Worked Example

Eccentric weld Q6: from geometry to resultant (Eccentric Weld Group)

Task: Understand eccentricity ee, line-group second moments and vector combination rather than adding component magnitudes directly.

Original question · Lecture notes Chapter 2, p. 45, 48 (Tutorial 2 Q6)
Original question with the given values boxed
Yellow boxes: values the question gives, the same values marked yellow in the Given table below.

The question in short: A load (dead 350 kN, imposed 300 kN) acts 200 mm from the column face and is shared equally by two 20 mm side plates. Each plate is welded all round, 200 mm wide and 300 mm high. Find the force per mm at the most heavily loaded point of the weld and the leg size needed.

What differs from the previous example of this type: In the earlier examples the force passed through the centroid of the welds. Here the load sits to one side of the weld group, so the welds resist twisting as well as direct shear, and the two parts are combined by direction, not simply added.

GivenValue and Unit
LoadingDL 350, LL 300 kN; two 20 mm side plates each carry half
GeometryLoad 200 mm from the column face; each side plate is welded on four sides, weld group 200 mm wide and 300 mm high
MaterialS355, class 42 electrode; pw=250 N/mm2\htmlClass{read}{p_w=250\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}}

Yellow: values given in the question. The same values are marked where they are substituted in the steps below.
Orange box: values read directly from the Data File, the same values boxed orange in the lookup screenshots. A value interpolated between two table rows is a calculation, so it has no box.

Eccentricity e = 300 mm485 kN200 mm300 mmGreen rectangle: four weld linesCentroid at centre; total weld length 1000 mm
Supplementary schematic for understanding; not to scale.

Solution Route: Total design force→one-side force→centre/eccentricity ee→direct shear FsF_s→torsional component→resultant FRF_R→required leg size ss.

Interactive 3D model · drag to turn

This browser cannot show the 3D model.

Two side plates lap onto the outer faces of the two column flanges, each welded on four sides: a weld group 200 mm wide and 300 mm high. The load is 200 mm from the column face, e=300 mme=300\ \mathrm{mm} from the weld centroid, so the welds resist a torque as well as direct shear; the farthest corner (purple line rr) takes the largest resultant.Yellow: values given in the question; orange box: values read from the Data File; white: calculated results; red arrows: forces.
Load path · the stations the force passes through, in order

The load is first shared equally by the two side plates. The force on each plate misses the centroid of the weld group, so the welds resist a torque as well as direct shear.

  1. Design load
    970 kN, 485 kN per side plate
    Step 1
  2. Side plate: eccentricity gives a torque
    e=300 mme=300\ \mathrm{mm}, M=145500 kNmmM=145500\ \mathrm{kNmm}
    Step 2
  3. Weld group: direct shear
    0.485 kN/mm, uniform all round
    Step 3
  4. Weld group: torsional shear
    1.26 kN/mm at the farthest corner
    Step 4–6
  5. Resultant and leg size
    1.58 kN/mm; a leg of about 9.04 mm is needed
    Step 7–8
  6. Column flange
    Receives the load from the weld groups on both sides
    Step 1
Each station links to the step that calculates it. Press “Show on the 3D model” to light up that part of the model above; press again to clear.
  1. Step 1 · Total force and side allocation

    Why this step: The rest of the calculation looks at the weld group on one side plate only, so the factored force taken by one group must be known first.

    Combine loads to obtain 970 kN, then divide symmetrically into 485 kN per side.

    New symbols in this step
    • GkG_k, QkQ_k: Unfactored dead and imposed loads; kN
    Ptotal=1.4Gk+1.6Qk=1.4(350)+1.6(300)=970 kNP=Ptotal/2=970/2=485 kN\begin{aligned}P_{total}&=1.4G_k+1.6Q_k=1.4({\htmlClass{given}{350}})+1.6({\htmlClass{given}{300}})=970\ \mathrm{kN}\\P&=P_{total}/2=970/2=485\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}
    Ptotal=1.4Gk+1.6Qk=1.4(350)+1.6(300)=970 kNP=Ptotal/2=970/2=485 kN\begin{aligned}P_{total}&=1.4G_k+1.6Q_k\\&=1.4({\htmlClass{given}{350}})+1.6({\htmlClass{given}{300}})\\&=970\ \mathrm{kN}\\P&=P_{total}/2=970/2=485\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}
  2. Step 2 · Measure eccentricity from the centre

    Why this step: The load does not pass through the centroid of the weld group, so it tries to turn the group about that centroid. A larger eccentricity means a larger twisting moment, which is why the distance is measured to the centroid.

