STEELWORK / CON4334
Crash course · Section A (b)

Short theory: 4 marks you can learn by heart

The last part of Section A is usually a 4-mark theory question. There are only a few topics, and they repeat. They are listed below by how often they appeared in the 16 papers, each with a short explanation and a model answer to learn.

How often each topic appeared (16 papers, 2014–2024)

TopicTimesPriority
Fire protection: sketch two methods4★★★
Second-order effects P–Δ and P–δ3★★★
Hot-rolled sections: sketch and name2★★
Corrosion protection: two methods2★★
Limit states (ULS / SLS): examples2★★
Purpose of classification1★
Load–displacement curves of four analysis types1★

Fire protection Always examined

Lecture Chapter 1 Figure 1: solid, hollow and profile casing
Original lecture figure: three casing methods. The exam asks you to sketch two.
MethodHow to sketchExample
Solid casinga rectangle around the I-section, completely filled (hatched)concrete encasement
Hollow casinga rectangular outline around the I-section, empty insidefire boards forming a box
Profile casinga thin layer that follows the I shapesprayed coating, intumescent paint

Concept map

Fire protection: why wrap the steel, and how to sketch the three methods

The most frequent theory question (4 times in 16 papers). Understand the cause — steel softens when hot — and the three methods become three ways of doing the same thing: insulation.

Text version (from cause to result)

  1. Cause

    A fire heats the steel

    Steel conducts heat well, so it heats up quickly in a fire.

  2. Key idea

    Steel softens: strength and stiffness drop

    The hotter the steel, the lower its strength and stiffness. At a critical temperature the member can no longer carry its load.

  3. Result

    Members fail → collapse, less time to escape

    Beams and columns fail early; the structure may collapse before people can get out.

  4. How design deals with it

    The principle: insulate to delay heating

    Fire protection does not stop the steel heating; it gives it an insulating coat that delays it reaching the critical temperature, buying time.

  5. How design deals with it

    Solid casing

    The whole I-section is encased in solid material, e.g. concrete. Sketch: the I-section inside a filled (hatched) rectangle.

  6. How design deals with itWhere marks are lost

    Hollow casing

    Fire boards form a box around the I-section with an air space inside. Sketch: the I-section inside a rectangular outline.

  7. How design deals with it

    Profile casing

    A sprayed coating or intumescent paint forms a thin layer following the I shape. Sketch: a thin layer drawn around the I outline.

  8. Exam answerWhere marks are lost

    Exam: one-line principle + sketch two

    Write the principle in one line, then sketch two methods. Draw the I-section in every sketch and label it. The lecture gives no thickness or fire rating, so do not invent numbers.

    Lecture figure: solid, hollow and profile casing

Tour steps

  1. 1. Why protect against fire?

    Fire → steel heats up → strength and stiffness drop → members fail.

  2. 2. One principle: insulation

    The aim is to delay the steel heating, buying time for escape and fire-fighting.

  3. 3. Three ways to do it

    Solid (filled), hollow (an outline), profile (a thin layer following the shape). The difference is all in the outline you draw.

  4. 4. The exam answer

    One line of principle + two labelled sketches is the skeleton of a full-mark answer.

Second-order effects: P–Δ and P–δ Always examined

Global P–Delta sway and local P–delta bow
Left: the whole frame sways by Δ (P–Δ). Right: one member bows by δ (P–δ).
P–Δ (capital Delta)P–δ (small delta)
What moves?a whole storey / the frame swaysone member bows between its ends
Extra momentP×ΔP\times\DeltaP×δP\times\delta

Concept map

P–Δ and P–δ: why deformation makes the moment bigger

One of the most frequent theory questions (3 times in 16 papers). Read from top to bottom: compression plus an offset → the two effects → the snowball → how analysis and design deal with it → the exam answer.

Text version (from cause to result)

  1. Cause

    PP Axial compression

    A column carries a large compression PP. As soon as it does not push straight down the centre line, it adds a moment.

