Worked Example

Column interaction revision: where each ratio comes from (Column Interaction Review)

Task: Recalculate the three course ratios and confirm that they belong to the same member expression.

The question in short: A 305×305×158 UC column carries 3000 kN of compression with moments of 90 kNm in the xx direction and 60 kNm in the yy direction. Recalculate the three ratios of the member interaction check one by one and see whether they add up to less than 1.

What differs from the previous example of this type: Moments no longer come from eccentricity here; the moments, λy\lambda_{y}, mxm_x and mym_y are all given. The point is to see how demand and capacity are paired in each term of one member check.

GivenValue and Unit
Axial forceFc=3000 kN\htmlClass{given}{F_c=3000\ \mathrm{kN}}; 305×305×158 UC, S355
Section propertiesT=25.0 mm\htmlClass{read}{T=25.0\ \mathrm{mm}}, py=345 N/mm2\htmlClass{read}{p_y=345\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}}; Ag=201 cm2\htmlClass{read}{A_g=201\ \mathrm{cm^{2}}}; Zx=2369\htmlClass{read}{Z_x=2369}, Zy=808 cm3\htmlClass{read}{Z_y=808\ \mathrm{cm^{3}}}
Bucklingλy=57.0\htmlClass{given}{\lambda_{y}=57.0} (lecturer’s worksheet)
xx directionMoment 90 kNm; amplification 1.1; mx=0.91\htmlClass{given}{m_x=0.91} (lecturer’s worksheet)
yy directionMoment 60 kNm; amplification 1.15; my=0.43\htmlClass{given}{m_y=0.43} (lecturer’s worksheet)

Yellow: values given in the question. The same values are marked where they are substituted in the steps below.
Orange box: values read directly from the Data File, the same values boxed orange in the lookup screenshots. A value interpolated between two table rows is a calculation, so it has no box.

Data file lookup · Data Page 11 · Universal Columns — Properties
305×305×158 UC: Zx = 2369 cm³, Zy = 808 cm³, A = 201 cm².
305×305×158 UC: Zx=2369 cm3Z_x=2369\ \mathrm{cm^{3}}, Zy=808 cm3Z_y=808\ \mathrm{cm^{3}}, A=201 cm2A=201\ \mathrm{cm^{2}}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
Data file lookup · Data Page 11 · Universal Columns — Dimensions
305×305×158 UC: flange T = 25.0 mm.
305×305×158 UC: flange T=25.0 mmT=25.0\ \mathrm{mm}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
Data file lookup · Data Page 1 · Design strength pyp_y
T = 25.0 mm thick: the T ≤ 40 mm row, S355 column gives py = 345 N/mm².
T=25.0 mmT=25.0\ \mathrm{mm} thick: the T≤40 mmT\le40\ \mathrm{mm} row, S355 column gives py=345 N/mm2p_y=345\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}. How the grade and thickness choose this row →Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too

Solution Route: Calculate PcP_c→amplify each directional demand→apply moment factors→divide by resistance→add.

Load path · the stations the force passes through, in order

One column carries axial force and moments about both axes together. The three ratios are the three terms of one member check, added and compared with 1.

  1. Axial term
    3000 / 5014.95 ≈ 0.5982
  2. xx-axis moment term
    ≈ 0.1102
  3. yy-axis moment term
    ≈ 0.1064
  4. Sum of the three terms
    Sum 0.815Limit 1
Each station links to the step that calculates it.
  1. Step 1 · Compression resistance

    Why this step: The member check guards against the whole column becoming unstable, so the compression capacity must be PcP_c, which allows for buckling. The weak axis bows most easily, so pcp_c is read using λy\lambda_{y}.

    Curve c about yy: λy=57.0\lambda_{y}=57.0 lies between the 56 and 58 rows of Table 8.8(c), and interpolation gives pc=249.5 N/mm2p_c=249.5\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}; 201 cm² is multiplied by 100 to give mm².