    200 mm reaches only the group edge; add half-width 100 mm.

    New symbols in this step
    • ee, rr: Eccentricity and weld-group corner radius; mm
    e=200+200/2=300 mm,M=Pe=485(300)=145500 kNmme={\htmlClass{given}{200}}+{\htmlClass{given}{200}}/2=300\ \mathrm{mm},\quad M=Pe=485(300)=145500\ \mathrm{kNmm}
    e=200+200/2=300 mmM=Pe=485(300)=145500 kNmm\begin{aligned}e&={\htmlClass{given}{200}}+{\htmlClass{given}{200}}/2=300\ \mathrm{mm}\\M&=Pe=485(300)=145500\ \mathrm{kNmm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 485485 from Step 1.

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 3 October Recording A 01:13:35

  3. Step 3 · Direct-shear distribution

    Why this step: This is the force the weld would feel if the load passed exactly through the centroid: the whole group is sheared together in the direction of the load, and every millimetre takes the same force.

    Each side plate is welded on four sides, so the total weld length is the perimeter of the weld group; sharing the load over that length gives kN per mm.

    New symbols in this step
    • ss, aa: Leg size and effective throat; mm, with a≈0.7sa\approx0.7s in this course
    • LL, LeffL_{eff}: Actual or effective weld length; mm, as identified by each step
    • PP, FF: Applied force; kN
    • bb, hh: Width and height of the rectangular weld group; mm
    L=2(b+h)=2(200+300)=1000 mmFs=P/L=485/1000=0.485 kN/mm\begin{aligned}L&=2(b+h)=2({\htmlClass{given}{200}}+{\htmlClass{given}{300}})=1000\ \mathrm{mm}\\F_s&=P/L=485/1000=0.485\ \mathrm{kN/mm}\end{aligned}
    L=2(b+h)=2(200+300)=1000 mmFs=P/L=485/1000=0.485 kN/mm\begin{aligned}L&=2(b+h)\\&=2({\htmlClass{given}{200}}+{\htmlClass{given}{300}})\\&=1000\ \mathrm{mm}\\F_s&=P/L\\&=485/1000\\&=0.485\ \mathrm{kN/mm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 485485 from Step 1.

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 3 October Recording A 01:18:46

  4. Step 4 · Rectangular line-group IxI_x

    Why this step: The second moment measures how far the weld lies from the centroid and so how well it resists turning. The farther out the weld is, the larger the value and the smaller the force caused by twisting.

    Width 200 and height 300 mm: add the two vertical lines' own second moments and the parallel-axis terms of the horizontal lines.

    New symbols in this step
    • IxI_x, IyI_y, IpI_p: Line-group second moments in this problem; mm³, Ip=Ix+IyI_p=I_x+I_y
    Ix=2h312+2b(h2)2=2300312+2(200)(1502)=13.5×106 mm3I_x=2\frac{h^3}{12}+2b\left(\frac h2\right)^2=2\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{300}}^3}{12}+2({\htmlClass{given}{200}})(150^2)=13.5\times10^6\ \mathrm{mm^3}
    Ix=2h312+2b(h2)2=2300312+2(200)(1502)=13.5×106 mm3\begin{aligned}I_x&=2\frac{h^3}{12}+2b\left(\frac h2\right)^2\\&=2\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{300}}^3}{12}+2({\htmlClass{given}{200}})(150^2)\\&=13.5\times10^6\ \mathrm{mm^3}\end{aligned}
  5. Step 5 · Rectangular line-group IyI_y

    Why this step: Under twisting the weld group turns in its own plane about the centroid, so distances in both directions matter. The two second moments are therefore added before the twisting force is worked out.

