Steelwork · Exam learning

2022–2024 · Exam-focused route

2022 AQ1 — floor beams and fire protection Section A · compulsory

A complete 40-mark compulsory question. The highest-value habit is tracing which beam receives each slab strip and reaction.

Original source: 21ENGTY031.pdf · physical page 2

Note: marks are as printed in the paper; the working is a teaching guide, not an official marking scheme.

Read the load path before using a formula

Given: 150 mm slab, concrete unit weight 24.5 kN/m³, finishes 0.5 kN/m², imposed load 5 kN/m²; S355 beams, simple end supports, full slab restraint to the compression flange and brittle finishes. Find ULS actions, section classes, shear/bending resistance, imposed-load deflection, then sketch two fire-protection methods.

In the original plan, B1 spans 8 m. Its tributary width is 3.2 m: half the adjacent strip on each side. The central B2 span is 6.4 m, between the I-shaped column symbols. At its midpoint, TWO B1 members meet from opposite sides, so add their two end reactions. The slab load must not be applied to B2 a second time.

Simple explanation — open only if needed

Imagine the slab passing parcels to B1. Each B1 passes half its parcels to each support. The middle beam receives a parcel pile from each side, so the piles add. Its own weight is a separate load spread along its length.

Prerequisites: intensity × tributary width = line load; force × lever arm = moment. Use kN and metres for statics. Use N, mm and N/mm² for deflection and strength. One kN/m equals one N/mm. All intermediate values below are calculated without rounding until the displayed answer.

Collect the section data once

Source: LectureNotes/CON4334-Data File-20260730.pdf · p.1, p.9, p.10

Look up the exact section designation, not the nearest depth. The mass column gives 60.1 and 82.1 kg/m; the rounded 60 and 82 in the names are labels. The flange thickness selects the design-strength row. E = 205,000 N/mm² is the course elastic modulus.

Beam / sectionDimensions and ratiosProperties
B1 / 406 × 178 × 60 UBD=406.4, t=7.9, T=12.8  mmD=406.4,\ t=7.9,\ T=12.8\;\mathrm{mm}
b/T=6.95, d/t=45.6b/T=6.95,\ d/t=45.6
Ix=21600  cm4, Zx=1063  cm3, Sx=1199  cm3I_x=21600\;\mathrm{cm^4},\ Z_x=1063\;\mathrm{cm^3},\ S_x=1199\;\mathrm{cm^3}
py=355  N/mm2p_y=355\;\mathrm{N/mm^2}
B2 / 457 × 152 × 82 UBD=465.8, t=10.5, T=18.9  mmD=465.8,\ t=10.5,\ T=18.9\;\mathrm{mm}
b/T=4.11, d/t=38.8b/T=4.11,\ d/t=38.8
Ix=36590  cm4, Zx=1571  cm3, Sx=1811  cm3I_x=36590\;\mathrm{cm^4},\ Z_x=1571\;\mathrm{cm^3},\ S_x=1811\;\mathrm{cm^3}
py=345  N/mm2p_y=345\;\mathrm{N/mm^2}

D is overall depth, t web thickness, T flange thickness, b flange outstand used by the table, d clear web depth, I second moment of area, Z elastic modulus and S plastic modulus. The table gives centimetre-based I, Z and S; convert explicitly below.

AQ1(a)(i) — slab design intensity [4 marks]

Convert slab thickness to metres before multiplying by concrete unit weight. Apply the course gravity ULS factors once to characteristic permanent and imposed loads.

gk=0.150 m×24.5 kN/m3+0.5 kN/m2=4.175 kN/m2g_k=0.150\,\mathrm{m}\times24.5\,\mathrm{kN/m^3}+0.5\,\mathrm{kN/m^2}=4.175\,\mathrm{kN/m^2}
qu=1.4gk+1.6qk=1.4(4.175)+1.6(5)=13.845 kN/m2q_u=1.4g_k+1.6q_k=1.4(4.175)+1.6(5)=13.845\,\mathrm{kN/m^2}

AQ1(a)(ii) — actions on both beams [8 marks]

To turn the beam mass (kg/m) into a load (kN/m), use g = 10 m/s². The 2022 paper does not state g, so we use the usual course value; write “take g = 10 m/s²” in your answer. If a paper gives another g, only the self-weight terms change.

wg1=60.1(10)/1000=0.601 kN/m,wg2=82.1(10)/1000=0.821 kN/mw_{g1}=60.1(10)/1000=0.601\,\mathrm{kN/m},\quad w_{g2}=82.1(10)/1000=0.821\,\mathrm{kN/m}
wu1=13.845(3.2)+1.4(0.601)=45.1454 kN/mw_{u1}=13.845(3.2)+1.4(0.601)=45.1454\,\mathrm{kN/m}

For a simply supported beam with uniform load, equilibrium shares the total load equally; the maximum sagging moment is at midspan.