  2. Cause

    Δ\Delta The frame sways

    Horizontal loads such as wind, or a frame that is not perfectly plumb (design assumes a lean of h/200h/200), move the top of a storey sideways by Δ\Delta relative to its base.

    Source: Lecture: global imperfection Δ=h/200\Delta=h/200, or a notional horizontal force of 0.5% of the vertical load.

  3. Cause

    δ\delta The member bows

    No member is perfectly straight (initial bow about L/550L/550 to L/200L/200, depending on the buckling curve), and it bows out by δ\delta between its ends under moment.

  4. Key idea

    P–ΔP\text{–}\Delta P–Δ effect (global)

    The compression acts through the storey sway Δ\Delta and creates an extra moment P×ΔP\times\Delta. It is an effect of the whole frame.

    Left: frame sway Δ; right: member bow δ
  5. Key ideaWhere marks are lost

    P–δP\text{–}\delta P–δ effect (member)

    The compression acts through the member’s own bow δ\delta and creates an extra moment P×δP\times\delta. It is an effect of one member.

  6. Result

    A snowball: more bending, more moment

    The extra moment bends the member more, the offset grows, and so does the extra moment. Deflections increase, stiffness drops, and in the worst case the frame becomes unstable.

  7. How design deals with it

    Second-order analysis: equilibrium on the deformed shape

    First-order analysis writes equilibrium on the original, undeformed shape and misses the extra moments; second-order analysis writes it on the deformed shape and includes them. A P–Δ–δ analysis also includes member bow and imperfections.

  8. What changes itWhere marks are lost

    λcr\lambda_{cr} How far from instability

    The elastic critical load factor: how many times the loads must be multiplied before the frame becomes unstable. λcr≥10\lambda_{cr}\ge10 is non-sway and P–Δ may be simplified; λcr<5\lambda_{cr}<5 is ultra-sensitive and needs second-order or advanced analysis.

    Source: Columns lecture section 5

  9. Exam answer

    Four load–displacement curves

    First-order elastic: a straight line; second-order elastic: stiffness gradually drops; first-order plastic: reaches a plateau (mechanism); second-order elastic-plastic: a lower peak, then the load falls.

    Load–displacement curves of four analysis types

    Source: Short theory: four analysis types (asked once)

  10. How design deals with itWhere marks are lost

    Mamp=k MM_{\text{amp}}=k\,M Amplification factor: add it in one go

    Without a second-order analysis, multiply the first-order moment by an amplification factor to include the extra moment. Exam questions usually give the factor (e.g. 1.1).

    Source: How it is used: columns crash course.

  11. Exam answer

    Exam answer: definition + both effects + sketch

    Write one definition (equilibrium on the deformed shape), one line each for P–Δ and P–δ, and a sketch: a frame swaying by Δ\Delta on the left and a column bowing by δ\delta on the right.

    Lecture figure: P–Δ and P–δ

Tour steps

  1. 1. The cause: compression plus an offset

    Compression alone adds no moment; it must act through an offset. There are two kinds of offset: storey sway Δ\Delta or member bow δ\delta.

  2. 2. The two effects

    Compression × storey sway = P–Δ (global); compression × member bow = P–δ (member).

  3. 3. The snowball

    Extra moment → more deformation → more extra moment. That is why it cannot be ignored.

  4. 4. Analysis

    First-order analysis cannot see it; second-order analysis works on the deformed shape. The four analysis curves may also be asked on their own.

  5. 5. How design deals with it

    Use λcr\lambda_{cr} to judge how sensitive the frame is; in calculations multiply the first-order moment by the amplification factor, once only.

  6. 6. The exam answer

    Definition + P–Δ + P–δ + sketch, about 4 marks. No essay needed.