    Exchange horizontal and vertical roles, then add for IpI_p, consistent with the course's rounded 2.08×10⁷.

    Iy=2b312+2h(b2)2=2200312+2(300)(1002)=7.3333×106 mm3Ip=Ix+Iy=13.5×106+7.3333×106≈2.08333×107 mm3\begin{aligned}I_y&=2\frac{b^3}{12}+2h\left(\frac b2\right)^2=2\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{200}}^3}{12}+2({\htmlClass{given}{300}})(100^2)=7.3333\times10^6\ \mathrm{mm^3}\\I_p&=I_x+I_y=13.5\times10^6+7.3333\times10^6\approx2.08333\times10^7\ \mathrm{mm^3}\end{aligned}
    Iy=2b312+2h(b2)2=2200312+2(300)(1002)=7.3333×106 mm3Ip=Ix+Iy=13.5×106+7.3333×106≈2.08333×107 mm3\begin{aligned}I_y&=2\frac{b^3}{12}+2h\left(\frac b2\right)^2\\&=2\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{200}}^3}{12}+2({\htmlClass{given}{300}})(100^2)\\&=7.3333\times10^6\ \mathrm{mm^3}\\I_p&=I_x+I_y\\&=13.5\times10^6+7.3333\times10^6\\&\approx2.08333\times10^7\ \mathrm{mm^3}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 13.513.5 from Step 4.

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 3 October Recording A 01:24:50

  6. Step 6 · Line-group IpI_p

    Why this step: Twisting turns the weld about its centroid. Points farther from the centroid move more and take more force, so only the farthest corner needs checking; that is where the force from twisting is greatest.

    rr is the distance from the centroid of the weld group to the farthest corner: half width 100 mm, half height 150 mm. The course treats the welds as lines of unit throat aa, so IpI_p has units of mm³.

    r=1002+1502≈180.28 mmFt=PerIp=485(300)(180.28)2.08333×107≈1.26 kN/mm\begin{aligned}r&=\sqrt{100^2+150^2}\approx180.28\ \mathrm{mm}\\F_t&=\frac{Per}{I_p}=\frac{485(300)(180.28)}{2.08333\times10^7}\approx1.26\ \mathrm{kN/mm}\end{aligned}
    r=1002+1502≈180.28 mmFt=PerIp=485(300)(180.28)2.08333×107≈1.26 kN/mm\begin{aligned}r&=\sqrt{100^2+150^2}\approx180.28\ \mathrm{mm}\\F_t&=\frac{Per}{I_p}\\&=\frac{485(300)(180.28)}{2.08333\times10^7}\\&\approx1.26\ \mathrm{kN/mm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 485485 from Step 1; 2.083332.08333 from Step 5.

  7. Step 7 · Use the included angle for the resultant

    Why this step: The weld at the corner feels the direct shear and the twisting force at the same time. They point in different directions, so the true demand per millimetre is their combined force, found by taking direction into account.

    The two components do not act along one line. FtF_t is perpendicular to rr, and the cosine of its angle with the vertical FsF_s equals the half width 100 mm divided by rr.

    New symbols in this step
    • FsF_s, FtF_t, FRF_R: Direct, torsional and resultant force per millimetre; kN/mm
    cos⁡θ=100/r=100/180.28≈0.5547FR=Fs2+Ft2+2FsFtcos⁡θ=0.4852+1.262+2(0.485)(1.26)(0.5547)≈1.58 kN/mm\begin{aligned}\cos\theta&=100/r=100/180.28\approx0.5547\\F_R&=\sqrt{F_s^2+F_t^2+2F_sF_t\cos\theta}\\&=\sqrt{0.485^2+1.26^2+2(0.485)(1.26)(0.5547)}\approx1.58\ \mathrm{kN/mm}\end{aligned}
    cos⁡θ=100/r=100/180.28≈0.5547FR=Fs2+Ft2+2FsFtcos⁡θ=0.4852+1.262+2(0.485)(1.26)(0.5547)≈1.58 kN/mm\begin{aligned}\cos\theta&=100/r\\&=100/180.28\\&\approx0.5547\\F_R&=\sqrt{F_s^2+F_t^2+2F_sF_t\cos\theta}\\&=\sqrt{0.485^2+1.26^2+2(0.485)(1.26)(0.5547)}\\&\approx1.58\ \mathrm{kN/mm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 180.28180.28 from Step 6; 0.4850.485 from Step 3; 1.261.26 from Step 6.

