Worked Example

6 m revision beam: coexisting shear and deflection (Coexistent Shear)

Task: Use overall maximum shear, shear at maximum moment and SLS loading separately.

The question in short: A 6 m beam uses a 406×178×74 UB in S355. The largest shear is 77.91 kN, the largest moment is 229.1 kNm with a shear of 74.80 kN at that point, and the imposed midspan point load is 47.25 kN. Check shear, moment and deflection.

What differs from the previous example of this type: The previous example was a local web check at a support. This one returns to whole-beam checks, and separates the largest shear in the beam from the shear at the point of largest moment.

GivenValue and Unit
ULSVmax=77.91 kN\htmlClass{given}{V_{max}=77.91\ \mathrm{kN}}; V=74.80 kN\htmlClass{given}{V=74.80\ \mathrm{kN}} where Mmax=229.1 kNm\htmlClass{given}{M_{max}=229.1\ \mathrm{kNm}} (lecturer’s worksheet)
Section406×178×74 UB, S355; D=412.8\htmlClass{read}{D=412.8}, t=9.5 mm\htmlClass{read}{t=9.5\ \mathrm{mm}}; Sx=1501\htmlClass{read}{S_x=1501}, Zx=1323 cm3\htmlClass{read}{Z_x=1323\ \mathrm{cm^{3}}}; Ix=27310 cm4\htmlClass{read}{I_x=27310\ \mathrm{cm^{4}}}; py=355\htmlClass{read}{p_y=355}
SLSMidspan P=47.25 kN\htmlClass{given}{P=47.25\ \mathrm{kN}}; L=6 m\htmlClass{given}{L=6\ \mathrm{m}}; E=205000 N/mm2\htmlClass{read}{E=205000\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}}

Yellow: values given in the question. The same values are marked where they are substituted in the steps below.
Orange box: values read directly from the Data File, the same values boxed orange in the lookup screenshots. A value interpolated between two table rows is a calculation, so it has no box.

Data file lookup · Data Page 9 · Universal Beams — Dimensions
406×178×74 UB: D = 412.8 mm, t = 9.5 mm; for a rolled section Av = tD.
406×178×74 UB: D=412.8 mmD=412.8\ \mathrm{mm}, t=9.5 mmt=9.5\ \mathrm{mm}; for a rolled section Av=tDA_v=tD.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
Data file lookup · Data Page 10 · Universal Beams — Properties
406×178×74 UB: Ix = 27310 cm⁴, Zx = 1323 cm³, Sx = 1501 cm³. The lecturer's moment candidates 532.9 = 355 × 1501/1000 and 563.6 = 1.2 × 355 × 1323/1000 kNm come from these values.
406×178×74 UB: Ix=27310 cm4I_x=27310\ \mathrm{cm^{4}}, Zx=1323 cm3Z_x=1323\ \mathrm{cm^{3}}, Sx=1501 cm3S_x=1501\ \mathrm{cm^{3}}. The lecturer's moment candidates 532.9 = 355 × 1501/1000 and 563.6 = 1.2 × 355 × 1323/1000 kNm come from these values.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too

Solution Route: Overall shear→low shear at maximum moment→bending→unfactored deflection Δ\Delta.

Load path · the stations the force passes through, in order

The beam takes the load to its two supports. Shear is largest at the supports and moment at midspan; each is checked with the values at its own position.

  1. Forces from the class sheet
    Vmax=77.91 kNV_{max}=77.91\ \mathrm{kN}; Mmax=229.1 kNmM_{max}=229.1\ \mathrm{kNm}
  2. Shear (supports)
    Demand 77.91 kNCapacity 803.77 kN
    Utilisation 0.10
  3. Bending (midspan)
    Demand 229.1 kNmCapacity 532.9 kNm
    Utilisation 0.43 · closest to the limit
  4. Deflection (SLS point load)
    Demand 3.8 mmCapacity 16.67 mm
    Utilisation 0.23
Red frame: the station closest to its limit. Each station links to the step that calculates it.
Load path · Load, shear force and bending moment
Loads and reactionsself-weightPRA​RB​3 m3 mShear force diagram V (kN)Vmax​ = 77.91−77.91V = 74.80Bending moment diagram M (kNm): sagging moment drawn below the lineMmax​ = 229.1 kNm
A sketch drawn from the VmaxV_{max}, VV and MmaxM_{max} of the class sheet, for a midspan point load with self-weight. The largest shear in the beam, 77.91 kN, is at the supports; the largest moment is at midspan, where the shear is 74.80 kN, the value used to judge low shear.
  1. Step 1 · Overall shear check

    Why this step: The section with the largest shear is the one most likely to fail in shear, so the largest shear in the beam is compared with the web's shear capacity.