V1,max=R1=wu1L12=45.1454(8)2=180.5816 kNV_{1,max}=R_1=\frac{w_{u1}L_1}{2}=\frac{45.1454(8)}{2}=180.5816\,\mathrm{kN}
M1,max=wu1L128=45.1454(82)8=361.1632 kN mM_{1,max}=\frac{w_{u1}L_1^2}{8}=\frac{45.1454(8^2)}{8}=361.1632\,\mathrm{kN\,m}

B2 receives the two B1 reactions as ONE midspan point load. Add its own factored self-weight as a UDL; superpose the two standard simple-beam solutions.

Pu=2R1=2(180.5816)=361.1632 kN,wu2=1.4(0.821)=1.1494 kN/mP_u=2R_1=2(180.5816)=361.1632\,\mathrm{kN},\quad w_{u2}=1.4(0.821)=1.1494\,\mathrm{kN/m}
V2,max=Pu2+wu2L22=361.16322+1.1494(6.4)2=184.25968 kNV_{2,max}=\frac{P_u}{2}+\frac{w_{u2}L_2}{2}=\frac{361.1632}{2}+\frac{1.1494(6.4)}{2}=184.25968\,\mathrm{kN}
M2,max=PuL24+wu2L228=361.1632(6.4)4+1.1494(6.42)8=583.746048 kN mM_{2,max}=\frac{P_uL_2}{4}+\frac{w_{u2}L_2^2}{8}=\frac{361.1632(6.4)}{4}+\frac{1.1494(6.4^2)}{8}=583.746048\,\mathrm{kN\,m}

Check: the two reactions of the supporting beam equal its point load plus its total self-weight. No extra slab UDL is added.

AQ1(a)(iii) — classification [4 marks]

Source: LectureNotes/CON4334-Data File-20260730.pdf · p.1

Use the material strength selected by flange thickness. For a rolled I section in pure major-axis bending, Class 1 limits are 9ε for the compression-flange outstand and 80ε for the web. Both must pass. The web limit for uniform axial compression is different and must not be used here.

B1

ϵ=275/355=0.880141,b/T=6.95<9ϵ=7.921,d/t=45.6<80ϵ=70.411\epsilon=\sqrt{275/355}=0.880141,\quad b/T=6.95<9\epsilon=7.921,\quad d/t=45.6<80\epsilon=70.411

B2

ϵ=275/345=0.892805,b/T=4.11<9ϵ=8.035,d/t=38.8<80ϵ=71.424\epsilon=\sqrt{275/345}=0.892805,\quad b/T=4.11<9\epsilon=8.035,\quad d/t=38.8<80\epsilon=71.424

Both sections are Class 1, so the low-shear bending check may use the plastic modulus, subject to the elastic-modulus cap.

AQ1(a)(iv) — B1 adequacy [10 marks]

Source: LectureNotes/Ch3_Beam.pdf · p.2, p.3

Shear is carried mainly by the web. The course rolled-I shear area is overall depth times web thickness. Multiply area by shear strength, then divide by 1,000 to obtain kN.

Av=Dt=406.4(7.9)=3210.56 mm2A_v=Dt=406.4(7.9)=3210.56\,\mathrm{mm^2}
Pv=pyAv/(3 1000)=355(3210.56)/(3 1000)=658.034276 kNP_v=p_yA_v/(\sqrt3\,1000)=355(3210.56)/(\sqrt3\,1000)=658.034276\,\mathrm{kN}
Vmax=180.5816 kN<0.6Pv=394.820566 kNV_{max}=180.5816\,\mathrm{kN}<0.6P_v=394.820566\,\mathrm{kN}

Shear passes and lies in the low-shear range, so no high-shear reduction is needed. Full slab restraint is given; this question needs section bending resistance, not an unrestrained-beam LTB calculation.

Mc=min⁡(pySx,1.2pyZx)/1000=min⁡(355(1199),1.2(355)(1063))/1000=425.645 kN mM_c=\min(p_yS_x,1.2p_yZ_x)/1000=\min(355(1199),1.2(355)(1063))/1000=425.645\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
Mmax=361.1632 kN m<Mc=425.645 kN mM_{max}=361.1632\,\mathrm{kN\,m}<M_c=425.645\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
Source: LectureNotes/Ch1_Introduction.pdf · p.16, p.17

Deflection check (brittle finishes): use the unfactored imposed load only and the limit span/360. Do not apply the ULS load factors or add the beam’s own weight here.

wQ=5(3.2)=16.0 kN/m=16.0 N/mmw_Q=5(3.2)=16.0\,\mathrm{kN/m}=16.0\,\mathrm{N/mm}
δ=5wQL4384EIx=5(16.0)(80004)384(205000)(21600×104)=19.271304 mm\delta=\frac{5w_QL^4}{384EI_x}=\frac{5(16.0)(8000^4)}{384(205000)(21600\times10^4)}=19.271304\,\mathrm{mm}
δlim=8000360=22.222222 mm>δ\delta_{lim}=\frac{8000}{360}=22.222222\,\mathrm{mm}>\delta

All three requested checks pass under the stated load model.

