Steelwork · Exam learning

2014–2019 · Reference answers

2016-01-08 — beam answers

All independent beam subquestions, including the required sketches and restraint variants.

Independent teaching answer, not an official solution or marking scheme. Printed marks are retained. Read the source conditions beside each result.

Read the diagram and choose the checks

Units: 1 kN = 1,000 N; 1 m = 1,000 mm; 1 cm³ = 1,000 mm³; 1 cm⁴ = 10,000 mm⁴. A demand is the load effect; a resistance is what the member can carry. Compare matching units.

The member is 457 × 191 × 74 UB, S355, simply supported over 7 m, with compression-flange restraints at its ends. Read M and V as ultimate design actions; Q is the unfactored imposed load for deflection. Do not factor a given design moment again.

Source: LectureNotes/CON4334-Data File-20260730.pdf · p.9, p.10

Lookup the exact 457 × 191 × 74 UB row. Read dimensions first, properties second. D = overall depth; t = web thickness; T = flange thickness; d = clear web depth. The designation is not an exact dimension.

D=457, t=9, T=14.5, d=407.6(mm)D=457,\ t=9,\ T=14.5,\ d=407.6\quad(\mathrm{mm})
b/T=6.57, d/t=45.3, Ix=33320 cm4, Zx=1458 cm3, Sx=1653 cm3b/T=6.57,\ d/t=45.3,\ I_x=33320\,\mathrm{cm^4},\ Z_x=1458\,\mathrm{cm^3},\ S_x=1653\,\mathrm{cm^3}
ry=42 mm,u=0.877,x=33.9r_y=42\,\mathrm{mm},\quad u=0.877,\quad x=33.9

Section classification [2 marks]

Source: LectureNotes/CON4334-Data File-20260730.pdf · p.1

S355 design strength depends on the actual flange thickness. Local classification decides whether plastic bending resistance is allowed. In pure bending the web limit is different from uniform compression.

py=355 N/mm2,ϵ=275/355=0.880141p_y=355\,\mathrm{N/mm^2},\quad\epsilon=\sqrt{275/355}=0.880141
b/T=6.57,9ϵ=7.921,10ϵ=8.801,13ϵ=11.442b/T=6.57,\quad9\epsilon=7.921,\quad10\epsilon=8.801,\quad13\epsilon=11.442
d/t=45.3<80ϵ=70.411⟹Class 1d/t=45.3<80\epsilon=70.411\quad\Longrightarrow\quad\mathrm{Class}\ 1

Take the worse flange/web class. Class 1 or 2 permits the capped plastic modulus; Class 3 uses the elastic modulus.

Compact exam answer — key result lines
py=355 N/mm2,ϵ=275/355=0.880141p_y=355\,\mathrm{N/mm^2},\quad\epsilon=\sqrt{275/355}=0.880141
b/T=6.57,9ϵ=7.921,10ϵ=8.801,13ϵ=11.442b/T=6.57,\quad9\epsilon=7.921,\quad10\epsilon=8.801,\quad13\epsilon=11.442
d/t=45.3<80ϵ=70.411⟹Class 1d/t=45.3<80\epsilon=70.411\quad\Longrightarrow\quad\mathrm{Class}\ 1

Take the worse flange/web class. Class 1 or 2 permits the capped plastic modulus; Class 3 uses the elastic modulus.

Shear and section resistance [4 marks]

Source: LectureNotes/CON4334-Data File-20260730.pdf · p.2

The web carries shear. For a rolled UB use Av = Dt, then the course shear resistance pyAv/√3. The 0.6 factor below is the low-shear threshold; it is not the coefficient in the shear-resistance formula.

Av=457(9)=4113 mm2A_v=457(9)=4113\,\mathrm{mm^2}
Vc=pyAv3=355(4113)3(1000)=842.997788 kNV_c=\frac{p_yA_v}{\sqrt3}=\frac{355(4113)}{\sqrt3(1000)}=842.997788\,\mathrm{kN}
V=100 kN,V/Vc=0.118624,0.6Vc=505.798673 kNV=100\,\mathrm{kN},\quad V/V_c=0.118624,\quad0.6V_c=505.798673\,\mathrm{kN}

PASS

Mc=min⁡(pySx,1.2pyZx)/1000=min⁡(355(1653),1.2(355)(1458))/1000=586.815 kN mM_c=\min(p_yS_x,1.2p_yZ_x)/1000=\min(355(1653),1.2(355)(1458))/1000=586.815\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
M/Mc=175/586.815=0.29822M/M_c=175/586.815=0.29822

PASS

Even the maximum shear is below 0.6Vc, so the low-shear moment resistance applies throughout.