Hot-rolled sections Often examined

Lecture Chapter 1 Figure 2: common rolled sections
Original lecture figure: UB, UC, channel, equal/unequal angles, tee and hollow sections.
NameShapeTypical use
Universal Beam (UB)“I” shape, deep and narrowbeams: efficient in strong-axis bending
Universal Column (UC)“H” shape, width ≈ depthcolumns: strong in both directions
Channel“[” or C shapebracing, secondary members, compound sections
Angle“L” shape, equal or unequal legsbracing, trusses, connection pieces

Concept map

Hot-rolled sections: the shape decides the job

The theory question “sketch and name four hot-rolled sections” has been asked twice. Once you see where the steel sits, it is clear why a UB is a beam and a UC a column — and how ryr_y links to LTB and column buckling.

Text version (from cause to result)

  1. Cause

    Steel far from the axis works hardest

    In bending, steel far from the neutral axis carries the most stress with the longest lever arm. That is why an I shape puts most of its steel in the flanges.

  2. Key idea

    II, ZZ, SS, rr Section properties come from the shape

    II governs stiffness (deflection), ZZ the elastic moment, SS the plastic moment, and r=I/Ar=\sqrt{I/A} buckling. They are not interchangeable.

    Why I, Z and S are not interchangeable
  3. Key idea

    Strong axis x–x, weak axis y–y

    For the same section II and rr about xx are far larger than about yy. In this course x–xx\text{–}x is always the strong axis.

  4. What changes it

    How to read a section name

    356×127×39 UB: about 356 mm deep, 127 mm wide, 39 kg per metre (self-weight 39×10/1000=0.39 kN/m39\times10/1000=0.39\text{ kN/m}). These are nominal; read the real dimensions from the table row.

  5. Result

    UB: deep and narrow → beams

    Very efficient in strong-axis bending; but the narrow flanges give a small ryr_y, so it is prone to LTB and needs lateral restraint (see the LTB concept map).

  6. Result

    UC: wide flanges, width ≈ depth → columns

    Stocky in both directions, so ryr_y is not too small — suited to compression and bending both ways (see the column-buckling map).

  7. Result

    Channel

    “[” shape: one web with both flanges on the same side. Used for bracing, secondary members and compound sections.

  8. Result

    Angle

    “L” shape with equal or unequal legs. Used in bracing, trusses and connection pieces. Connected through one leg it needs a deduction (see the net-area map).

  9. Exam answerWhere marks are lost

    Exam: sketch and name four

    The safest four: UB, UC, channel and angle. Sketch each cross-section, label it and give one line on its use.

    Lecture figure: common rolled sections

Tour steps

  1. 1. Where the steel sits

    The further from the axis the more useful, so the shape sets I,Z,S,rI,Z,S,r.

  2. 2. Strong and weak axes

    Strong about xx, weak about yy — that is what separates beams from columns.

  3. 3. UB for beams, UC for columns

    A UB is deep and narrow — efficient in bending but with a small ryr_y; a UC is stocky both ways.

  4. 4. Channels and angles

    Mostly for bracing, trusses and connections.

  5. 5. The exam answer

    Four labelled sketches, one line of use each.

Corrosion protection Often examined

MethodHow it protects
Paint coatingforms a barrier that keeps out moisture and air
Galvanizing (zinc or aluminium coating)the zinc layer isolates the steel and corrodes first, sacrificing itself
Cathodic protectionfor structures permanently in water; reduces electrochemical corrosion
Weathering steelits alloy forms a stable protective oxide layer

Concept map

Corrosion protection: why steel rusts, and the two ways to stop it

The question asks for two methods. The key is that they must work differently: one keeps water and air away, the other lets another metal corrode instead of the steel.

Text version (from cause to result)

  1. Cause

    Moisture + oxygen

    Steel is exposed to damp air or water.

  2. Key idea

    Electrochemical corrosion: rust

    The iron in the steel reacts electrochemically with water and oxygen and slowly turns into rust.

  3. Result

    Thinner section, less strength

    Rust eats the steel away; the effective section gets thinner and weaker, and durability suffers (a serviceability limit state, SLS).

  4. Key idea

    Two ideas: barrier / sacrifice

    (1) Barrier: keep water and air away from the steel; (2) sacrifice: let another metal (e.g. zinc) corrode instead of the steel.

