Worked Example

B3: a support reaction loads the next beam (Reaction Transfer)

Task: Connect the load path with two loading models and understand the lecturer's deflection Δ\Delta-formula correction.

Original question · Lecture notes Chapter 3, p. 35–36 (Tutorial 3 Q2)
Original question with the given values boxed
Yellow boxes: values the question gives, the same values marked yellow in the Given table below.

The question in short: A 6 m simply supported beam (457×191×67 UB, S355) carries B2's reaction at midspan: 79.2 kN dead and 67.5 kN imposed, plus its own weight. Find the design moment and shear, and check the deflection.

What differs from the previous example of this type: B2's load is spread evenly along its length. B3's main load is one point load at midspan from another beam, so the moment and deflection formulas change.

GivenValue and Unit
Span and model457×191×67 UB, S355; 6 m simply supported; midspan point load and self-weight UDL
Reaction sourceSupport reactions of B2: dead 79.2 kN; imposed 67.5 kN
ULS self-weight line load1.072 kN/m
SLS dataI=29380 cm4\htmlClass{read}{I=29380\ \mathrm{cm^{4}}}; E=205000 N/mm2\htmlClass{read}{E=205000\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}}; central imposed load 67.5 kN

Yellow: values given in the question. The same values are marked where they are substituted in the steps below.
Orange box: values read directly from the Data File, the same values boxed orange in the lookup screenshots. A value interpolated between two table rows is a calculation, so it has no box.

Data file lookup · Data Page 10 · Universal Beams — Properties
457×191×67 UB: Ix = 29380 cm⁴.
457×191×67 UB: Ix=29380 cm4I_x=29380\ \mathrm{cm^{4}}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
PRA​RB​Span between supports, L
Supplementary schematic for understanding; not to scale.

Solution Route: Factored reaction RR→separate point-load and UDL effects→add→use the SLS central-point-load expression.

Load path · the stations the force passes through, in order

The reaction of B2 becomes a point load at the midspan of B3. B3 takes it, with its own weight, to the columns at its ends.

  1. Reaction of B2
    Dead 79.2 and imposed 67.5 kN → P=218.88 kNP=218.88\ \mathrm{kN}
  2. Moment in B3 (midspan)
    M=333.144 kNmM=333.144\ \mathrm{kNm}
  3. Shear in B3 (supports)
    V=112.656 kNV=112.656\ \mathrm{kN}
  4. Deflection (imposed load)
    Demand 5.043 mmCapacity 16.667 mm
    Utilisation 0.30
  5. Support reactions
    112.656 kN at each end, through the web into the column (next example)
Each station links to the step that calculates it.
Load path · Floor plan: which part of the slab each beam carries
B1B1B2B3B3Column9 m3 m3 m6 m11The reaction of B2 becomes a point load at the midspan of B3: P = 218.88 kN22B3 takes this force and its own weight to its ends: 112.656 kN at each end33All the load ends up in the four columns; the reactions of B1 go straight into the columns, not through B3Arrows: the direction the load travels (plan seen from above)
B3 (red) spans 6 m and carries one end of B2 at its middle. The load path of the whole floor is: slab → B1 and B2 → B3 (reaction of B2 only) → columns.
  1. Step 1 · Treat reactions as forces

    Why this step: B2 rests on B3, so the force holding B2 up presses down on B3 with the same size. Dead and imposed parts stay separate because their load factors differ.

    79.2 and 67.5 are the end reactions RR of B2 (kN, not kN/m), found from the B2 line loads ww times the 9 m span LL divided by 2; they become the midspan point load on B3.