    New symbols in this step
    • AgA_g, pyp_y, pcp_c: Gross area mm²; yield and compression buckling strengths N/mm²
    pc=252+57.0−5658−56(247−252)=249.5 N/mm2Pc=Agpc=201(100)(249.5)/1000=5014.95 kN\begin{aligned}p_c&={\htmlClass{read}{252}}+\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{57.0}}-{\htmlClass{given}{56}}}{{\htmlClass{given}{58}}-{\htmlClass{given}{56}}}({\htmlClass{read}{247}}-{\htmlClass{read}{252}})=249.5\ \mathrm{N/mm^2}\\P_c&=A_gp_c={\htmlClass{read}{201}}(100)(249.5)/1000=5014.95\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}
    pc=252+57.0−5658−56(247−252)=249.5 N/mm2Pc=Agpc=201(100)(249.5)/1000=5014.95 kN\begin{aligned}p_c&={\htmlClass{read}{252}}+\frac{{\htmlClass{given}{57.0}}-{\htmlClass{given}{56}}}{{\htmlClass{given}{58}}-{\htmlClass{given}{56}}}({\htmlClass{read}{247}}-{\htmlClass{read}{252}})\\&=249.5\ \mathrm{N/mm^2}\\P_c&=A_gp_c\\&={\htmlClass{read}{201}}(100)(249.5)/1000\\&=5014.95\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}

    Units: AgA_g of 201 cm² is multiplied by 100 to change it into mm². pcp_c in N/mm² times mm² gives N, and dividing by 1000 gives kN.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 8 · Table 8.8(c)
    Table 8.8(c) (y axis, curve c), py = 345 column: λ = 56 → 252 and λ = 58 → 247 N/mm²; interpolating at λy = 57.0 gives pc = 249.5 N/mm².
    Table 8.8(c) (yy axis, curve c), py=345p_y=345 column: λ=56\lambda=56 → 252 and λ=58\lambda=58 → 247 N/mm²; interpolating at λy=57.0\lambda_{y}=57.0 gives pc=249.5 N/mm2p_c=249.5\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 14 November 01:19:56

  2. Step 2 · Axial-force term

    Why this step: This ratio is the share of the column's buckling capacity used by compression. It is more than half, so less than half is left for the two moment terms.

    Use pcp_c here, not pyp_y.

    New symbols in this step
    • FcF_c, PcP_c: Design axial force and buckling compression resistance; kN
    ηN=Fc/Pc=3000/5014.95≈0.5982\eta_N=F_c/P_c={\htmlClass{given}{3000}}/5014.95\approx0.5982
    ηN=Fc/Pc=3000/5014.95≈0.5982\begin{aligned}\eta_N&=F_c/P_c\\&={\htmlClass{given}{3000}}/5014.95\\&\approx0.5982\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 5014.955014.95 from Step 1.

  3. Step 3 · xx-bending term

    Why this step: This ratio is the share used by the xx-axis moment. mxm_x reduces the moment because the largest value does not act along the whole column; the capacity pyZxp_yZ_x is the moment at which the outermost steel just yields.

    Both amplification and moment-distribution factors act on demand.

    New symbols in this step
    • mxm_x, mym_y, mLTm_{LT}: Equivalent moment-distribution factors; dimensionless
    pyZx=345(2369)/1000=817.3 kNmηx=mxMx′pyZx=0.91(1.1)(90)/817.3≈0.1102\begin{aligned}p_yZ_x&={\htmlClass{read}{345}}({\htmlClass{read}{2369}})/1000=817.3\ \mathrm{kNm}\\\eta_x&=\frac{m_xM_x'}{p_yZ_x}={\htmlClass{given}{0.91}}({\htmlClass{given}{1.1}})({\htmlClass{given}{90}})/817.3\approx0.1102\end{aligned}
    pyZx=345(2369)/1000=817.3 kNmηx=mxMx′pyZx=0.91(1.1)(90)/817.3≈0.1102\begin{aligned}p_yZ_x&={\htmlClass{read}{345}}({\htmlClass{read}{2369}})/1000\\&=817.3\ \mathrm{kNm}\\\eta_x&=\frac{m_xM_x'}{p_yZ_x}\\&={\htmlClass{given}{0.91}}({\htmlClass{given}{1.1}})({\htmlClass{given}{90}})/817.3\\&\approx0.1102\end{aligned}

    Units: ZxZ_x is multiplied by 1000 to change cm³ into mm³. pyp_y times mm³ gives Nmm, and dividing by 1000000 gives kNm. Together this is a division by 1000.

