given}{12}}=43.333\ \mathrm{kN}

    Where the numbers come from: 520520 from Step 1.

  3. Step 3 · Rotation geometry

    Why this step: When the bracket tips outwards about its bottom, higher bolts are stretched more. The distance of each row from the bottom row is listed first, to share out the tension in the next step.

    The bottom row, y=0y=0, gives no tension moment in this model; the other five levels have two bolts each, at 60, 120, 180, 240 and 300 mm above it (vertical spacing 60 mm).

    yi=60, 120, 180, 240, 300 mm∑yi2=2(602+1202+1802+2402+3002)=396000 mm2\begin{aligned}y_i&={\htmlClass{given}{60}},\ 120,\ 180,\ 240,\ {\htmlClass{given}{300}}\ \mathrm{mm}\\\sum y_i^2&=2({\htmlClass{given}{60}}^2+120^2+180^2+240^2+{\htmlClass{given}{300}}^2)=396000\ \mathrm{mm^2}\end{aligned}
    yi=60, 120, 180, 240, 300 mm∑yi2=2(602+1202+1802+2402+3002)=396000 mm2\begin{aligned}y_i&={\htmlClass{given}{60}},\ 120,\ 180,\ 240,\ {\htmlClass{given}{300}}\ \mathrm{mm}\\\sum y_i^2&=2({\htmlClass{given}{60}}^2+120^2+180^2+240^2+{\htmlClass{given}{300}}^2)\\&=396000\ \mathrm{mm^2}\end{aligned}

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 26 September 02:14:06

  4. Step 4 · Maximum tension

    Why this step: The top row is farthest from the bottom, so it is pulled the most. If the bolts in this row do not snap, those in the lower rows will not either.

    Bolt tension FtF_t moments balance external moment F×eF\times e. Proportional distribution gives FT,i=Feyi/Σy2F_{T,i}=Fey_i/\Sigma y^{2}.

    FT,max=Feymax∑yi2=520(250)(300)/396000≈98.485 kNF_{T,max}=\frac{Fey_{max}}{\sum y_i^2}=520({\htmlClass{given}{250}})({\htmlClass{given}{300}})/396000\approx98.485\ \mathrm{kN}
    FT,max=Feymax∑yi2=520(250)(300)/396000≈98.485 kN\begin{aligned}F_{T,max}&=\frac{Fey_{max}}{\sum y_i^2}\\&=520({\htmlClass{given}{250}})({\htmlClass{given}{300}})/396000\\&\approx98.485\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 520520 from Step 1; 396000396000 from Step 3.

    Load path · How the moment becomes tension in the bolts
    Column flangeF = 520 kNe = 250Pivot row: no tension19.7 kN39.4 kN59.1 kN78.8 kN98.5 kN5 @ 60 = 300Applied moment: Fe = 520 × 250 = 130000 kNmmTwo bolts per row; values are per boltTension is proportional to the distance yTop row: FT,max​ = 98.485 kN
    The eccentric load turns the bracket about the bottom row of bolts. The farther a bolt is from this line, the harder it is pulled, so the tensions form a triangle with the largest at the top row. The moments of all the bolt tensions about the line add up to the applied moment Fe.
  5. Step 5 · Calculate both resistances separately

    Why this step: Being cut across and being pulled apart are two different ways for a bolt to fail, each with its own strength. So two capacities are worked out.

    PsP_s uses psp_s; course PnomP_{nom} uses 0.8ptAs. The 0.8 does not reduce the external load.

    New symbols in this step
    • PsP_s, PbbP_{bb}, PbsP_{bs}, PtP_t: Shear, bolt bearing, plate bearing and plate tension resistances; kN
    • psp_s, pbbp_{bb}, pbsp_{bs}, pyp_y: Corresponding course design strengths; N/mm²
    Ps=psAs=375(245)/1000=91.875 kNPnom=0.8ptAs=0.8(560)(245)/1000=109.76 kN\begin{aligned}P_s&=p_sA_s={\htmlClass{read}{375}}({\htmlClass{read}{245}})/1000=91.875\ \mathrm{kN}\\P_{nom}&=0.8p_tA_s=0.8({\htmlClass{read}{560}})({\htmlClass{read}{245}})/1000=109.76\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}
    Ps=psAs=375(245)/1000=91.875 kNPnom=0.8ptAs=0.8(560)(245)/1000=109.76 kN\begin{aligned}P_s&=p_sA_s\\&={\htmlClass{read}{375}}({\htmlClass{read}{245}})/1000\\&=91.875\ \mathrm{kN}\\P_{nom}&=0.8p_tA_s\\&=0.8({\htmlClass{read}{560}})({\htmlClass{read}{245}})/1000\\&=109.76\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}