    For a rolled section Av=tDA_v=tD; find VcV_c first, then compare it with the beam’s VmaxV_{max}.

    New symbols in this step
    • McM_c, VcV_c, MbM_b: Section bending resistance in kNm, shear resistance in kN, LTB resistance in kNm
    • AvA_v, II, SS, ZZ: Shear area mm², second moment of area mm⁴, plastic/elastic moduli mm³
    • pyp_y, pbp_b, EE: Design yield/bending buckling strength and elastic modulus; N/mm²
    Av=tD=9.5(412.8)=3921.6 mm2Vc=pyAv/3=355(3921.6)/(3 1000)≈803.77 kNVmax=77.91<Vc=803.77 kN\begin{aligned}A_v&=tD={\htmlClass{read}{9.5}}({\htmlClass{read}{412.8}})=3921.6\ \mathrm{mm^2}\\V_c&=p_yA_v/\sqrt3={\htmlClass{read}{355}}(3921.6)/(\sqrt3\,1000)\approx803.77\ \mathrm{kN}\\V_{max}&={\htmlClass{given}{77.91}}<V_c=803.77\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}
    Av=tD=9.5(412.8)=3921.6 mm2Vc=pyAv/3=355(3921.6)/(3 1000)≈803.77 kNVmax=77.91<Vc=803.77 kN\begin{aligned}A_v&=tD={\htmlClass{read}{9.5}}({\htmlClass{read}{412.8}})=3921.6\ \mathrm{mm^2}\\V_c&=p_yA_v/\sqrt3\\&={\htmlClass{read}{355}}(3921.6)/(\sqrt3\,1000)\\&\approx803.77\ \mathrm{kN}\\V_{max}&={\htmlClass{given}{77.91}}<V_c=803.77\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}

    Units: N/mm² times mm² gives N. Dividing by 1000 gives kN (1 kN is 1000 N), so it can be compared with the shear in kN.

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 14 November 01:54:50

  2. Step 2 · Coexisting shear

    Why this step: Shear weakens bending strength, but only at the same section. So the shear at the point of largest moment matters here, not the largest shear in the beam.

    Use 74.80 at the maximum-moment section to decide whether high-shear reduction is needed there.

    New symbols in this step
    • MM, VV: Moment demand in kNm; shear demand in kN
    V/Vc=74.80/803.77≈0.093<0.6V/V_c={\htmlClass{given}{74.80}}/803.77\approx0.093<0.6
    V/Vc=74.80/803.77≈0.093<0.6\begin{aligned}V/V_c&={\htmlClass{given}{74.80}}/803.77\\&\approx0.093\\&<0.6\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 803.77803.77 from Step 1.

  3. Step 3 · Bending

    Why this step: This guards against yielding at the section with the largest moment. The capacity is more than twice the demand, so the beam has plenty of margin in bending.

    Once the conditions are satisfied, select the smaller candidate and compare.

    Mc=min⁡(pySx, 1.2pyZx)=min⁡(355(1501), 1.2(355)(1323))/1000=min⁡(532.9, 563.6)=532.9 kNm>229.1 kNm\begin{aligned}M_c&=\min(p_yS_x,\ 1.2p_yZ_x)=\min({\htmlClass{read}{355}}({\htmlClass{read}{1501}}),\ 1.2({\htmlClass{read}{355}})({\htmlClass{read}{1323}}))/1000\\&=\min(532.9,\ 563.6)=532.9\ \mathrm{kNm}>{\htmlClass{given}{229.1}}\ \mathrm{kNm}\end{aligned}
    Mc=min⁡(pySx, 1.2pyZx)=min⁡(355(1501), 1.2(355)(1323))/1000=min⁡(532.9, 563.6)=532.9 kNm>229.1 kNm\begin{aligned}M_c&=\min(p_yS_x,\ 1.2p_yZ_x)\\&=\min({\htmlClass{read}{355}}({\htmlClass{read}{1501}}),\\&\quad \ 1.2({\htmlClass{read}{355}})({\htmlClass{read}{1323}}))/1000\\&=\min(532.9,\ 563.6)\\&=532.9\ \mathrm{kNm}\\&>{\htmlClass{given}{229.1}}\ \mathrm{kNm}\end{aligned}

    Units: N/mm² times cm³, divided by 1000, gives kNm: 1 cm³ is 1000 mm³ and 1 kNm is 1000000 Nmm, which together leave a division by 1000.

