Worked Example

Simple-construction column: how beam reactions produce moments (Beam Reactions into Columns)

Task: Connect the load line, column centre, segment stiffnesses and section interaction expression.

Original question · Lecture notes Chapter 4, p. 25–26 (Example 3)
Original question with the given values boxed
Yellow boxes: values the question gives, the same values marked yellow in the Given table below.

The question in short: A main beam delivers reactions of 42 kN and 320 kN to the side of a 203×203×60 UC column, not at its centre, so the column bends. The column lengths above and below are 6000 and 3000 mm. Find the column moment and do the section check.

What differs from the previous example of this type: In the previous example the column lengths above and below had equal stiffness and shared the moment equally. Here their lengths differ; the shorter length is stiffer and takes the larger share of the moment.

GivenValue and Unit
Section203×203×60 UC, S355; D=209.6 mm\htmlClass{read}{D=209.6\ \mathrm{mm}}
Beam-end reactionMain beam R22: dead 42 kN, imposed 320 kN (factored, from the loading table)
Column segmentsSame section; upper and lower lengths 6000 and 3000 mm
Data for the checkTotal axial load 272 + 832 kN (loading table); amplification factor 1.15; Ag=76.4 cm2\htmlClass{read}{A_g=76.4\ \mathrm{cm^{2}}}; Sx=656\htmlClass{read}{S_x=656}, Zx=584 cm3\htmlClass{read}{Z_x=584\ \mathrm{cm^{3}}}; py=355\htmlClass{read}{p_y=355}

Yellow: values given in the question. The same values are marked where they are substituted in the steps below.
Orange box: values read directly from the Data File, the same values boxed orange in the lookup screenshots. A value interpolated between two table rows is a calculation, so it has no box.

Data file lookup · Data Page 11 · Universal Columns — Dimensions
203×203×60 UC: D = 209.6 mm, T = 14.2 mm.
203×203×60 UC: D=209.6 mmD=209.6\ \mathrm{mm}, T=14.2 mmT=14.2\ \mathrm{mm}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
Data file lookup · Data Page 11 · Universal Columns — Properties
203×203×60 UC: Zx = 584 cm³, Sx = 656 cm³, A = 76.4 cm².
203×203×60 UC: Zx=584 cm3Z_x=584\ \mathrm{cm^{3}}, Sx=656 cm3S_x=656\ \mathrm{cm^{3}}, A=76.4 cm2A=76.4\ \mathrm{cm^{2}}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too

Solution Route: Eccentricity ee→joint moment→upper/lower distribution→amplified demand→section comparison.

Interactive 3D model · drag to turn

This browser cannot show the 3D model.

Simple construction: the beam reaction is taken 100 mm from the column face, so its eccentricity about the column centre is D/2+100≈205 mmD/2+100\approx205\ \mathrm{mm} and it causes MM = Re. The upper and lower lengths have the same section, so the moment is shared in proportion to stiffness (inversely to length): the shorter 3000 mm length takes more. Press − to see the whole column.Yellow: values given in the question; orange box: values read from the Data File; white: calculated results; red arrows: forces.
Load path · the stations the force passes through, in order

The beam reaction acts 100 mm from the column face, not at the column centre, so it causes a moment at the joint. The column lengths above and below share this moment in proportion to their stiffness.

  1. Beam reaction
    R=362 kNR=362\ \mathrm{kN}
    Step 2
  2. Eccentricity gives a joint moment
    e≈205 mme\approx205\ \mathrm{mm} → M≈74.2 kNmM\approx74.2\ \mathrm{kNm}
    Step 1–2
  3. Shared by the column lengths
    About 49.5 kNm in the shorter lower length; amplified to 56.925 kNm
    Step 3–4
  4. Cross-section check (axial force and moment)
    Sum 0.651Limit 1
    Step 5–6
Each station links to the step that calculates it. Press “Show on the 3D model” to light up that part of the model above; press again to clear.
  1. Step 1 · Measure eccentricity from the column centre

    Why this step: The beam sits on the side of the column, so its reaction does not pass through the column centre. The further the force is from the centre, the more it bends the column, so this distance is needed first.

    In simple construction the beam reaction RR is taken 100 mm from the column face (a rule in the lecture notes, not stated in the question); the eccentricity ee is measured from the column centre, so half the section depth is added. The lecturer rounds 204.8 to about 205 mm.

    e=D/2+100=209.6/2+100=204.8≈205 mme=D/2+100={\htmlClass{read}{209.6}}/2+100=204.8\approx205\ \mathrm{mm}
    e=D/2+100=209.6/2+100=204.8≈205 mm\begin{aligned}e&=D/2+100\\&={\htmlClass{read}{209.6}}/2+100\\&=204.8\\&\approx205\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 24 October 02:49:56

  2. Step 2 · Joint moment

    Why this step: The off-centre reaction acts like a spanner on the column. Force times distance is the moment it puts into the column at the beam joint, which the column lengths above and below then share.

