Worked Example

Q7: separate flange and web weld roles (Bracket Flange and Web Welds)

Task: Trace the change from assumed 8 mm to 10 mm and check the two weld groups separately.

Original question · Lecture notes Chapter 2, p. 45, 48 (Tutorial 2 Q7)
Original question with the given values boxed
Yellow boxes: values the question gives, the same values marked yellow in the Given table below.

The question in short: A 533×210×82 UB bracket carries an ultimate force of 600 kN at an eccentricity e=250 mme=250\ \mathrm{mm}. Flange welds of 10 mm and web welds of 6 mm are tried. Check separately that the flange welds can resist the moment and the web welds can resist the shear.

What differs from the previous example of this type: The previous example treated all the welds as one group sharing shear and twisting. Here the work is divided: flange welds take only the moment, web welds take only the shear, and a trial leg size is chosen first and then compared.

GivenValue and Unit
Question data533×210×82 UB bracket, S355; ultimate load 600 kN; e=250 mm\htmlClass{given}{e=250\ \mathrm{mm}}
GeometryFrom the figure: section depth 528.3 mm (lever arm DD of the couple); usable flange length 190 mm; web 340 mm on each side
WeldingClass 42 electrode, pw=250 N/mm2\htmlClass{read}{p_w=250\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}}; try 10 mm on the flanges and 6 mm on the web

Yellow: values given in the question. The same values are marked where they are substituted in the steps below.
Orange box: values read directly from the Data File, the same values boxed orange in the lookup screenshots. A value interpolated between two table rows is a calculation, so it has no box.

Data file lookup · Data Page 9 · Universal Beams — Dimensions
533×210×82 UB: D = 528.3 mm, the same as on the figure, used as the lever arm between the flange welds.
533×210×82 UB: D=528.3 mmD=528.3\ \mathrm{mm}, the same as on the figure, used as the lever arm between the flange welds.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too

Solution Route: Accept the specified force allocation→deduct effective length LwL_w for trial leg→force per millimetre→required leg→compare with trial.

Interactive 3D model · drag to turn

This browser cannot show the 3D model.

The bracket is cut from a 533×210×82 UB and welded to the column flange. As the question assumes, the moment PePe is resisted by a couple in the top and bottom flange welds, 528.3 mm apart, and the shear by the welds on both sides of the web.Yellow: values given in the question; orange box: values read from the Data File; white: calculated results; red arrows: forces.
Load path · the stations the force passes through, in order

The load passes from the bracket through the welds into the column flange. As the question assumes, the moment is resisted by a couple in the flange welds and the shear by the web welds.

  1. Ultimate load
    600 kN at 250 mm eccentricity
    Step 1
  2. Bracket: moment and shear
    M=150000 kNmmM=150000\ \mathrm{kNmm}; V=600 kNV=600\ \mathrm{kN}
    Step 1
  3. Flange welds resist the moment
    Needs leg 9.544 mmUse 10 mm
    Step 2–4
  4. Web welds resist the shear
    Needs leg 5.133 mmUse 6 mm
    Step 5–7
  5. Column flange
    Receives the forces from the welds
    Step 1
Each station links to the step that calculates it. Press “Show on the 3D model” to light up that part of the model above; press again to clear.
  1. Step 1 · State the model first

    Why this step: The force acts some distance away from the welded face, so besides shearing the bracket it also bends it. The moment is found first to show how much the flange welds must resist.

    Flange welds resist moment 600×250; web welds carry 600 kN shear. Do not repeatedly distribute the same load uniformly across every weld.

    M=Pe=600(250)=150000 kNmmM=Pe={\htmlClass{given}{600}}({\htmlClass{given}{250}})=150000\ \mathrm{kNmm}
    Load path · What each group of welds does
    Column flangeP = 600 kNe = 250pull ≈ 283.9 kNpush ≈ 283.9 kNWeb welds: shear 600 kND = 528.3[Flange welds resist the moment]M = Pe = 600 × 250 = 150000 kNmmCouple: M/D = 150000 / 528.3 ≈ 283.9 kN÷ 170 mm effective length ≈ 1.670 kN/mm[Web welds resist the shear]600 kN ÷ 668 mm ≈ 0.898 kN/mm
    The moment PePe is resisted by a pair of equal and opposite forces: the top flange weld in tension and the bottom flange weld in compression, a distance DD apart, so each force is M/DM/D. The 600 kN shear is carried entirely by the welds on the two sides of the web.