  4. Step 4 · Deflection units

    Why this step: This finds how far the beam sags at midspan under the everyday imposed load. With every value in N and mm, the answer comes out directly in mm.

    Use P=47250 NP=47250\ \mathrm{N}, L=6000 mmL=6000\ \mathrm{mm} and I=27310×10000 mm4I=27310\times10000\ \mathrm{mm^{4}}. PP is the SLS point load, not a ULS internal-action value.

    New symbols in this step
    • Δ\Delta, η\eta: Deflection mm; demand/resistance utilisation is dimensionless
    Δ=PL348EI=47250(6000)348(205000)(27310×104)≈3.80 mm\Delta=\frac{PL^3}{48EI}=\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{47250}}({\htmlClass{given}{6000}})^3}{48({\htmlClass{read}{205000}})({\htmlClass{read}{27310}}\times10^4)}\approx3.80\ \mathrm{mm}
    Δ=PL348EI=47250(6000)348(205000)(27310×104)≈3.80 mm\begin{aligned}\Delta&=\frac{PL^3}{48EI}\\&=\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{47250}}({\htmlClass{given}{6000}})^3}{48({\htmlClass{read}{205000}})({\htmlClass{read}{27310}}\times10^4)}\\&\approx3.80\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}

    Units: 47.25 kN times 1000 gives 47250 N and 6 m gives 6000 mm. IxI_x in cm⁴ times 10^4 gives mm⁴, because 1 cm is 10 mm, multiplied four times.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 1 · Steel properties
    Data Page 1, steel properties: modulus of elasticity E = 205000 N/mm² (printed as 205,000).
    Data Page 1, steel properties: modulus of elasticity E=205000 N/mm2E=205000\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}} (printed as 205,000).Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
  5. Step 5 · Limit

    Why this step: The sag is far below the limit, so the beam is stiff enough in use and will not make the floor dip noticeably or crack the finishes.

    L/360=16.67 mmL/360=16.67\ \mathrm{mm}.

    New symbols in this step
    • LL, RAR_A, RBR_B: Span in m or mm; end reactions in kN
    Δ=3.80<L/360=6000/360=16.67 mm\Delta=3.80<L/{\htmlClass{read}{360}}={\htmlClass{given}{6000}}/{\htmlClass{read}{360}}=16.67\ \mathrm{mm}
    Δ=3.80<L/360=6000/360=16.67 mm\begin{aligned}\Delta&=3.80\\&<L/{\htmlClass{read}{360}}\\&={\htmlClass{given}{6000}}/{\htmlClass{read}{360}}\\&=16.67\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}

    Units: The 6 m span times 1000 gives 6000 mm, because 1 m is 1000 mm; the limit is therefore in mm too.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 2 · Table 5.1 Deflection limits
    For beams carrying plaster or other brittle finish, the imposed-load deflection limit is span/360.
    For beams carrying plaster or other brittle finish, the imposed-load deflection limit is span/360.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
Conclusion

The checks shown pass. A complete design also needs the stability checks for the full load model in the original question.

All the symbols of this example

SymbolsMeaning and Units
qq, ww, PPArea load kN/m², line load kN/m, point load kN
LL, RAR_A, RBR_BSpan in m or mm; end reactions in kN
MM, VVMoment demand in kNm; shear demand in kN
McM_c, VcV_c, MbM_bSection bending resistance in kNm, shear resistance in kN, LTB resistance in kNm
DD, dd, tt, TTOverall depth, classification web depth, web thickness and flange thickness; mm
AvA_v, II, SS, ZZShear area mm², second moment of area mm⁴, plastic/elastic moduli mm³
pyp_y, pbp_b, EEDesign yield/bending buckling strength and elastic modulus; N/mm²
Δ\Delta, η\etaDeflection mm; demand/resistance utilisation is dimensionless

Video positions: 14 November 01:55:00

↑ Top