    New symbols in this step
    • GkG_k, QkQ_k: Unfactored dead and imposed loads; kN/m or kN
    RG=17.6(9)/2=79.2,RQ=15(9)/2=67.5 kNP=1.4Gk+1.6Qk=1.4(79.2)+1.6(67.5)=218.88 kN\begin{aligned}R_G&=17.6({\htmlClass{given}{9}})/2={\htmlClass{given}{79.2}},\quad R_Q=15({\htmlClass{given}{9}})/2={\htmlClass{given}{67.5}}\ \mathrm{kN}\\P&=1.4G_k+1.6Q_k=1.4({\htmlClass{given}{79.2}})+1.6({\htmlClass{given}{67.5}})=218.88\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}
    RG=17.6(9)/2=79.2RQ=15(9)/2=67.5 kNP=1.4Gk+1.6Qk=1.4(79.2)+1.6(67.5)=218.88 kN\begin{aligned}R_G&=17.6({\htmlClass{given}{9}})/2={\htmlClass{given}{79.2}}\\R_Q&=15({\htmlClass{given}{9}})/2={\htmlClass{given}{67.5}}\ \mathrm{kN}\\P&=1.4G_k+1.6Q_k\\&=1.4({\htmlClass{given}{79.2}})+1.6({\htmlClass{given}{67.5}})\\&=218.88\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 17 October 01:18:58

  2. Step 2 · Point-load moment

    Why this step: The point load sits at midspan, as far as possible from both supports, which is where it bends the beam most.

    A central point load gives P/2P/2 at each support and midspan moment (P/2P/2)(L/2L/2)=PL/4PL/4.

    New symbols in this step
    • qq, ww, PP: Area load kN/m², line load kN/m, point load kN
    MP=PL/4=218.88(6)/4=328.32 kNmM_P=PL/4=218.88({\htmlClass{given}{6}})/4=328.32\ \mathrm{kNm}
    MP=PL/4=218.88(6)/4=328.32 kNm\begin{aligned}M_P&=PL/4\\&=218.88({\htmlClass{given}{6}})/4\\&=328.32\ \mathrm{kNm}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 218.88218.88 from Step 1.

  3. Step 3 · Self-weight moment

    Why this step: The beam's own weight is spread along its length and also bends it. The effect is much smaller than the point load's, but it is still counted.

    Use wL2/8wL^{2}/8 separately for UDL. Do not add unlike loads before putting them into one formula.

    Mw=wL2/8=1.072(6)2/8=4.824 kNmM_w=wL^2/8={\htmlClass{given}{1.072}}({\htmlClass{given}{6}})^2/8=4.824\ \mathrm{kNm}
    Mw=wL2/8=1.072(6)2/8=4.824 kNm\begin{aligned}M_w&=wL^2/8\\&={\htmlClass{given}{1.072}}({\htmlClass{given}{6}})^2/8\\&=4.824\ \mathrm{kNm}\end{aligned}
  4. Step 4 · Combine internal actions

    Why this step: Both loads act at the same time, so the beam must resist their combined moment and shear. These totals are the demands for the later checks.

    In this linear-elastic simply supported model, add both loads' effects at the same location.

    New symbols in this step
    • MM, VV: Moment demand in kNm; shear demand in kN
    M=MP+Mw=328.32+4.824=333.144 kNmV=P/2+wL/2=218.88/2+1.072(6)/2=112.656 kN\begin{aligned}M&=M_P+M_w=328.32+4.824=333.144\ \mathrm{kNm}\\V&=P/2+wL/2=218.88/2+{\htmlClass{given}{1.072}}({\htmlClass{given}{6}})/2=112.656\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}
    M=MP+Mw=328.32+4.824=333.144 kNmV=P/2+wL/2=218.88/2+1.072(6)/2=112.656 kN\begin{aligned}M&=M_P+M_w\\&=328.32+4.824\\&=333.144\ \mathrm{kNm}\\V&=P/2+wL/2\\&=218.88/2+{\htmlClass{given}{1.072}}({\htmlClass{given}{6}})/2\\&=112.656\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 328.32328.32 from Step 2; 4.8244.824 from Step 3; 218.88218.88 from Step 1.

    Load path · Load, shear force and bending moment
    Loads and reactionsw = 1.072 kN/mP = 218.88 kNRA​ = 112.656 kNRB​ = 112.656 kN3 m3 mShear force diagram V (kN)112.656−112.656Bending moment diagram M (kNm): sagging moment drawn below the lineMmax​ = 333.144 kNm
    The point load makes the shear diagram jump at midspan and the moment diagram a triangle with its peak under the load. The self-weight is a UDL and only curves the diagrams slightly.
  5. Step 5 · Return to unfactored imposed load for SLS

    Why this step: Deflection is about how far the beam sags in everyday use, so only the imposed point load without load factors is used, with the point-load deflection formula.