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 3 October Recording B 01:44:23

  2. Step 2 · Flange effective length changes with trial size

    Why this step: The ends of a weld are not counted as carrying load, and the amount deducted depends on the leg size. Whenever the leg size is changed, the effective length has to be recalculated.

    For a 10 mm leg, the course deducts 2s2s from the 190 mm length for the ends.

    New symbols in this step
    • ss, aa: Leg size and effective throat; mm, with a≈0.7sa\approx0.7s in this course
    • BB, BeffB_{eff}, LwebL_{web}: Flange weld length and effective length, web weld length on each side; mm
    Beff=B−2s=190−2(10)=170 mmB_{eff}=B-2s={\htmlClass{given}{190}}-2({\htmlClass{given}{10}})=170\ \mathrm{mm}

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 3 October Recording B 01:53:04

  3. Step 3 · Flange force per millimetre

    Why this step: The moment acts like a pair of equal and opposite forces: one flange is pulled and the other pushed, a section depth apart. The flange weld has to carry this force.

    Find force-couple tension from M/DM/D, then divide by effective weld length.

    FT=PeDBeff=600(250)528.3(170)≈1.67017 kN/mmF_T=\frac{Pe}{DB_{eff}}=\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{600}}({\htmlClass{given}{250}})}{{\htmlClass{given}{528.3}}(170)}\approx1.67017\ \mathrm{kN/mm}
    FT=PeDBeff=600(250)528.3(170)≈1.67017 kN/mm\begin{aligned}F_T&=\frac{Pe}{DB_{eff}}\\&=\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{600}}({\htmlClass{given}{250}})}{{\htmlClass{given}{528.3}}(170)}\\&\approx1.67017\ \mathrm{kN/mm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 170170 from Step 2.

  4. Step 4 · Required flange leg

    Why this step: This gives the smallest leg size whose throat can just carry the flange force. It is smaller than the trial leg size, so the trial flange weld is adequate.

    Divide unit-length demand by 0.7pw, converting kN and N consistently.

    New symbols in this step
    • pwp_w, qwq_w: Weld design strength N/mm²; resistance per millimetre kN/mm
    sreq=FT0.7pw=1.67017(1000)/(0.7(250))≈9.544 mm<10 mms_{req}=\frac{F_T}{0.7p_w}=1.67017(1000)/(0.7({\htmlClass{read}{250}}))\approx9.544\ \mathrm{mm}<{\htmlClass{given}{10}}\ \mathrm{mm}
    sreq=FT0.7pw=1.67017(1000)/(0.7(250))≈9.544 mm<10 mm\begin{aligned}s_{req}&=\frac{F_T}{0.7p_w}\\&=1.67017(1000)/(0.7({\htmlClass{read}{250}}))\\&\approx9.544\ \mathrm{mm}\\&<{\htmlClass{given}{10}}\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 1.670171.67017 from Step 3.

    Units: FTF_T is in kN/mm; multiplying by 1000 gives N/mm. Dividing by pwp_w in N/mm² gives the throat in mm, and dividing again by 0.7 gives the leg size in mm.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 3 · Design strength of fillet weld pwp_w
    For S355 steel with class 42 electrodes the fillet weld design strength is pw = 250 N/mm².
    For S355 steel with class 42 electrodes the fillet weld design strength is pw=250 N/mm2p_w=250\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
  5. Step 5 · Total effective web length: record the worksheet faithfully

    Why this step: The shear is carried by the welds on both sides of the web together, so the first thing needed is how much of their combined length counts as carrying load.

    The worksheet uses K15/(2*O15−2*S15), deducting 2s2s from the combined length of both sides. Its result matches the next screen. The calculation here first follows that expression.

    Lw=2Lweb−2s=2(340)−2(6)=668 mmL_w=2L_{web}-2s=2({\htmlClass{given}{340}})-2({\htmlClass{given}{6}})=668\ \mathrm{mm}
    Lw=2Lweb−2s=2(340)−2(6)=668 mm\begin{aligned}L_w&=2L_{web}-2s\\&=2({\htmlClass{given}{340}})-2({\htmlClass{given}{6}})\\&=668\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 3 October Recording B 01:55:43

  6. Step 6 · Web demand

    Why this step: The whole shear is spread evenly over the effective length of the web welds. This gives the shear each millimetre of weld must carry, which is the demand on the web weld.

    Combined length 668 mm gives the original 0.8982036 kN/mm. Do not silently change the denominator to 2(340−12).