  5. How design deals with it

    Paint coating (barrier)

    A paint system forms a barrier on the surface that keeps out moisture and oxygen.

  6. How design deals with it

    Hot-dip galvanizing (barrier + sacrifice)

    The zinc layer both isolates the steel and corrodes first, sacrificing itself to protect the steel.

  7. How design deals with it

    Cathodic protection (immersed)

    For structures permanently in water; it reduces electrochemical corrosion.

  8. How design deals with it

    Weathering steel (material choice)

    Its alloy content forms a stable protective oxide layer. It is a choice of steel, not a coating.

  9. Exam answerWhere marks are lost

    Exam: two methods that work differently

    One line each on how it protects. The safest pair: paint (barrier) + galvanizing (sacrifice), or add cathodic protection.

Tour steps

  1. 1. Why does steel rust?

    Moisture + oxygen → electrochemical reaction → rust → a thinner section.

  2. 2. Two ideas

    Cut off the cause (keep water and air out), or find a stand-in (a sacrificial metal).

  3. 3. Four methods

    Paint, galvanizing, cathodic protection, weathering steel — which idea does each belong to?

  4. 4. The exam answer

    Pick two methods that work differently and give one line each on how they protect.

Limit states (ULS and SLS) Often examined

ULS (safety)SLS (use)
bending or shear failure of a beam (yielding)excessive deflection cracking finishes
buckling of a columnexcessive vibration causing discomfort
overturning or slidingwind-induced oscillation
brittle fracture, fatiguedurability (e.g. corrosion)

Concept map

Limit states: “will it collapse?” and “does it work?” are two different routes

ULS and SLS are not only a theory question (asked twice); they decide which load each calculation uses: strength with factored loads, deflection with unfactored loads. This map links the two.

Text version (from cause to result)

  1. Cause

    Limit state

    A condition beyond which the structure no longer meets a design requirement. Design makes sure none of them is reached.

  2. Key idea

    ULS: will it collapse?

    Ultimate limit state: safety — collapse or damage that cannot be repaired.

  3. Key idea

    SLS: does it work in everyday use?

    Serviceability limit state: it does not collapse, but it does not work properly in normal use.

  4. Result

    ULS examples

    Bending or shear failure of a beam (yielding), column buckling, overturning or sliding, brittle fracture, fatigue, fire.

  5. Result

    SLS examples

    Excessive deflection cracking finishes, vibration causing discomfort, wind-induced oscillation, durability (e.g. corrosion).

  6. How design deals with itWhere marks are lost

    1.4Gk+1.6Qk1.4G_k+1.6Q_k ULS uses factored loads

    Characteristic loads × load factors, compared with the design resistance. Imposed load is less predictable, so its factor is larger (1.6). The material safety margin is already inside the course design strength pyp_y — do not apply another.

  7. How design deals with itWhere marks are lost

    QkQ_k SLS uses unfactored loads

    Deflection looks at the real everyday load: imposed load only, unfactored, compared with a limit (L/360L/360 with brittle finishes).

  8. Exam answer

    The floor-beam question tests both

    Shear and bending checks = ULS (factored); the deflection check = SLS (unfactored). Both routes run side by side in one question — see the floor-beam map.

  9. Exam answer

    Theory question: definition + two examples each

    One definition, then two examples each of ULS and SLS.

Tour steps

  1. 1. Two questions

    ULS asks “will it collapse?”; SLS asks “does it work normally?”.

  2. 2. Examples of each

    Collapse, fracture and buckling are ULS; too much deflection, vibration or rust are SLS.

  3. 3. The two routes use different loads

    ULS: 1.4Gk+1.6Qk1.4G_k+1.6Q_k; SLS: the real imposed load QkQ_k, unfactored.

  4. 4. Calculation and theory

    The floor-beam question uses both routes; the theory question needs a definition + two examples each.