    This course check uses P=67500 NP=67500\ \mathrm{N}, L=6000 mmL=6000\ \mathrm{mm} and I=29380×10000 mm4I=29380\times10000\ \mathrm{mm^{4}}.

    New symbols in this step
    • Δ\Delta, η\eta: Deflection mm; demand/resistance utilisation is dimensionless
    Δ=PL348EI=67500(6000)348(205000)(29380×104)≈5.043 mm\Delta=\frac{PL^3}{48EI}=\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{67500}}({\htmlClass{given}{6000}})^3}{48({\htmlClass{read}{205000}})({\htmlClass{read}{29380}}\times10^4)}\approx5.043\ \mathrm{mm}
    Δ=PL348EI=67500(6000)348(205000)(29380×104)≈5.043 mm\begin{aligned}\Delta&=\frac{PL^3}{48EI}\\&=\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{67500}}({\htmlClass{given}{6000}})^3}{48({\htmlClass{read}{205000}})({\htmlClass{read}{29380}}\times10^4)}\\&\approx5.043\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}

    Units: 67.5 kN times 1000 gives 67500 N and 6 m gives 6000 mm. II in cm⁴ times 10^4 gives mm⁴, because 1 cm is 10 mm, multiplied four times.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 1 · Steel properties
    Data Page 1, steel properties: modulus of elasticity E = 205000 N/mm² (printed as 205,000).
    Data Page 1, steel properties: modulus of elasticity E=205000 N/mm2E=205000\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}} (printed as 205,000).Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 17 October 01:30:00

  6. Step 6 · Compare with the limit

    Why this step: The deflection formula must match the shape of the load. Using the uniform-load formula for a point load gives a wrong sag and could even make the beam seem to fail.

    6000/360=16.667 mm. The approximately 18.9 mm obtained temporarily with a UDL formula is not the answer for this point-load model.

    New symbols in this step
    • LL, RAR_A, RBR_B: Span in m or mm; end reactions in kN
    Δ=5.043<L/360=6000/360=16.667 mm\Delta=5.043<L/{\htmlClass{read}{360}}={\htmlClass{given}{6000}}/{\htmlClass{read}{360}}=16.667\ \mathrm{mm}
    Δ=5.043<L/360=6000/360=16.667 mm\begin{aligned}\Delta&=5.043\\&<L/{\htmlClass{read}{360}}\\&={\htmlClass{given}{6000}}/{\htmlClass{read}{360}}\\&=16.667\ \mathrm{mm}\end{aligned}

    Units: The 6 m span times 1000 gives 6000 mm (1 m is 1000 mm), so the limit can be compared with the deflection in mm.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 2 · Table 5.1 Deflection limits
    For beams carrying plaster or other brittle finish, the imposed-load deflection limit is span/360.
    For beams carrying plaster or other brittle finish, the imposed-load deflection limit is span/360.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
  7. Step 7 · Check local support effects separately

    Why this step: A large force enters a short length of web. The thin web may be crushed there or bulge sideways, even when the beam as a whole is strong enough.

    A concentrated force entering the web requires bearing length and other data for local bearing/buckling checks. Overall shear resistance VcV_c cannot replace them.

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 17 October 01:19:47

Conclusion

B3 point-load moment greatly exceeds its self-weight moment. This explains the next lecture's observation that self-weight has a small effect in a particular LTB diagram interpretation. Whether it may be neglected still follows the lecturer's stated assumption at that step.

All the symbols of this example

SymbolsMeaning and Units
qq, ww, PPArea load kN/m², line load kN/m, point load kN
LL, RAR_A, RBR_BSpan in m or mm; end reactions in kN
MM, VVMoment demand in kNm; shear demand in kN
DD, dd, tt, TTOverall depth, classification web depth, web thickness and flange thickness; mm
AvA_v, II, SS, ZZShear area mm², second moment of area mm⁴, plastic/elastic moduli mm³
pyp_y, pbp_b, EEDesign yield/bending buckling strength and elastic modulus; N/mm²
Δ\Delta, η\etaDeflection mm; demand/resistance utilisation is dimensionless
GkG_k, QkQ_kUnfactored dead and imposed loads; kN/m or kN

Video positions: 17 October 01:19:00 · 17 October 01:30:00

↑ Top