    Units: psp_s and ptp_t are in N/mm² and AsA_s is in mm², so each product is in N; both lines divide by 1000 to give kN.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 4 · Bolt tables
    The M20 row gives tensile stress area As = 245 mm²; the Grade 8.8 row gives ps = 375 N/mm² and pt = 560 N/mm².
    The M20 row gives tensile stress area As=245 mm2A_s=245\ \mathrm{mm^{2}}; the Grade 8.8 row gives ps=375 N/mm2p_s=375\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}} and pt=560 N/mm2p_t=560\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 26 September 02:14:06

  6. Step 6 · Check individual limits first

    Why this step: First confirm that shear alone does not cut the bolt and tension alone does not snap it. If either one fails, the bolt is already inadequate.

    43.333<91.875 and 98.485<109.76, so both individual checks pass.

    Fs=43.333<Ps=91.875 kN,FT,max=98.485<Pnom=109.76 kNF_s=43.333<P_s=91.875\ \mathrm{kN},\qquad F_{T,max}=98.485<P_{nom}=109.76\ \mathrm{kN}
    Fs=43.333<Ps=91.875 kNFT,max=98.485<Pnom=109.76 kN\begin{aligned}F_s&=43.333<P_s=91.875\ \mathrm{kN}\\F_{T,max}&=98.485<P_{nom}=109.76\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}
  7. Step 7 · Then check interaction

    Why this step: The same bolt is sheared and pulled at once, and each force uses up part of its strength. So the two utilisations are added together and checked.

    Do not omit interaction because the separate checks pass. The course limit 1.4 belongs specifically to this bolt expression.

    FsPs+FT,maxPnom=43.33391.875+98.485109.76≈1.369<1.4\frac{F_s}{P_s}+\frac{F_{T,max}}{P_{nom}}=\frac{43.333}{91.875}+\frac{98.485}{109.76}\approx1.369<1.4
    FsPs+FT,maxPnom=43.33391.875+98.485109.76≈1.369<1.4\begin{aligned}\frac{F_s}{P_s}+\frac{F_{T,max}}{P_{nom}}&=\frac{43.333}{91.875}+\frac{98.485}{109.76}\\&\approx1.369\\&<1.4\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 43.33343.333 from Step 2; 91.87591.875 from Step 5; 98.48598.485 from Step 4; 109.76109.76 from Step 5.

    Load path · Checking shear and tension together
    Fs​/Ps​FT​/Pnom​1.00.41.00.40.472 + 0.897 = 1.369Limit of 1.4 on the sumShear: 43.333 / 91.875 ≈ 0.472 ≤ 1Tension: 98.485 / 109.76 ≈ 0.897 ≤ 1Sum: 1.369 ≤ 1.4
    The horizontal axis is the share used by shear and the vertical axis the share used by tension. The green area is the allowed range: neither above 1, and their sum not above 1.4. The point for this example (red) is inside, but close to the sloping edge.
Conclusion

The displayed shear, tension and interaction checks all pass, with interaction close to its limit. Do not transfer 1.4 to column expressions requiring ≤1.

All the symbols of this example

SymbolsMeaning and Units
FF, FsF_s, FTF_TTotal force, shear per bolt and tension per bolt; kN
PsP_s, PbbP_{bb}, PbsP_{bs}, PtP_tShear, bolt bearing, plate bearing and plate tension resistances; kN
dd, d0d_0, ee, lel_eBolt diameter, hole diameter, end distance along force and clear hole spacing; mm
AsA_s, AgA_g, AnA_n, AeA_eBolt effective shear area and gross/net/effective plate areas; mm²
psp_s, pbbp_{bb}, pbsp_{bs}, pyp_yCorresponding course design strengths; N/mm²
GkG_k, QkQ_kUnfactored dead and imposed loads; kN
pp, nnBolt spacing along the force, mm; number of bolts

Video positions: 26 September 02:10:00 · 26 September 02:15:00 · 26 September 02:20:00

↑ Top