    Load path · Eccentric load = direct shear + torsional shear
    ① Eccentric load② Direct shear③ Torsional shear④ Vector sum=+→Pe = 300P = 485 kNcentroidFs​ = 0.485 kN/mmFt​ = 1.26 kN/mm (farthest point)M = Pe = 145500 kNmmFR​ = 1.58 kN/mmsame at every pointlarger farther from the centroidcritical point: needs a leg of about 9.04 mm
    The method is the same as for an eccentric bolt group, with “force per bolt” replaced by “force per mm of weld”. The four corners are shown: ② the direct shear is the same all round; ③ the torsional shear is perpendicular to the radius and largest at the corners, the farthest points; ④ the corners on the load side take the largest resultant.
  8. Step 8 · Calculate required leg size

    Why this step: A larger leg size gives a thicker throat and more capacity per millimetre. Here the calculation is turned round to find the smallest leg at which the throat is just not sheared.

    With pw=250 N/mm2p_w=250\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}, convert force-per-millimetre demand into leg size ss. The lecturer does not select a final size in class.

    New symbols in this step
    • pwp_w, qwq_w: Weld design strength N/mm²; resistance per millimetre kN/mm
    sreq=FR0.7pw=1.58(1000)/(0.7(250))≈9.04 mms_{req}=\frac{F_R}{0.7p_w}=1.58(1000)/(0.7({\htmlClass{read}{250}}))\approx9.04\ \mathrm{mm}
    sreq=FR0.7pw=1.58(1000)/(0.7(250))≈9.04 mm\begin{aligned}s_{req}&=\frac{F_R}{0.7p_w}\\&=1.58(1000)/(0.7({\htmlClass{read}{250}}))\\&\approx9.04\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 1.581.58 from Step 7.

    Units: FRF_R is in kN/mm; multiplying by 1000 gives N/mm. Dividing by pwp_w in N/mm² gives the throat in mm, and dividing by 0.7 gives the leg size in mm.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 3 · Design strength of fillet weld pwp_w
    For S355 steel with class 42 electrodes the fillet weld design strength is pw = 250 N/mm².
    For S355 steel with class 42 electrodes the fillet weld design strength is pw=250 N/mm2p_w=250\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 3 October Recording B 01:18:08

Conclusion

Approximately 9.04 mm is the requirement. The provided leg must be at least this large, with plate-thickness and detailing checks completed.

All the symbols of this example

SymbolsMeaning and Units
ss, aaLeg size and effective throat; mm, with a≈0.7sa\approx0.7s in this course
pwp_w, qwq_wWeld design strength N/mm²; resistance per millimetre kN/mm
LL, LeffL_{eff}Actual or effective weld length; mm, as identified by each step
PP, FFApplied force; kN
ee, rrEccentricity and weld-group corner radius; mm
FsF_s, FtF_t, FRF_RDirect, torsional and resultant force per millimetre; kN/mm
IxI_x, IyI_y, IpI_pLine-group second moments in this problem; mm³, Ip=Ix+IyI_p=I_x+I_y
GkG_k, QkQ_kUnfactored dead and imposed loads; kN
bb, hhWidth and height of the rectangular weld group; mm

Video positions: 3 October Recording A 01:10:00 · 3 October Recording A 01:25:00 · 3 October Recording B 01:05:00 · 3 October Recording B 01:20:00

↑ Top