Purpose of section classification Background

Concept map

Local buckling and the four classes: thin plates wrinkle first, so sections are graded

Classification is not arithmetic for its own sake: it answers “are the plates thick enough to reach full strength before they wrinkle?”. The answer decides whether you may use SS or only ZZ.

Text version (from cause to result)

  1. Cause

    Plates in compression

    A section is made of plates. In bending the compression flange is squeezed; the web is bent (and in a column also compressed).

  2. Key idea

    Local buckling: thin plates wrinkle

    If a plate is too thin it wrinkles locally before it fully yields, so the section cannot reach its full strength. This is different from the whole member buckling.

    A thin plate in compression wrinkles locally
  3. What changes itWhere marks are lost

    b/Tb/T, d/td/t Width-to-thickness ratios

    The larger the ratio, the thinner the plate and the easier it wrinkles. The section table already lists them.

  4. What changes it

    ε\varepsilon Stronger steel, stricter limits

    ε=275/py\varepsilon=\sqrt{275/p_y}. Stronger steel must reach a higher stress before wrinkling, so it needs chunkier plates; the limits are multiplied by ε\varepsilon to tighten them.

  5. Result

    Class 1 plastic

    Reaches the full plastic moment with enough rotation to form a plastic hinge. I-section flange b/T≤9εb/T\le9\varepsilon, web d/t≤80εd/t\le80\varepsilon.

  6. Result

    Class 2 compact

    Reaches the full plastic moment but with limited rotation. Flange within 10ε10\varepsilon, web within 100ε100\varepsilon.

  7. Result

    Class 3 semi-compact

    Only reaches the elastic moment pyZp_yZ (first yield at the edge); it wrinkles before the plastic moment. Flange within 15ε15\varepsilon, web within 120ε120\varepsilon.

  8. Result

    Class 4 slender

    Wrinkles before yielding; effective (reduced) properties are needed. The usual exam UB/UC sections are never Class 4.

  9. How design deals with itWhere marks are lost

    The worst plate decides

    Classify the flange and the web separately and take the higher (worse) class. E.g. flange Class 2, web Class 3 → Class 3.

  10. How design deals with it

    Decides which moment resistance

    Class 1 or 2 → Mc=min⁡(pyS,1.2pyZ)M_c=\min(p_yS,1.2p_yZ); Class 3 → pyZp_yZ; Class 4 → effective section. The LTB βw\beta_w also depends on the class. Worked numbers: classification map.

  11. Exam answer

    Theory: purpose of classification

    One line of purpose (width-to-thickness limits decide whether local buckling stops the section reaching its yield or plastic resistance), then one line for each of the four classes.

Tour steps

  1. 1. Thin plates in compression wrinkle

    A section is made of plates; a thin plate in compression wrinkles locally (local buckling).

  2. 2. What makes it wrinkle more easily?

    A larger width-to-thickness ratio; and stronger steel tightens the limits (ε\varepsilon).

  3. 3. The four classes

    From “can form a plastic hinge” to “wrinkles before yield”, each class is worse than the one before.

  4. 4. The whole section takes the worst

    Compare flange and web separately and take the worse; that decides between SS and ZZ.

  5. 5. The theory answer

    One line of purpose + one line per class.

Four types of structural analysis Background

Load–displacement curves of four analysis types
Sketch: first-order elastic is a straight line; second-order elastic softens; first-order plastic reaches a plateau; second-order elastic-plastic peaks and then falls.

Other possible topics Background

Fatigue

Repeated changes of stress (e.g. crane girders, bridges) slowly grow small cracks until the member breaks, even though each load on its own is small.

Brittle fracture

Steel cracks suddenly with little visible deformation. Low temperature, thick plates, welding, stress concentrations and rapid loading increase the risk.

Simple vs continuous construction

Simple design treats beam-to-column joints as pins that carry no moment; bracing or a core resists sideways loads. Continuous design uses joints stiff enough to pass moments between members.

Robustness

Local damage (e.g. a column hit by a vehicle) must not cause a disproportionately large collapse. Measures: ties, alternative load paths, stronger key elements.