Worked Example

65×50×8 angle: centroid and unequal weld lengths (Unequal Weld Lengths)

Task: Follow the lecturer from total force to weld length, then divide between sides by moment equilibrium.

Original question · Lecture notes Chapter 2, p. 38 (Example 6)
Original question with the given values boxed
Yellow boxes: values the question gives, the same values marked yellow in the Given table below.

The question in short: A 65×50×8 angle carries a tension from a dead load of 60 kN and an imposed load of 70 kN, and is fixed with 6 mm fillet welds. Its centroid is 21.1 mm and 43.9 mm from the two edges. Decide the weld length on each side.

What differs from the previous example of this type: The method is the same as the previous example, but here only the welds are designed and the tension capacity of the angle is not worked out. The angle size, leg size and centroid distances all differ, so the earlier figures cannot be reused.

GivenValue and Unit
Question dataDL 60, LL 70 kN; 65×50×8 angle, S355
WeldingTry a 6 mm fillet weld; class 42 electrode, pw=250 N/mm2\htmlClass{read}{p_w=250\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}}
CentroidFrom the figure: connected width 65 mm; centroid 21.1 and 43.9 mm from the two edges

Yellow: values given in the question. The same values are marked where they are substituted in the steps below.
Orange box: values read directly from the Data File, the same values boxed orange in the lookup screenshots. A value interpolated between two table rows is a calculation, so it has no box.

Data file lookup · Data Page 12 · Unequal Angles
65×50×8 angle: the table gives cx = 2.12 cm = 21.2 mm. The figure in the question already gives 21.1 mm and 43.9 mm, so the example uses them; the 0.1 mm difference does not change the weld lengths chosen.
65×50×8 angle: the table gives cx=2.12 cm=21.2 mmc_x=2.12\ \mathrm{cm}=21.2\ \mathrm{mm}. The figure in the question already gives 21.1 mm and 43.9 mm, so the example uses them; the 0.1 mm difference does not change the weld lengths chosen.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
Effective throat a ≈ 0.7sLeg size sqw = 0.7 s pw/1000 (kN/mm)
Supplementary schematic for understanding; not to scale.

Solution Route: FF→resistance per millimetre→total effective length LwL_w→side allocation→end allowance→actual lengths.

Interactive 3D model · drag to turn

This browser cannot show the 3D model.

The centroid is 21.1 mm from side XX and 43.9 mm from side YY. Taking moments about the centroid, the nearer side XX takes more force and gets 140 mm of weld; side YY gets 75 mm. Both include the 2s=12 mm2s=12\ \mathrm{mm} end allowance.Yellow: values given in the question; orange box: values read from the Data File; white: calculated results; red arrows: forces.
Load path · the stations the force passes through, in order

The tension acts along the centroid line. Side XX is only 21.1 mm from the centroid, so its weld carries more force and is longer.

  1. Design tension
    F=196 kNF=196\ \mathrm{kN}
    Step 1
  2. Angle 65×50×8
    Carries the force to the two welds; this example sizes the welds only
    Step 2
  3. Weld on side XX (nearer the centroid)
    Needs 138.07 mmUse 140 mm
    Step 3–5
  4. Weld on side YY (farther away)
    Needs 72.59 mmUse 75 mm
    Step 3–5
  5. Connecting plate
    Receives the whole 196 kN from the two welds
    Step 2
Each station links to the step that calculates it. Press “Show on the 3D model” to light up that part of the model above; press again to clear.
  1. Step 1 · Design force and resistance per millimetre

    Why this step: Two figures are prepared here: the factored tension the welds must pass on, and the force the throat of each millimetre of weld can carry. Dividing one by the other in the next step gives the weld length.

    Convert leg to throat aa with 0.7. Keep force and unit-length resistance consistently in kN.

