Worked Example

B3 with midspan restraint: complete the LTB procedure (Restrained Segments)

Task: Distinguish ordinary slenderness λ\lambda, equivalent slenderness λLT\lambda_{LT}, tabulated strength and equivalent moment.

Original question · Lecture notes Chapter 3, p. 35–36 (Tutorial 3 Q3)
Original question with the given values boxed
Yellow boxes: values the question gives, the same values marked yellow in the Given table below.

The question in short: Beam B3 is a 457×191×67 UB spanning 6 m. It is held sideways at both ends and at mid-span, so each unrestrained length is 3000 mm. The largest moment is 333.144 kNm. Decide whether this length fails by lateral-torsional buckling.

What differs from the previous example of this type: Same section as B2, but there is now a sideways restraint at mid-span, so the unrestrained length is half the span, not the full span. The moment diagram also differs, so mLTm_{LT} is looked up again.

GivenValue and Unit
GeometryB3 (457×191×67 UB, S355), span 6 m, laterally restrained at both ends and midspan; this segment Le=3000 mm\htmlClass{given}{L_e=3000\ \mathrm{mm}}
Section parametersry=41.2 mm\htmlClass{read}{r_y=41.2\ \mathrm{mm}}; u=0.872\htmlClass{read}{u=0.872}; x=37.9\htmlClass{read}{x=37.9}; Sx=1471 cm3\htmlClass{read}{S_x=1471\ \mathrm{cm^{3}}}
Classification and strengthClass1/2, βw=1\beta_{w}=1; py=355 N/mm2\htmlClass{read}{p_y=355\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}}
Bending momentMmax=333.144 kNm\htmlClass{given}{M_{max}=333.144\ \mathrm{kNm}} (B3 example); this segment β=0\htmlClass{given}{\beta=0}, mLT=0.6\htmlClass{read}{m_{LT}=0.6}

Yellow: values given in the question. The same values are marked where they are substituted in the steps below.
Orange box: values read directly from the Data File, the same values boxed orange in the lookup screenshots. A value interpolated between two table rows is a calculation, so it has no box.

Data file lookup · Data Page 10 · Universal Beams — Properties
457×191×67 UB: ry = 4.12 cm = 41.2 mm, Sx = 1471 cm³, u = 0.872, x = 37.9.
457×191×67 UB: ry=4.12 cm=41.2 mmr_y=4.12\ \mathrm{cm}=41.2\ \mathrm{mm}, Sx=1471 cm3S_x=1471\ \mathrm{cm^{3}}, u=0.872u=0.872, x=37.9x=37.9.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too

Solution Route: LeL_e→λ\lambda→vv→λLT\lambda_{LT}→pbp_b→MbM_b; separately derive mLTm_{LT} from the moment diagram, then compare demand and resistance.

Interactive 3D model · drag to turn

This browser cannot show the 3D model.

Drag the slider to see lateral-torsional buckling: the compressed top flange moves sideways and the whole section twists. B2 holds the top flange at midspan (green), so each 3 m segment buckles on its own and the effective length is only Le=3000 mmL_e=3000\ \mathrm{mm}.Yellow: values given in the question; orange box: values read from the Data File; white: calculated results; red arrows: forces.
Load path · the stations the force passes through, in order

Bending puts the top flange in compression, and a compressed flange can buckle sideways like a column. B2 holds the top flange of B3 at midspan, so each segment is only 3 m.

  1. Largest moment (midspan)
    333.144 kNm
  2. Segment between restraints
    Le=3000 mmL_e=3000\ \mathrm{mm}; λLT≈60.86\lambda_{LT}\approx60.86
    Step 1–3
  3. Buckling strength
    pb≈253.90 N/mm2p_b\approx253.90\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}, below py=355p_y=355
    Step 4
  4. Lateral-torsional buckling (equivalent moment)
    Demand 199.8864 kNmCapacity 373.48 kNm
    Utilisation 0.54
    Step 5–7
Each station links to the step that calculates it. Press “Show on the 3D model” to light up that part of the model above; press again to clear.
  1. Step 1 · Define the segment

    Why this step: A sideways restraint holds the beam like a hand from the side. The compression flange can only bow sideways between two restraints, so a shorter length makes the beam harder to buckle.

    Use the 3 m between adjacent effective lateral restraints, not the full 6 m span LL.