  4. Step 4 · yy-bending term

    Why this step: The section is much weaker in bending about its weak axis. So although the yy-axis moment is smaller, it uses about the same share as the xx-axis moment.

    Retain the yy axis's own factor, demand and resistance.

    pyZy=345(808)/1000=278.8 kNmηy=myMy′pyZy=0.43(1.15)(60)/278.8≈0.1064\begin{aligned}p_yZ_y&={\htmlClass{read}{345}}({\htmlClass{read}{808}})/1000=278.8\ \mathrm{kNm}\\\eta_y&=\frac{m_yM_y'}{p_yZ_y}={\htmlClass{given}{0.43}}({\htmlClass{given}{1.15}})({\htmlClass{given}{60}})/278.8\approx0.1064\end{aligned}
    pyZy=345(808)/1000=278.8 kNmηy=myMy′pyZy=0.43(1.15)(60)/278.8≈0.1064\begin{aligned}p_yZ_y&={\htmlClass{read}{345}}({\htmlClass{read}{808}})/1000\\&=278.8\ \mathrm{kNm}\\\eta_y&=\frac{m_yM_y'}{p_yZ_y}\\&={\htmlClass{given}{0.43}}({\htmlClass{given}{1.15}})({\htmlClass{given}{60}})/278.8\\&\approx0.1064\end{aligned}

    Units: ZyZ_y is in cm³ and is multiplied by 1000 to give mm³. pyp_y times mm³ gives Nmm, and dividing by 1000000 gives kNm, so the formula divides by 1000.

  5. Step 5 · Add and assess

    Why this step: Compression and the two moments act on the same column at the same time, so their three shares are added. A total below 1 means the column stays stable under all three together.

    The three terms add up to about 0.8148; the 0.8149 on the lecturer’s sheet is only a rounding difference and does not change the comparison.

    η=ηN+ηx+ηy≈0.5982+0.1102+0.1064≈0.815<1\eta=\eta_N+\eta_x+\eta_y\approx0.5982+0.1102+0.1064\approx0.815<1
    η=ηN+ηx+ηy≈0.5982+0.1102+0.1064≈0.815<1\begin{aligned}\eta&=\eta_N+\eta_x+\eta_y\\&\approx0.5982+0.1102+0.1064\\&\approx0.815\\&<1\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 0.59820.5982 from Step 2; 0.11020.1102 from Step 3; 0.10640.1064 from Step 4.

    Load path · How the ratios add up
    Limit 1Member check0.5980.110.106≈ 0.815Axial termx-axis moment termy-axis moment term
    Each bar is one check: blue is the share used by the axial force, green and yellow the shares used by the moments about the two axes. Together they must not pass the red dashed line.
Conclusion

This member expression passes. It does not establish that every column check is complete, and must not be mixed with the separate 3500 kN problem.

All the symbols of this example

SymbolsMeaning and Units
FcF_c, PcP_cDesign axial force and buckling compression resistance; kN
AgA_g, pyp_y, pcp_cGross area mm²; yield and compression buckling strengths N/mm²
MxM_x, MyM_y, MLTM_{LT}Two-axis and LTB governing moment demands; kNm
SxS_x, SyS_y, ZxZ_x, ZyZ_yTwo-axis plastic/elastic moduli; convert the tabulated cm³
mxm_x, mym_y, mLTm_{LT}Equivalent moment-distribution factors; dimensionless

Video positions: 14 November 01:20:00

↑ Top