    New symbols in this step
    • PP, FF: Applied force; kN
    • GkG_k, QkQ_k: Unfactored dead and imposed loads; kN
    F=1.4Gk+1.6Qk=1.4(60)+1.6(70)=196 kNqw=0.7spw=0.7(6)(250)/1000=1.05 kN/mm\begin{aligned}F&=1.4G_k+1.6Q_k=1.4({\htmlClass{given}{60}})+1.6({\htmlClass{given}{70}})=196\ \mathrm{kN}\\q_w&=0.7sp_w=0.7({\htmlClass{given}{6}})({\htmlClass{read}{250}})/1000=1.05\ \mathrm{kN/mm}\end{aligned}
    F=1.4Gk+1.6Qk=1.4(60)+1.6(70)=196 kNqw=0.7spw=0.7(6)(250)/1000=1.05 kN/mm\begin{aligned}F&=1.4G_k+1.6Q_k\\&=1.4({\htmlClass{given}{60}})+1.6({\htmlClass{given}{70}})\\&=196\ \mathrm{kN}\\q_w&=0.7sp_w\\&=0.7({\htmlClass{given}{6}})({\htmlClass{read}{250}})/1000\\&=1.05\ \mathrm{kN/mm}\end{aligned}

    Units: Leg size in mm times 0.7 gives the throat in mm; times pwp_w in N/mm² gives N per mm. Dividing by 1000 gives kN/mm, matching the tension in kN.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 3 · Design strength of fillet weld pwp_w
    For S355 steel with class 42 electrodes the fillet weld design strength is pw = 250 N/mm².
    For S355 steel with class 42 electrodes the fillet weld design strength is pw=250 N/mm2p_w=250\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
  2. Step 2 · Total effective length

    Why this step: If the welds together have less load-carrying length than this, the throat will shear. It is the total that the next step shares between the two sides.

    This is the total of both lines, not each line.

    New symbols in this step
    • pwp_w, qwq_w: Weld design strength N/mm²; resistance per millimetre kN/mm
    • LL, LeffL_{eff}: Actual or effective weld length; mm, as identified by each step
    L=F/qw=196/1.05=186.667 mmL=F/q_w=196/1.05=186.667\ \mathrm{mm}

    Where the numbers come from: 196196 from Step 1; 1.051.05 from Step 1.

  3. Step 3 · Establish equilibrium

    Why this step: The turning effects of the two weld forces about the centroid must cancel. Then their combined force lines up with the pull in the angle and the joint gets no extra twist.

    Side XX is nearer the centroid, with lever arm 21.1, so it carries more force. For equal leg sizes ss, force is proportional to effective length LwL_w.

    LXcX=LYcY: LX(21.1)=LY(43.9),LX+LY=L=186.667L_Xc_X=L_Yc_Y:\ L_X({\htmlClass{given}{21.1}})=L_Y({\htmlClass{given}{43.9}}),\qquad L_X+L_Y=L=186.667
    LXcX=LYcY: LX(21.1)=LY(43.9)LX+LY=L=186.667\begin{aligned}L_Xc_X&=L_Yc_Y:\ L_X({\htmlClass{given}{21.1}})=L_Y({\htmlClass{given}{43.9}})\\L_X+L_Y&=L=186.667\end{aligned}

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 26 September 02:39:05

  4. Step 4 · Solve the two lengths

    Why this step: The solution gives a clearly longer weld on side XX, matching the fact that it is nearer the centroid and takes more force. The two lengths still add up to the total effective length.

    Substitute into the two simple algebraic equations to obtain unequal lengths.