    New symbols in this step
    • LeL_e, ryr_y: Effective unrestrained length and weak-axis radius of gyration; both in mm
    • λ\lambda, λLT\lambda_{LT}: Ordinary and equivalent slenderness; dimensionless
    λ=LE/ry=3000/41.2≈72.8155\lambda=L_E/r_y={\htmlClass{given}{3000}}/{\htmlClass{read}{41.2}}\approx72.8155
    Load path · Load, shear force and bending moment
    Loads and reactionsP = 218.88 kNlateral restraintRA​ = 112.656 kNRB​ = 112.656 kN3 m3 mBending moment diagram M (kNm): sagging moment drawn below the lineMmax​ = 333.144 kNmLE​ = 3000 mm, β = 0, mLT​ = 0.6LE​ = 3000 mm
    Green marks the lateral restraints: the two supports and B2 at midspan. The top flange can only buckle between restraints, so each segment has an effective length of 3000 mm. In each segment the moment rises from zero at one end to the maximum at the other, so β=0\beta=0 and mLT=0.6m_{LT}=0.6.

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 24 October 00:34:29

  2. Step 2 · Calculate vv

    Why this step: vv turns the section's resistance to twisting into a factor below 1. The next step uses it to reduce the ordinary slenderness into the slenderness used for lateral-torsional buckling.

    Calculate λ/x\lambda/x before squaring. The quarter power is in the denominator, equivalent to raising the whole bracket to −1/4.

    New symbols in this step
    • uu, xx, vv, βw\beta_{w}: Course LTB section/conversion parameters; dimensionless
    v=[1+0.05(λ/x)2]−1/4=[1+0.05(72.8155/37.9)2]−1/4≈0.9585v=\left[1+0.05(\lambda/x)^2\right]^{-1/4}=\left[1+0.05(72.8155/{\htmlClass{read}{37.9}})^2\right]^{-1/4}\approx0.9585
    v=[1+0.05(λ/x)2]−1/4=[1+0.05(72.8155/37.9)2]−1/4≈0.9585\begin{aligned}v&=\left[1+0.05(\lambda/x)^2\right]^{-1/4}\\&=\left[1+0.05(72.8155/{\htmlClass{read}{37.9}})^2\right]^{-1/4}\\&\approx0.9585\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 72.815572.8155 from Step 1.

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 24 October 00:24:35

  3. Step 3 · Convert to equivalent slenderness

    Why this step: Ordinary slenderness only describes sideways bending, but lateral-torsional buckling also involves twisting. λLT\lambda_{LT} combines both in one value; the smaller it is, the closer the beam gets to using its full section strength.

    uu, vv and βw\beta_{w} are course-method parameters. This step obtains λLT\lambda_{LT} for the pbp_b lookup.

    λLT=uvλβw=0.872(0.9585)(72.8155)1≈60.86\lambda_{LT}=uv\lambda\sqrt{\beta_w}={\htmlClass{read}{0.872}}(0.9585)(72.8155)\sqrt1\approx60.86
    λLT=uvλβw=0.872(0.9585)(72.8155)1≈60.86\begin{aligned}\lambda_{LT}&=uv\lambda\sqrt{\beta_w}\\&={\htmlClass{read}{0.872}}(0.9585)(72.8155)\sqrt1\\&\approx60.86\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 0.95850.9585 from Step 2; 72.815572.8155 from Step 1.

  4. Step 4 · Interpolate within the same strength column

    Why this step: pbp_b is the bending stress this length can carry before it moves sideways and twists. It is lower than pyp_y; the difference is the strength lost because the beam may buckle.

    In the py=355p_y=355 column, λLT=60\lambda_{LT}=60 gives 257 and 65 gives 239 N/mm². 60.86 lies between them.

    New symbols in this step
    • pyp_y, pbp_b: Design yield and bending buckling strengths; N/mm²
    • λ1\lambda_1, λ2\lambda_2, p1p_1, p2p_2: Slenderness and table values of the two rows used for interpolation
    pb=p1+λLT−λ1λ2−λ1(p2−p1)≈257+60.86−6065−60(239−257)≈253.90 N/mm2\begin{aligned}p_b&=p_1+\frac{\lambda_{LT}-\lambda_1}{\lambda_2-\lambda_1}(p_2-p_1)\\&\approx{\htmlClass{read}{257}}+\frac{60.86-{\htmlClass{given}{60}}}{{\htmlClass{given}{65}}-{\htmlClass{given}{60}}}({\htmlClass{read}{239}}-{\htmlClass{read}{257}})\approx253.90\ \mathrm{N/mm^2}\end{aligned}
    pb=p1+λLT−λ1λ2−λ1(p2−p1)≈257+60.86−6065−60(239−257)≈253.90 N/mm2\begin{aligned}p_b&=p_1+\frac{\lambda_{LT}-\lambda_1}{\lambda_2-\lambda_1}(p_2-p_1)\\&\approx{\htmlClass{read}{257}}+\frac{60.86-{\htmlClass{given}{60}}}{{\htmlClass{given}{65}}-{\htmlClass{given}{60}}}({\htmlClass{read}{239}}-{\htmlClass{read}{257}})\\&\approx253.90\ \mathrm{N/mm^2}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 60.8660.86 from Step 3.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 5 · Table 8.3a
    Table 8.3a, py = 355 column: λLT = 60 → 257 and λLT = 65 → 239 N/mm²; interpolating at λLT = 60.86 gives pb ≈ 253.9 N/mm².
    Table 8.3a, py=355p_y=355 column: λLT=60\lambda_{LT}=60 → 257 and λLT=65\lambda_{LT}=65 → 239 N/mm²; interpolating at λLT=60.86\lambda_{LT}=60.86 gives pb≈253.9 N/mm2p_b\approx253.9\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 24 October 00:29:23

