Worked Example

Pure-compression UC column: from two-axis lookup to capacity (Axial Compression)

Task: Use section dimensions and length to understand why the weak axis governs here.

Original question · Lecture notes Chapter 4, p. 21 (Example 1)
Original question with the given values boxed
Yellow boxes: values the question gives, the same values marked yellow in the Given table below.

The question in short: AnA_n S355 steel column is pinned at both ends, with an effective length of 6 m, and carries a compression force of 2500 kN. A 305×305×118 UC is tried. Decide whether the column can carry this force without buckling.

GivenValue and Unit
ProblemS355; pinned at both ends, effective length 6 m; Fc=2500 kN\htmlClass{given}{F_c=2500\ \mathrm{kN}}
Trial section305×305×118 UC; T=18.7 mm\htmlClass{read}{T=18.7\ \mathrm{mm}}, py=345 N/mm2\htmlClass{read}{p_y=345\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}}; Ag=150 cm2\htmlClass{read}{A_g=150\ \mathrm{cm^{2}}}; rx=13.6 cm\htmlClass{read}{r_x=13.6\ \mathrm{cm}}; ry=7.77 cm\htmlClass{read}{r_y=7.77\ \mathrm{cm}}

Yellow: values given in the question. The same values are marked where they are substituted in the steps below.
Orange box: values read directly from the Data File, the same values boxed orange in the lookup screenshots. A value interpolated between two table rows is a calculation, so it has no box.

Data file lookup · Data Page 11 · Universal Columns — Properties
305×305×118 UC: rx = 13.6 cm, ry = 7.77 cm, A = 150 cm².
305×305×118 UC: rx=13.6 cmr_x=13.6\ \mathrm{cm}, ry=7.77 cmr_y=7.77\ \mathrm{cm}, A=150 cm2A=150\ \mathrm{cm^{2}}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
Whole compression member bucklesλ = Le/rEnd restraints affect Le​
Supplementary schematic for understanding; not to scale.

Solution Route: Consistent units→two-axis slenderness λ\lambda→axis-specific curves→compare pcp_c→capacity versus demand.

Load path · the stations the force passes through, in order

The axial force passes straight down the column. The column can buckle about either axis; the more slender axis buckles first and sets the capacity.

  1. Axial compression
    Fc=2500 kNF_c=2500\ \mathrm{kN}
  2. Buckling about the xx axis
    λx≈44.1\lambda_{x}\approx44.1 → pcx ≈ 302 N/mm²
  3. Buckling about the yy axis (governs)
    λy≈77.2\lambda_{y}\approx77.2 → pcy = 193 N/mm²
  4. Compression buckling capacity
    Demand 2500 kNCapacity 2895 kN
    Utilisation 0.86
Each station links to the step that calculates it.
  1. Step 1 · Consistent lengths

    Why this step: A column can bow in two directions, so slenderness is found for each axis. The direction with the smaller rr is the thinner one, where the column bows more easily.

    Centimetres also work if numerator and denominator agree: 6 m=600 cm.

    New symbols in this step
    • LeL_e, rxr_x, ryr_y, λ\lambda: Effective length and radius of gyration mm; dimensionless slenderness
    λx=LE/rx=600/13.6≈44.1λy=LE/ry=600/7.77≈77.2\begin{aligned}\lambda_x&=L_E/r_x={\htmlClass{given}{600}}/{\htmlClass{read}{13.6}}\approx44.1\\\lambda_y&=L_E/r_y={\htmlClass{given}{600}}/{\htmlClass{read}{7.77}}\approx77.2\end{aligned}