    Convert mm to m before multiplying by kN.

    R=42+320=362 kNM=Re=362(0.205)≈74.2 kNm\begin{aligned}R&={\htmlClass{given}{42}}+{\htmlClass{given}{320}}=362\ \mathrm{kN}\\M&=Re=362(0.205)\approx74.2\ \mathrm{kNm}\end{aligned}

    Units: The eccentricity of 205 mm is divided by 1000 to give 0.205 m. kN times m gives kNm.

  3. Step 3 · Stiffness and distribution

    Why this step: When the joint rotates, the column lengths above and below resist together. The stiffer one is harder to bend and so takes more of the moment, just as the stiffer of two springs takes more force.

    For equal sections, rotational stiffness is proportional to 1/L1/L. The shorter segment is stiffer and takes more moment. Use the lecturer's segment labels to identify each share; the length in the numerator is not necessarily the receiving segment's own length.

    Mshort=MLlongLshort+Llong=74.260006000+3000≈49.5 kNmMlong=M−Mshort≈24.7 kNm\begin{aligned}M_{short}&=M\frac{L_{long}}{L_{short}+L_{long}}=74.2\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{6000}}}{{\htmlClass{given}{6000}}+{\htmlClass{given}{3000}}}\approx49.5\ \mathrm{kNm}\\M_{long}&=M-M_{short}\approx24.7\ \mathrm{kNm}\end{aligned}
    Mshort=MLlongLshort+Llong=74.260006000+3000≈49.5 kNmMlong=M−Mshort≈24.7 kNm\begin{aligned}M_{short}&=M\frac{L_{long}}{L_{short}+L_{long}}\\&=74.2\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{6000}}}{{\htmlClass{given}{6000}}+{\htmlClass{given}{3000}}}\\&\approx49.5\ \mathrm{kNm}\\M_{long}&=M-M_{short}\approx24.7\ \mathrm{kNm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 74.274.2 from Step 2.

    Load path · How a beam reaction bends the column
    xyR = 42 + 320 = 362 kNe = 104.8 + 100 ≈ 205Plan: ⊗ is the beam reaction (downwards)Lever arms measured from the column centre (mm)Elevation: joint moment sharedUpper 6 m: 24.7 kNmLower 3 m: 49.5 kNmM = Re = 362 × 0.205 ≈ 74.2 kNmShorter length is stiffer: 74.2 × 6000 / 9000 ≈ 49.5 kNm
    Left, the column seen from above: the beam reaction acts 100 mm from the column face, about 205 mm from the centre, so it causes a moment MM = Re about the xx axis. Right, the elevation: the joint moment is shared by the column lengths above and below, and the shorter, stiffer length takes more.
  4. Step 4 · Amplify governing demand

    Why this step: The check uses the hardest-worked place, which is the end of the shorter column length. The amplification factor then adds the extra moment that appears when the compressed column deforms.

    Use 1.15 here and the maximum end moment 49.5 for this demand.

    New symbols in this step
    • MxM_x, MyM_y, MLTM_{LT}: Two-axis and LTB governing moment demands; kNm
    Mx=1.15Mshort=1.15(49.5)=56.925 kNmM_x={\htmlClass{given}{1.15}}M_{short}={\htmlClass{given}{1.15}}(49.5)=56.925\ \mathrm{kNm}
    Mx=1.15Mshort=1.15(49.5)=56.925 kNm\begin{aligned}M_x&={\htmlClass{given}{1.15}}M_{short}\\&={\htmlClass{given}{1.15}}(49.5)\\&=56.925\ \mathrm{kNm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 49.549.5 from Step 3.

  5. Step 5 · Section axial-compression resistance

    Why this step: This is the force at which all the steel in the section is compressed to pyp_y, the limit for crushing the section. It is the denominator of the compression term in the next step.

    Convert 76.4 cm² to mm² first. This is a section check only; member buckling is separate.