Compact exam answer — key result lines
Av=457(9)=4113 mm2A_v=457(9)=4113\,\mathrm{mm^2}
Vc=pyAv3=355(4113)3(1000)=842.997788 kNV_c=\frac{p_yA_v}{\sqrt3}=\frac{355(4113)}{\sqrt3(1000)}=842.997788\,\mathrm{kN}
V=100 kN,V/Vc=0.118624,0.6Vc=505.798673 kNV=100\,\mathrm{kN},\quad V/V_c=0.118624,\quad0.6V_c=505.798673\,\mathrm{kN}
Mc=min⁡(pySx,1.2pyZx)/1000=min⁡(355(1653),1.2(355)(1458))/1000=586.815 kN mM_c=\min(p_yS_x,1.2p_yZ_x)/1000=\min(355(1653),1.2(355)(1458))/1000=586.815\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
M/Mc=175/586.815=0.29822M/M_c=175/586.815=0.29822

Even the maximum shear is below 0.6Vc, so the low-shear moment resistance applies throughout.

Lateral-torsional buckling [15 marks]

Source: LectureNotes/CON4334-Data File-20260730.pdf · p.3

For this restraint segment, take the absolute moments at its quarter, half and three-quarter points; divide by the largest absolute moment anywhere in the same segment. The stations belong to the segment, not necessarily to the whole beam. Apply the lower bound 0.44.

M2=131.25,M3=175,M4=131.25,Mmax=175(kN m)M_2=131.25,\quad M_3=175,\quad M_4=131.25,\quad M_{max}=175\quad(\mathrm{kN\,m})
mLT=max⁡[0.44,0.2+0.15∣131.25∣+0.5∣175∣+0.15∣131.25∣175]=0.925m_{LT}=\max\left[0.44,0.2+\frac{0.15|131.25|+0.5|175|+0.15|131.25|}{175}\right]=0.925

Use the stated normal-loading effective-length branch: LE equals the distance between effective lateral/torsional restraints. A restraint does not create a new vertical support. Class 1/2 gives βW = 1.

λ=LEry=700042=166.666667\lambda=\frac{L_E}{r_y}=\frac{7000}{42}=166.666667
v=[1+0.05(166.66666733.9)2]−1/4=0.8203v=\left[1+0.05\left(\frac{166.666667}{33.9}\right)^2\right]^{-1/4}=0.8203
λLT=uvλ=0.877(0.8203)(166.666667)=119.900517\lambda_{LT}=uv\lambda=0.877(0.8203)(166.666667)=119.900517
Source: LectureNotes/CON4334-Data File-20260730.pdf · p.5

Table 8.3, py = 355 N/mm² column; bracketing λLT rows 115 and 120. Interpolate in this column only.

pb=111+119.900517−115120−115(104−111)=104.139276 N/mm2p_b=111+\frac{119.900517-115}{120-115}(104-111)=104.139276\,\mathrm{N/mm^2}
Mb=pbSx/1000=104.139276(1653)/1000=172.142223 kN mM_b=p_bS_x/1000=104.139276(1653)/1000=172.142223\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
mLTMmax=0.925(175)=161.875 kN mm_{LT}M_{max}=0.925(175)=161.875\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
ηLT=161.875/172.142223=0.940356\eta_{LT}=161.875/172.142223=0.940356

PASS

Compact exam answer — key result lines
λLT=uvλ=0.877(0.8203)(166.666667)=119.900517\lambda_{LT}=uv\lambda=0.877(0.8203)(166.666667)=119.900517
pb=111+119.900517−115120−115(104−111)=104.139276 N/mm2p_b=111+\frac{119.900517-115}{120-115}(104-111)=104.139276\,\mathrm{N/mm^2}
Mb=pbSx/1000=104.139276(1653)/1000=172.142223 kN mM_b=p_bS_x/1000=104.139276(1653)/1000=172.142223\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
mLTMmax=0.925(175)=161.875 kN mm_{LT}M_{max}=0.925(175)=161.875\,\mathrm{kN\,m}
ηLT=161.875/172.142223=0.940356\eta_{LT}=161.875/172.142223=0.940356

PASS

Imposed-load deflection [3 marks]

Use imposed load only: 9 kN/m over the whole span. E = 205,000 N/mm². Convert I from cm⁴ to mm⁴ by multiplying by 10,000; use span in mm. 1 kN/m is numerically 1 N/mm.

