Steelwork · Exam learning

2014–2019 · Reference answers

2016-01-08 — column answer

Check 305 × 305 × 137 UC under combined compression and biaxial bending.

Independent teaching answer, not an official solution or marking scheme. Printed marks are retained. Read the source conditions beside each result.

Strategy and prerequisites

Units: 1 kN = 1,000 N; 1 m = 1,000 mm; 1 cm³ = 1,000 mm³; 1 cm⁴ = 10,000 mm⁴. A demand is the load effect; a resistance is what the member can carry. Compare matching units.

Simple explanation — open only if needed

A section is one slice of the column; buckling concerns the whole long member. Three passing checks are needed, just as a strong ruler can still bend sideways when pushed at its ends.

Biaxial column checks [30 marks]

Source: LectureNotes/CON4334-Data File-20260730.pdf · p.1, p.11

Exact UC row: 305 × 305 × 137. A is gross area, r radius of gyration, Z elastic modulus, S plastic modulus. Convert the tabulated radii from cm to mm; do not use nominal section size as a radius.

T=21.7, t=13.8, d=246.7, rx=137, ry=78.3(mm)T=21.7,\ t=13.8,\ d=246.7,\ r_x=137,\ r_y=78.3\quad(\mathrm{mm})
Ag=174×100=17400 mm2A_g=174\times100=17400\,\mathrm{mm^2}
Zx=2048, Zy=692, Sx=2297, Sy=1053(cm3)Z_x=2048,\ Z_y=692,\ S_x=2297,\ S_y=1053\quad(\mathrm{cm^3})
u=0.851, x=14.2, py=345 N/mm2u=0.851,\ x=14.2,\ p_y=345\,\mathrm{N/mm^2}

The conservative Class 1 web bound 40ε is valid for the course combined-stress formula because its axial stress parameter is bounded by one. Check the flange separately; use the worse class.

ϵf=275/345=0.892805,b/T=7.12,9ϵf=8.035,10ϵf=8.928\epsilon_f=\sqrt{275/345}=0.892805,\quad b/T=7.12,\quad9\epsilon_f=8.035,\quad10\epsilon_f=8.928
d/t=17.9<40275/355=35.205633d/t=17.9<40\sqrt{275/355}=35.205633

Overall Class 1.

The signs are clockwise applied end moments on opposite end faces. Reverse the bottom-face sign to form the INTERNAL end-moment ratio. This avoids choosing the wrong moment-factor branch. Keep first-order Mx/My, amplified moments and the separately specified MLT distinct.

N=1800 kN,(Mx,top,Mx,bottom)=(150,70),(My,top,My,bottom)=(90,−50)(kN m)N=1800\,\mathrm{kN},\quad (M_{x,top},M_{x,bottom})=(150,70),\quad(M_{y,top},M_{y,bottom})=(90,-50)\quad(\mathrm{kN\,m})
Mx=150,My=90,MLT=165(kN m)M_x=150,\quad M_y=90,\quad M_{LT}=165\quad(\mathrm{kN\,m})
βx=−(70)/(150)=−0.466667,βy=−(−50)/(90)=0.555556\beta_x=-(70)/(150)=-0.466667,\quad\beta_y=-(-50)/(90)=0.555556
Source: LectureNotes/Ch4_Column.pdf · p.18
m=0.6+0.4β (β≥0),m=0.6+0.2β (β<0)m=0.6+0.4\beta\ (\beta\ge0),\qquad m=0.6+0.2\beta\ (\beta<0)
mx=0.506667,my=0.822222,mLT=max⁡(0.44,0.6+0.4βx)=0.44m_x=0.506667,\quad m_y=0.822222,\quad m_{LT}=\max(0.44,0.6+0.4\beta_x)=0.44
LE=KL=0.85(6000)=5100 mmL_E=KL=0.85(6000)=5100\,\mathrm{mm}
M^x=1.1(150)=165,M^y=1.2(90)=108(kN m)\widehat M_x=1.1(150)=165,\quad\widehat M_y=1.2(90)=108\quad(\mathrm{kN\,m})

At a section, combine compression and amplified bending using capped plastic resistances for Class 1/2. All three fractions are dimensionless.

NRd=174(100)(345)/1000=6003 kNN_{Rd}=174(100)(345)/1000=6003\,\mathrm{kN}
Mcx=min⁡(345(2297),1.2(345)(2048))/1000=792.465 kN mM_{cx}=\min(345(2297),1.2(345)(2048))/1000=792.465\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
Mcy=min⁡(345(1053),1.2(345)(692))/1000=286.488 kN mM_{cy}=\min(345(1053),1.2(345)(692))/1000=286.488\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
ηs=18006003+165792.465+108286.488=0.88504\eta_s=\frac{1800}{6003}+\frac{165}{792.465}+\frac{108}{286.488}=0.88504

PASS

Source: LectureNotes/CON4334-Data File-20260730.pdf · p.7, p.8

Rolled UC with flange thickness 21.7 mm ≤ 40 mm: curve b about x and curve c about y. Use py = 345 N/mm² in both tables. Linear interpolation uses adjacent slenderness rows, not the nearest section size.