    Units: The 6 m effective length is multiplied by 100 to give 600 cm, the same unit as rxr_x and ryr_y. Centimetres divided by centimetres leave slenderness with no unit.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 11 · Universal Columns — Dimensions
    305×305×118 UC: flange T = 18.7 mm (between 16 and 40 mm).
    305×305×118 UC: flange T=18.7 mmT=18.7\ \mathrm{mm} (between 16 and 40 mm).Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
    Data file lookup · Data Page 1 · Design strength pyp_y
    T = 18.7 mm thick: the T ≤ 40 mm row, S355 column gives py = 345 N/mm².
    T=18.7 mmT=18.7\ \mathrm{mm} thick: the T≤40 mmT\le40\ \mathrm{mm} row, S355 column gives py=345 N/mm2p_y=345\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}. How the grade and thickness choose this row →Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 24 October 02:15:00

  2. Step 2 · Choose curves

    Why this step: pcp_c is the compressive stress the column can carry before it bows. The more slender the column, the further pcp_c falls below pyp_y; here the weak axis gives a clearly lower pcp_c.

    The lecturer selects each curve from section type, thickness and buckling axis. Do not simply use one curve and change λ\lambda.

    New symbols in this step
    • λ1\lambda_1, λ2\lambda_2, p1p_1, p2p_2: Slenderness and table values of the two rows used for interpolation
    pcx≈302 N/mm2(λx=44.1)pcy=p1+λy−λ1λ2−λ1(p2−p1)=196+77.2−7678−76(191−196)=193 N/mm2\begin{aligned}p_{cx}&\approx{\htmlClass{read}{302}}\ \mathrm{N/mm^2}\quad(\lambda_x=44.1)\\p_{cy}&=p_1+\frac{\lambda_y-\lambda_1}{\lambda_2-\lambda_1}(p_2-p_1)\\&={\htmlClass{read}{196}}+\frac{77.2-{\htmlClass{given}{76}}}{{\htmlClass{given}{78}}-{\htmlClass{given}{76}}}({\htmlClass{read}{191}}-{\htmlClass{read}{196}})=193\ \mathrm{N/mm^2}\end{aligned}
    pcx≈302 N/mm2(λx=44.1)pcy=p1+λy−λ1λ2−λ1(p2−p1)=196+77.2−7678−76(191−196)=193 N/mm2\begin{aligned}p_{cx}&\approx{\htmlClass{read}{302}}\ \mathrm{N/mm^2}\\&(\lambda_x=44.1)\\p_{cy}&=p_1+\frac{\lambda_y-\lambda_1}{\lambda_2-\lambda_1}(p_2-p_1)\\&={\htmlClass{read}{196}}+\frac{77.2-{\htmlClass{given}{76}}}{{\htmlClass{given}{78}}-{\htmlClass{given}{76}}}({\htmlClass{read}{191}}-{\htmlClass{read}{196}})\\&=193\ \mathrm{N/mm^2}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 44.144.1 from Step 1; 77.277.2 from Step 1.

    Data file lookup · Data Page 7 · Table 8.7 Buckling curves
    Rolled H-section with thickness ≤ 40 mm: use curve b about the x-x axis and curve c about the y-y axis.
    Rolled H-section with thickness ≤ 40 mm: use curve b about the x-xx\text{-}x axis and curve c about the y-yy\text{-}y axis.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
    Data file lookup · Data Page 8 · Table 8.8(b)
    Table 8.8(b) (x axis, curve b), py = 345 column: λ = 44 → 302 and λ = 46 → 298 N/mm²; λx = 44.1 gives pc ≈ 302 N/mm².
    Table 8.8(b) (xx axis, curve b), py=345p_y=345 column: λ=44\lambda=44 → 302 and λ=46\lambda=46 → 298 N/mm²; λx=44.1\lambda_{x}=44.1 gives pc≈302 N/mm2p_c\approx302\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too
    Data file lookup · Data Page 8 · Table 8.8(c)
    Table 8.8(c) (y axis, curve c), py = 345 column: λ = 76 → 196 and λ = 78 → 191 N/mm²; interpolating at λy = 77.2 gives pc ≈ 193 N/mm².
    Table 8.8(c) (yy axis, curve c), py=345p_y=345 column: λ=76\lambda=76 → 196 and λ=78\lambda=78 → 191 N/mm²; interpolating at λy=77.2\lambda_{y}=77.2 gives pc≈193 N/mm2p_c\approx193\ \mathrm{N/mm^{2}}.Yellow: given parameter, row or columnOrange: value read from the table, boxed orange in the text too

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 24 October 02:24:51

  3. Step 3 · Take the governing value

    Why this step: The column buckles in whichever direction is easiest, so the smaller pcp_c decides the result. Here that is the weak yy axis, so the column would bow about the yy axis.