δ=5qL4384EI=5(9)(7000)4384(205000)(33320)(10000)=4.119216 mm\delta=\frac{5qL^4}{384EI}=\frac{5(9)(7000)^4}{384(205000)(33320)(10000)}=4.119216\,\mathrm{mm}
δlim=L/360=7000/360=19.444444 mm\delta_{lim}=L/360=7000/360=19.444444\,\mathrm{mm}

PASS

Compact exam answer — key result lines
δ=5qL4384EI=5(9)(7000)4384(205000)(33320)(10000)=4.119216 mm\delta=\frac{5qL^4}{384EI}=\frac{5(9)(7000)^4}{384(205000)(33320)(10000)}=4.119216\,\mathrm{mm}
δlim=L/360=7000/360=19.444444 mm\delta_{lim}=L/360=7000/360=19.444444\,\mathrm{mm}

PASS

Sketch LTB deformation [4 marks]

Teaching sketch: sideways compression-flange movement, twist and a midspan brace to a stable system.
Teaching sketch: sideways compression-flange movement, twist and a midspan brace to a stable system. Full-size image

LTB couples lateral movement of the compression flange with twisting of the section. An effective brace restrains that flange and twist through a load path to a stable system. For a positive-moment simple beam, the top flange is compressed. A midspan restraint splits the LTB length into two segments; it does not split the vertical-load beam into two simply supported beams. Recalculate the moment shape and mLT in each segment.

Compact exam answer — key result lines
Teaching sketch: sideways compression-flange movement, twist and a midspan brace to a stable system.
Teaching sketch: sideways compression-flange movement, twist and a midspan brace to a stable system. Full-size image

LTB couples lateral movement of the compression flange with twisting of the section. An effective brace restrains that flange and twist through a load path to a stable system. For a positive-moment simple beam, the top flange is compressed. A midspan restraint splits the LTB length into two segments; it does not split the vertical-load beam into two simply supported beams. Recalculate the moment shape and mLT in each segment.

Sketch a midspan restraint [2 marks]

Teaching sketch: sideways compression-flange movement, twist and a midspan brace to a stable system.
Teaching sketch: sideways compression-flange movement, twist and a midspan brace to a stable system. Full-size image

LTB couples lateral movement of the compression flange with twisting of the section. An effective brace restrains that flange and twist through a load path to a stable system. For a positive-moment simple beam, the top flange is compressed. A midspan restraint splits the LTB length into two segments; it does not split the vertical-load beam into two simply supported beams. Recalculate the moment shape and mLT in each segment.

Compact exam answer — key result lines
Teaching sketch: sideways compression-flange movement, twist and a midspan brace to a stable system.
Teaching sketch: sideways compression-flange movement, twist and a midspan brace to a stable system. Full-size image

LTB couples lateral movement of the compression flange with twisting of the section. An effective brace restrains that flange and twist through a load path to a stable system. For a positive-moment simple beam, the top flange is compressed. A midspan restraint splits the LTB length into two segments; it does not split the vertical-load beam into two simply supported beams. Recalculate the moment shape and mLT in each segment.

Reusable procedure and traps

  1. Separate ultimate resistance from imposed-load serviceability. Keep kN/m and mm-based formulas consistent.
  2. Establish the whole-beam reactions first. For each restraint segment use its own length, quarter-point moments and maximum moment.
  3. A high Mc does not prove LTB passes. Check mLT M ≤ Mb as well as the applicable section resistance.
  4. A smaller unrestrained length normally increases Mb, but its moment factor changes too; recalculate rather than scaling the old ratio.

Independent practice — invented variant

Invented variant: add a lateral brace at a quarter-span point without changing vertical supports or loads. Which calculations change?

Hint

Separate the vertical-load model from the lateral-restraint model.

Reveal answer

Reactions, SFD, BMD and vertical-load deflection remain unchanged in this ideal restraint model. Create new LTB segments, then recalculate each LE, quarter-station moments, mLT, λLT, pb and utilisation. The brace needs a stable load path and cannot be treated as a new vertical support.