Note: marks are as printed in the paper; the working is a teaching guide, not an official marking scheme.
In-plane eccentricity: direct shear plus torsion
Given dead load 120 kN, imposed load 170 kN, S355 and Class 42 electrodes. The four-sided weld rectangle is 280 mm wide and 420 mm high. The 330 mm dimension runs from its dashed centreline to the load line; do not add another half-width. Treat the four sides as a continuous closed weld centreline, with one bracket plate.
Simple explanation — open only if needed
The load makes the weld group slide down and rotate. At the critical corner, the rotation’s vertical part helps the downward sliding. Add those vertical parts, then combine with the horizontal part using a right-angled triangle.
The Class 42/S355 row gives weld design strength 250 N/mm². A fillet of leg size s has effective throat 0.7s. Work with force per unit weld length, q, in kN/mm; line second moments have units mm³, not mm⁴.
Take a corner on the side where torsional vertical shear adds to direct vertical shear. The opposite side has subtraction and is less severe. Signs choose the corner; the resistance check uses the resultant magnitude.
Provide a 6 mm continuous fillet on the four sides under the stated centreline model. Strength passes; parent/support thickness and detailing remain conditional.
Common mistakes
Do not add the magnitudes of perpendicular force components directly.
Do not add half the width to the given centroid eccentricity.
Procedure for a new variant
Locate centroid, load line and critical corner.
Calculate line length, polar line moment, direct shear and torsional components.
Resolve vectors, size the throat, round up and check detailing.
Independent self-check — invented variant
Invented variant: eccentricity becomes zero. Find the strength-only minimum leg size.
Hint
Set the torsional moment to zero.
Answer and reasoning
sreq=0.7(250)1000(440/1400)=1.795918mm
Only direct shear remains. Do not specify a 1.80 mm weld without checking the independent minimum size/detailing requirements.