  5. Step 5 · Resistance units

    Why this step: MbM_b is the largest moment this length can carry before lateral-torsional buckling. It is the capacity in this check and is compared with the demand later.

    With SS supplied in cm³, the conversions simplify to pb×S/1000p_b\times S/1000 in kNm.

    New symbols in this step
    • SxS_x, MbM_b: Plastic modulus cm³ or mm³; LTB resistance kNm
    Mb=pbSx≈253.8943(1471)/1000≈373.48 kNmM_b=p_bS_x\approx253.8943({\htmlClass{read}{1471}})/1000\approx373.48\ \mathrm{kNm}
    Mb=pbSx≈253.8943(1471)/1000≈373.48 kNm\begin{aligned}M_b&=p_bS_x\\&\approx253.8943({\htmlClass{read}{1471}})/1000\\&\approx373.48\ \mathrm{kNm}\end{aligned}

    Units: pbp_b is in N/mm² and SxS_x in cm³. Multiplying cm³ by 1000 gives mm³, so the product is in Nmm. Changing Nmm to kNm divides by 1000000, so the net step is a division by 1000.

  6. Step 6 · Demand factor

    Why this step: The moment in this length rises from zero at one end to the largest value at the other. Only a short part carries a high moment, which is less severe than the largest moment acting along the whole length.

    The segment moment diagram has β=0\beta=0, giving mLT=0.6m_{LT}=0.6. Do not multiply resistance by mLTm_{LT}.

    New symbols in this step
    • β\beta, mLTm_{LT}: Moment-diagram ratio and equivalent moment factor; dimensionless
    • M2M_2, M3M_3, M4M_4, MmaxM_{max}: Quarter-point and maximum moments from the same load case; kNm
    mLTMmax=0.6(333.144)=199.8864 kNmm_{LT}M_{max}={\htmlClass{read}{0.6}}({\htmlClass{given}{333.144}})=199.8864\ \mathrm{kNm}
    mLTMmax=0.6(333.144)=199.8864 kNm\begin{aligned}m_{LT}M_{max}&={\htmlClass{read}{0.6}}({\htmlClass{given}{333.144}})\\&=199.8864\ \mathrm{kNm}\end{aligned}
    Data file lookup · Data Page 6 · Table 8.4a
    Table 8.4a: β = 0 → mLT = 0.60.
    Table 8.4a: β=0\beta=0 → mLT=0.60m_{LT}=0.60.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
  7. Step 7 · Conclusion

    Why this step: Demand below capacity means this length will not move sideways and twist under the design loads. Whether the section itself fails in bending is still a separate check.

    199.89<373.48, so this segment passes LTB. The original moment has not physically changed to 199.89; that is the equivalent demand used in this check.

Conclusion

Small differences result from intermediate rounding. Keep the same pyp_y column throughout; do not interpolate arbitrarily between different strength columns.

All the symbols of this example

SymbolsMeaning and Units
LeL_e, ryr_yEffective unrestrained length and weak-axis radius of gyration; both in mm
λ\lambda, λLT\lambda_{LT}Ordinary and equivalent slenderness; dimensionless
uu, xx, vv, βw\beta_{w}Course LTB section/conversion parameters; dimensionless
pyp_y, pbp_bDesign yield and bending buckling strengths; N/mm²
SxS_x, MbM_bPlastic modulus cm³ or mm³; LTB resistance kNm
β\beta, mLTm_{LT}Moment-diagram ratio and equivalent moment factor; dimensionless
M2M_2, M3M_3, M4M_4, MmaxM_{max}Quarter-point and maximum moments from the same load case; kNm
λ1\lambda_1, λ2\lambda_2, p1p_1, p2p_2Slenderness and table values of the two rows used for interpolation

Video positions: 24 October 00:30:00 · 24 October 00:35:00

↑ Top