λx=5100/137=37.226277,λy=5100/78.3=65.1341\lambda_x=5100/137=37.226277,\quad\lambda_y=5100/78.3=65.1341
pcx=318+37.226277−3540−35(310−318)=314.437956 N/mm2p_{cx}=318+\frac{37.226277-35}{40-35}(310-318)=314.437956\,\mathrm{N/mm^2}
pcy=230+65.1341−6466−64(224−230)=226.597701 N/mm2p_{cy}=230+\frac{65.1341-64}{66-64}(224-230)=226.597701\,\mathrm{N/mm^2}
Pcx=174(314.437956)/10=5471.220438 kNP_{cx}=174(314.437956)/10=5471.220438\,\mathrm{kN}
Pcy=174(226.597701)/10=3942.8 kNP_{cy}=174(226.597701)/10=3942.8\,\mathrm{kN}
λ=5100/78.3=65.1341\lambda=5100/78.3=65.1341
v=[1+0.05(65.1341/14.2)2]−1/4=0.835519v=[1+0.05(65.1341/14.2)^2]^{-1/4}=0.835519
λLT=0.851(0.835519)(65.1341)=46.312087\lambda_{LT}=0.851(0.835519)(65.1341)=46.312087
Source: LectureNotes/CON4334-Data File-20260730.pdf · p.5

Table 8.3: py 345 column, λLT rows 45 to 50.

pb=302+46.312087−4550−45(285−302)=297.538904 N/mm2p_b=302+\frac{46.312087-45}{50-45}(285-302)=297.538904\,\mathrm{N/mm^2}
Mb=297.538904(2297)/1000=683.446863 kN mM_b=297.538904(2297)/1000=683.446863\,\mathrm{kN\,m}

Member interaction uses ELASTIC moduli in the ordinary bending denominators. First equation: smaller axial buckling resistance and amplified moments. Second equation: Pcy and MLT, with first-order minor-axis moment.

Source: LectureNotes/Ch4_Column.pdf · p.20
Mex=345(2048)/1000=706.56,Mey=345(692)/1000=238.74(kN m)M_{ex}=345(2048)/1000=706.56,\quad M_{ey}=345(692)/1000=238.74\quad(\mathrm{kN\,m})
ηf=Nmin⁡(Pcx,Pcy)+mxM^xMex+myM^yMey\eta_f=\frac{N}{\min(P_{cx},P_{cy})}+\frac{m_x\widehat M_x}{M_{ex}}+\frac{m_y\widehat M_y}{M_{ey}}
ηf=18003942.8+0.506667(165)706.56+0.822222(108)238.74=0.946801\eta_f=\frac{1800}{3942.8}+\frac{0.506667(165)}{706.56}+\frac{0.822222(108)}{238.74}=0.946801

PASS

ηLT=NPcy+mLTMLTMb+myMyMey\eta_{LT}=\frac{N}{P_{cy}}+\frac{m_{LT}M_{LT}}{M_b}+\frac{m_yM_y}{M_{ey}}
ηLT=18003942.8+0.44(165)683.446863+0.822222(90)238.74=0.872715\eta_{LT}=\frac{1800}{3942.8}+\frac{0.44(165)}{683.446863}+\frac{0.822222(90)}{238.74}=0.872715

PASS

Compact exam answer — key result lines
ηs=0.88504,ηf=0.946801,ηLT=0.872715\eta_s=0.88504,\quad\eta_f=0.946801,\quad\eta_{LT}=0.872715

All three checks: PASS under the stated model.

Procedure and common mistakes

Identify the model → axes and actions → class → section → both strut curves → LTB → both member equations. Do not halve axial load, swap x/y moduli, replace the given effective length with the actual height, or amplify MLT twice.

Independent practice — invented variant

Invented variant: axial load increases by 100 kN, moments and class unchanged. How does each utilisation change?

Hint

Only the axial-force numerator changes in this stated variant.

Reveal answer
Δηs=100/6003=0.016658,Δηf=100/3942.8=0.025363,ΔηLT=100/3942.8=0.025363\Delta\eta_s=100/6003=0.016658,\quad\Delta\eta_f=100/3942.8=0.025363,\quad\Delta\eta_{LT}=100/3942.8=0.025363