    The axis lookups give 302 and 193. Use the smaller 193 for governing resistance.

    New symbols in this step
    • AgA_g, pyp_y, pcp_c: Gross area mm²; yield and compression buckling strengths N/mm²
    pc=min⁡(pcx, pcy)=min⁡(302, 193)=193 N/mm2p_c=\min(p_{cx},\ p_{cy})=\min({\htmlClass{read}{302}},\ 193)=193\ \mathrm{N/mm^2}
    pc=min⁡(pcx, pcy)=min⁡(302, 193)=193 N/mm2\begin{aligned}p_c&=\min(p_{cx},\ p_{cy})\\&=\min({\htmlClass{read}{302}},\ 193)\\&=193\ \mathrm{N/mm^2}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 193193 from Step 2.

    Load path · A column can buckle about either axis
    Buckling about x–xλx​ = 600 / 13.6 ≈ 44.1pcx​ ≈ 302 N/mm²xybows in the y directionBuckling about y–y (governs)λy​ = 600 / 7.77 ≈ 77.2pcy​ = 193 N/mm²xybows in the x directionUse the smaller pc​ = 193 N/mm²Pc​ = Ag pc​ = 2895 kN > Fc​ = 2500 kN
    The same column and the same effective length, but the two axes have different radii of gyration. ryr_y is smaller, so λy\lambda_{y} is larger and buckling about yy–yy comes first (red); the compressive strength pcp_c is the smaller of the two.
  4. Step 4 · Convert area

    Why this step: PcP_c is the largest compression force the whole column can carry before it bows: the stress each square millimetre can take, multiplied by the full area of the section.

    150 cm²=15000 mm². This conversion is easily missed.

    New symbols in this step
    • FcF_c, PcP_c: Design axial force and buckling compression resistance; kN
    Pc=Agpc=150(100)(193)/1000=2895 kNP_c=A_gp_c={\htmlClass{read}{150}}(100)(193)/1000=2895\ \mathrm{kN}
    Pc=Agpc=150(100)(193)/1000=2895 kN\begin{aligned}P_c&=A_gp_c\\&={\htmlClass{read}{150}}(100)(193)/1000\\&=2895\ \mathrm{kN}\end{aligned}

    Where the numbers come from: 193193 from Step 2.

    Units: The area of 150 cm² is multiplied by 100 to change it into mm². N/mm² times mm² gives N, and dividing by 1000 gives kN.

    ▶ The lecturer on this part: 24 October 02:20:00

  5. Step 5 · Comparison

    Why this step: A ratio below 1 means the design force is not enough to make the column bow. The part left over is the margin of safety.

    Resistance exceeds design axial force FcF_c.

    η=Fc/Pc=2500/2895≈0.864<1\eta=F_c/P_c={\htmlClass{given}{2500}}/2895\approx0.864<1

    Where the numbers come from: 28952895 from Step 4.

Conclusion

Pure-compression buckling passes. Adding bending requires the relevant interaction expressions; FcF_c versus PcP_c alone is then insufficient.

All the symbols of this example

SymbolsMeaning and Units
FcF_c, PcP_cDesign axial force and buckling compression resistance; kN
AgA_g, pyp_y, pcp_cGross area mm²; yield and compression buckling strengths N/mm²
LeL_e, rxr_x, ryr_y, λ\lambdaEffective length and radius of gyration mm; dimensionless slenderness
λ1\lambda_1, λ2\lambda_2, p1p_1, p2p_2Slenderness and table values of the two rows used for interpolation

Video positions: 24 October 02:15:00 · 24 October 02:25:00 · 24 October 03:00:00

↑ Top