    New symbols in this step
    • cXc_X, cYc_Y: Distances from the two welds to the angle centroid; mm
    LX=LcYcX+cY=186.667(43.9)/65≈126.07 mmLY=L−LX≈60.59 mm\begin{aligned}L_X&=L\frac{c_Y}{c_X+c_Y}=186.667({\htmlClass{given}{43.9}})/{\htmlClass{given}{65}}\approx126.07\ \mathrm{mm}\\L_Y&=L-L_X\approx60.59\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}
    LX=LcYcX+cY=186.667(43.9)/65≈126.07 mmLY=L−LX≈60.59 mm\begin{aligned}L_X&=L\frac{c_Y}{c_X+c_Y}\\&=186.667({\htmlClass{given}{43.9}})/{\htmlClass{given}{65}}\\&\approx126.07\ \mathrm{mm}\\L_Y&=L-L_X\approx60.59\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 186.667186.667 from Step 2.

    Load path · How the two welds share the tension
    F = 196 kNFX​ ≈ 132.4 kNFY​ ≈ 63.6 kNcX​ = 21.1cY​ = 43.9LX​ = 126.07 mmLY​ = 60.59 mmWeld on side X (heel)Weld on side Y (toe)Centroid as in the question65×50×8 angle (connected leg in plan): total effective weld length L = 186.667 mmMoments about the centroid: FX cX​ = FY cY​; the nearer side carries more.LX​ = L × cY​ / (cX​ + cY​) = 186.667 × 43.9 / 65 = 126.07 mm
    The tension acts on the centroid line. The moments of the two weld forces about the centroid must cancel, so side XX, nearer the centroid, carries more force and needs the longer weld. Lengths shown are effective lengths, before adding 2s2s.
  5. Step 5 · Convert to actual lengths

    Why this step: The calculated values are effective lengths only. A short piece at each end of a weld is not counted, so each length is increased and then rounded up, never down.

    Add 2s=12 mm2s=12\ \mathrm{mm} to each. The lecturer selects 140 and 75 mm respectively.

    New symbols in this step
    • ss, aa: Leg size and effective throat; mm, with a≈0.7sa\approx0.7s in this course
    LX,actual≥LX+2s=126.07+2(6)=138.07→140 mmLY,actual≥LY+2s=60.59+2(6)=72.59→75 mm\begin{aligned}L_{X,actual}&\ge L_X+2s=126.07+2({\htmlClass{given}{6}})=138.07\to140\ \mathrm{mm}\\L_{Y,actual}&\ge L_Y+2s=60.59+2({\htmlClass{given}{6}})=72.59\to75\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}
    LX,actual≥LX+2s=126.07+2(6)=138.07→140 mmLY,actual≥LY+2s=60.59+2(6)=72.59→75 mm\begin{aligned}L_{X,actual}&\ge L_X+2s\\&=126.07+2({\htmlClass{given}{6}})\\&=138.07\to140\ \mathrm{mm}\\L_{Y,actual}&\ge L_Y+2s\\&=60.59+2({\htmlClass{given}{6}})\\&=72.59\to75\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 126.07126.07 from Step 4; 60.5960.59 from Step 4.

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 26 September 02:44:04

  6. Step 6 · Detailing comparison

    Why this step: If a weld is too short, or short compared with the spacing between the two welds, the force cannot spread evenly into the angle. The chosen lengths are therefore compared with the detailing requirements.

    Provided lengths must also satisfy course minimum-length and weld-spacing conditions. A 12 mm end allowance does not replace every detailing check.

Conclusion

The centroid distances 21.1/43.9 differ from the later 65×50×6 double-angle values 20.4/44.6. Equal nominal width does not justify copying centroid positions.

All the symbols of this example

SymbolsMeaning and Units
ss, aaLeg size and effective throat; mm, with a≈0.7sa\approx0.7s in this course
pwp_w, qwq_wWeld design strength N/mm²; resistance per millimetre kN/mm
LL, LeffL_{eff}Actual or effective weld length; mm, as identified by each step
PP, FFApplied force; kN
ee, rrEccentricity and weld-group corner radius; mm
GkG_k, QkQ_kUnfactored dead and imposed loads; kN
cXc_X, cYc_YDistances from the two welds to the angle centroid; mm

Video positions: 26 September 02:40:00 · 26 September 02:45:00

↑ Top