    New symbols in this step
    • PP, FF: Applied force; kN
    • FsF_s, FtF_t, FRF_R: Direct, torsional and resultant force per millimetre; kN/mm
    Fs=P/Lw=600/668≈0.89820 kN/mmF_s=P/L_w={\htmlClass{given}{600}}/668\approx0.89820\ \mathrm{kN/mm}
    Fs=P/Lw=600/668≈0.89820 kN/mm\begin{aligned}F_s&=P/L_w\\&={\htmlClass{given}{600}}/668\\&\approx0.89820\ \mathrm{kN/mm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 668668 from Step 5.

  7. Step 7 · Web leg comparison

    Why this step: The shear demand per millimetre is turned into a required leg size and compared with the trial value. The trial value is larger, so the throat of the web weld will not shear.

    The original requirement is about 5.13259 mm, below the trial 6 mm.

    sreq=Fs0.7pw=0.89820(1000)/(0.7(250))≈5.133 mm<6 mms_{req}=\frac{F_s}{0.7p_w}=0.89820(1000)/(0.7({\htmlClass{read}{250}}))\approx5.133\ \mathrm{mm}<{\htmlClass{given}{6}}\ \mathrm{mm}
    sreq=Fs0.7pw=0.89820(1000)/(0.7(250))≈5.133 mm<6 mm\begin{aligned}s_{req}&=\frac{F_s}{0.7p_w}\\&=0.89820(1000)/(0.7({\htmlClass{read}{250}}))\\&\approx5.133\ \mathrm{mm}\\&<{\htmlClass{given}{6}}\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 0.898200.89820 from Step 6.

    Units: FsF_s is in kN/mm; multiplying by 1000 gives N/mm. After dividing by 0.7 and by pwp_w in N/mm², the unit left is mm.

  8. Step 8 · Alternative end deduction

    Why this step: Each weld has two ends of its own, so deducting them separately gives a shorter effective length and a slightly larger demand. The check still passes with this more cautious figure, which makes the conclusion firmer.

    Deducting 2s2s from each side gives total effective length Lw=656 mmL_w=656\ \mathrm{mm} and required leg 5.227 mm, also below 6 mm. The lecturer does not explain the single deduction from combined length; both approaches give the same selection conclusion.

    Lw=2(Lweb−2s)=2(340−2(6))=656 mmsreq=P/Lw0.7pw=600(1000)/(656(0.7)(250))≈5.227 mm<6 mm\begin{aligned}L_w&=2(L_{web}-2s)=2({\htmlClass{given}{340}}-2({\htmlClass{given}{6}}))=656\ \mathrm{mm}\\s_{req}&=\frac{P/L_w}{0.7p_w}={\htmlClass{given}{600}}(1000)/(656(0.7)({\htmlClass{read}{250}}))\approx5.227\ \mathrm{mm}<{\htmlClass{given}{6}}\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}
    Lw=2(Lweb−2s)=2(340−2(6))=656 mmsreq=P/Lw0.7pw=600(1000)/(656(0.7)(250))≈5.227 mm<6 mm\begin{aligned}L_w&=2(L_{web}-2s)\\&=2({\htmlClass{given}{340}}-2({\htmlClass{given}{6}}))\\&=656\ \mathrm{mm}\\s_{req}&=\frac{P/L_w}{0.7p_w}\\&={\htmlClass{given}{600}}(1000)/(656(0.7)({\htmlClass{read}{250}}))\\&\approx5.227\ \mathrm{mm}\\&<{\htmlClass{given}{6}}\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}

    Units: The shear of 600 kN times 1000 gives N. Dividing by the effective length in mm, by 0.7 and by pwp_w in N/mm² gives the leg size in mm.

Conclusion

Under the lecturer's model, 10 mm flange and 6 mm web welds satisfy the numerical comparison. “Assume 8 mm” is not a final answer merely because it appears in the sheet. Effective length LwL_w changes with leg size ss and must be updated too. Check other detailing under the course conditions.

All the symbols of this example

SymbolsMeaning and Units
ss, aaLeg size and effective throat; mm, with a≈0.7sa\approx0.7s in this course
pwp_w, qwq_wWeld design strength N/mm²; resistance per millimetre kN/mm
PP, FFApplied force; kN
ee, rrEccentricity and weld-group corner radius; mm
FsF_s, FtF_t, FRF_RDirect, torsional and resultant force per millimetre; kN/mm
BB, BeffB_{eff}, LwebL_{web}Flange weld length and effective length, web weld length on each side; mm

Video positions: 3 October Recording B 01:45:00 · 3 October Recording B 01:50:00 · 3 October Recording B 01:55:00 · 3 October Recording B 01:57:00

↑ Top