    New symbols in this step
    • AgA_g, pyp_y, pcp_c: Gross area mm²; yield and compression buckling strengths N/mm²
    Agpy=76.4(100)(355)/1000=2712.2 kNA_gp_y={\htmlClass{read}{76.4}}(100)({\htmlClass{read}{355}})/1000=2712.2\ \mathrm{kN}
    Agpy=76.4(100)(355)/1000=2712.2 kN\begin{aligned}A_gp_y&={\htmlClass{read}{76.4}}(100)({\htmlClass{read}{355}})/1000\\&=2712.2\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}

    Units: AgA_g of 76.4 cm² is multiplied by 100 to change it into mm². pyp_y in N/mm² times mm² gives N, and dividing by 1000 gives kN.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 1 · Design strength pyp_y
    Flange T = 14.2 mm thick: the T ≤ 16 mm row, S355 column gives py = 355 N/mm².
    Flange T=14.2 mmT=14.2\ \mathrm{mm} thick: the T≤16 mmT\le16\ \mathrm{mm} row, S355 column gives py=355 N/mm2p_y=355\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}. How the grade and thickness choose this row →Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
  6. Step 6 · This section check

    Why this step: The column carries the compression from above together with the moment caused by the beam reaction. Each uses part of the section's strength; the total must be below 1 for the section not to be crushed.

    The section moment capacity McM_c is the smaller of pySx and 1.2pyZx; the total axial load FcF_c is 272 + 832 kN from the loading table.

    New symbols in this step
    • FcF_c, PcP_c: Design axial force and buckling compression resistance; kN
    • McxM_{cx}, McyM_{cy}, MbM_b: Corresponding bending resistances; kNm, with different section/member definitions
    Mcx=min⁡(pySx, 1.2pyZx)=min⁡(355(656), 1.2(355)(584))/1000≈232.9 kNmFc=272+832=1104 kNηs=FcAgpy+MxMcx=1104/2712.2+56.925/232.9≈0.651<1\begin{aligned}M_{cx}&=\min(p_yS_x,\ 1.2p_yZ_x)=\min({\htmlClass{read}{355}}({\htmlClass{read}{656}}),\ 1.2({\htmlClass{read}{355}})({\htmlClass{read}{584}}))/1000\approx232.9\ \mathrm{kNm}\\F_c&={\htmlClass{given}{272}}+{\htmlClass{given}{832}}=1104\ \mathrm{kN}\\\eta_s&=\frac{F_c}{A_gp_y}+\frac{M_x}{M_{cx}}=1104/2712.2+56.925/232.9\approx0.651<1\end{aligned}
    Mcx=min⁡(pySx, 1.2pyZx)=min⁡(355(656), 1.2(355)(584))/1000≈232.9 kNmFc=272+832=1104 kNηs=FcAgpy+MxMcx=1104/2712.2+56.925/232.9≈0.651<1\begin{aligned}M_{cx}&=\min(p_yS_x,\ 1.2p_yZ_x)\\&=\min({\htmlClass{read}{355}}({\htmlClass{read}{656}}),\\&\quad \ 1.2({\htmlClass{read}{355}})({\htmlClass{read}{584}}))/1000\\&\approx232.9\ \mathrm{kNm}\\F_c&={\htmlClass{given}{272}}+{\htmlClass{given}{832}}=1104\ \mathrm{kN}\\\eta_s&=\frac{F_c}{A_gp_y}+\frac{M_x}{M_{cx}}\\&=1104/2712.2+56.925/232.9\\&\approx0.651\\&<1\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 2712.22712.2 from Step 5; 56.92556.925 from Step 4.

    Units: SxS_x and ZxZ_x are multiplied by 1000 to change cm³ into mm³, and pyp_y times mm³ gives Nmm. Dividing by 1000000 gives kNm, so the formula divides by 1000.

    Load path · How the ratios add up
    Limit 1Cross-section0.4070.244≈ 0.651Axial termx-axis moment term
    This column has a moment about one axis only: blue is the share used by the axial force and green the share used by the moment. Together they must not pass the red dashed line.

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 24 October 02:44:56

Conclusion

The section passes. Effective lengths LeL_e, buckling strengths and corresponding member-check data are still needed for an overall column verdict. Equal moment halves apply only to equal stiffness.

All the symbols of this example

SymbolsMeaning and Units
FcF_c, PcP_cDesign axial force and buckling compression resistance; kN
AgA_g, pyp_y, pcp_cGross area mm²; yield and compression buckling strengths N/mm²
MxM_x, MyM_y, MLTM_{LT}Two-axis and LTB governing moment demands; kNm
SxS_x, SyS_y, ZxZ_x, ZyZ_yTwo-axis plastic/elastic moduli; convert the tabulated cm³
McxM_{cx}, McyM_{cy}, MbM_bCorresponding bending resistances; kNm, with different section/member definitions
ηs\eta_s, η1\eta_1, η2\eta_2Total utilisations for the section and two member expressions; dimensionless

Video positions: 24 October 02:45:00 · 24 October 02:50:00

↑ Top