AQ1(a)(v) — B2 adequacy [10 marks]

Source: LectureNotes/Ch3_Beam.pdf · p.2, p.3

Shear is carried mainly by the web. The course rolled-I shear area is overall depth times web thickness. Multiply area by shear strength, then divide by 1,000 to obtain kN.

Av=Dt=465.8(10.5)=4890.9 mm2A_v=Dt=465.8(10.5)=4890.9\,\mathrm{mm^2}
Pv=pyAv/(3 1000)=345(4890.9)/(3 1000)=974.198039 kNP_v=p_yA_v/(\sqrt3\,1000)=345(4890.9)/(\sqrt3\,1000)=974.198039\,\mathrm{kN}
Vmax=184.25968 kN<0.6Pv=584.518823 kNV_{max}=184.25968\,\mathrm{kN}<0.6P_v=584.518823\,\mathrm{kN}

Shear passes and lies in the low-shear range, so no high-shear reduction is needed. Full slab restraint is given; this question needs section bending resistance, not an unrestrained-beam LTB calculation.

Mc=min⁡(pySx,1.2pyZx)/1000=min⁡(345(1811),1.2(345)(1571))/1000=624.795 kN mM_c=\min(p_yS_x,1.2p_yZ_x)/1000=\min(345(1811),1.2(345)(1571))/1000=624.795\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
Mmax=583.746048 kN m<Mc=624.795 kN mM_{max}=583.746048\,\mathrm{kN\,m}<M_c=624.795\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
Source: LectureNotes/Ch1_Introduction.pdf · p.16, p.17

Deflection check (brittle finishes): use the unfactored imposed load only and the limit span/360. Do not apply the ULS load factors or add the beam’s own weight here.

PQ=2[5(3.2)(8)2]=128.0 kNP_Q=2\left[\frac{5(3.2)(8)}{2}\right]=128.0\,\mathrm{kN}
δ=PQL348EIx=(128.0×1000)(64003)48(205000)(36590×104)=9.319495 mm\delta=\frac{P_QL^3}{48EI_x}=\frac{(128.0\times1000)(6400^3)}{48(205000)(36590\times10^4)}=9.319495\,\mathrm{mm}
δlim=6400360=17.777778 mm>δ\delta_{lim}=\frac{6400}{360}=17.777778\,\mathrm{mm}>\delta

All three requested checks pass under the stated load model.

AQ1(b) — two fire-protection methods [4 marks]

Source: LectureNotes/Ch1_Introduction.pdf · p.3
Teaching sketches: an insulating coating follows the steel profile; protective boards enclose the steel with supported joints.
Teaching sketches: an insulating coating follows the steel profile; protective boards enclose the steel with supported joints. Full-size image
  • Sprayed fire-resisting material: draw the I section with a continuous external insulation layer. Label steel, sprayed protection and exposure to fire. The layer slows heat transfer to steel so it retains useful strength for longer.
  • Board encasement: draw a box around the I section, identify fire-resisting boards and their supports/joints. The enclosure delays heating. Do not claim a specific fire-resistance duration without a specified tested system.

For the full 4 marks: two methods, each with a labelled sketch and one sentence on how it slows down the heating of the steel.

Compact exam script

Reveal the exam script
qu=13.845 kN/m2;(V1,M1)=(180.582,361.163);(V2,M2)=(184.26,583.746)q_u=13.845\,\mathrm{kN/m^2};\quad(V_1,M_1)=(180.582,361.163);\quad(V_2,M_2)=(184.26,583.746)

Actions above are in kN and kN·m respectively. Both sections Class 1. B1: Pv 658.034 kN, Mc 425.645 kN·m, δ 19.271 mm < 22.222 mm. B2: Pv 974.198 kN, Mc 624.795 kN·m, δ 9.319 mm < 17.778 mm. Both pass. State g=10 and the two-reaction load path. For (b), give the two labelled sketches and explain delayed heating.

Common mistakes

  • Do not use just one B1 reaction at the middle beam.
  • Do not use ultimate loads in the imposed-load deflection check.
  • Do not confuse cm⁴ with mm⁴: the conversion factor is 10,000.

Procedure for a new variant

  1. Trace slab → B1 → supporting beam → columns.
  2. Factor gravity loads, include each beam self-weight once, then solve statics.
  3. Classify, check shear range, bending and unfactored deflection.

Independent self-check — invented variant

Invented change: the middle beam receives only one B1 end reaction, with every other input unchanged. Which terms halve?

Hint

Separate the point-load solution from the self-weight UDL solution.

Answer and reasoning

Its B1 point-load contribution to shear, moment and live-load deflection halves. Its own-weight UDL contribution does not halve. B1 actions do not change. Recalculate by replacing the two-reaction point load with one reaction.